Top Ten Best Baseball Players of All Time


The Contenders: Page 7

121 Jimmy Rollins

Champion. Best phillies shortstop even passing Larry Bowa. Now leads phillies in hits for all time. He won 6 gold gloves

122 Yadier Molina

Best catcher of all time. Should be in top 20.

Yadier Molina he should be in the top 5

144th ranking and 4 Golden gloves should be at least 20th ranking

Yea agree best throw to first ever

V 6 Comments
123 Felix Hernandez V 1 Comment
124 Evan Longoria

The rays were terrible until Longoria joined them

Baseball player one of the best when he retires he is going to be the best vote for hall of fame

Hof for sure, makes his team better instantly and awesome numbers. Top 70 for sure.

V 1 Comment
125 Miguel Sano V 3 Comments
126 Alex Gordon Alex Gordon Alexander Jonathan Gordon is an American professional baseball left fielder for the Kansas City Royals of Major League Baseball.

Alex Gordon dives a lot,he helps the royals a lot by doing that. He is also a great hitter!

127 Michael Young

He is way higher on the list

128 Greg Bird

Fly birdy fly

V 1 Comment
129 Eddie Cicotte

Blew the hall of fame for Shoeless Joe Jackson.

V 1 Comment
130 Starlin Castro

He is pretty good though I have to say I've seen a bunch of better people.

Fidel castro son

He's all the cubs got offensively

Would all cubs fans take a break. Billy Williams,Ferdie J. Maybe, but Castro NOT

V 4 Comments
131 Jim Rice

Jim Rice you are the powerful hitter and I think you will hit a home run!

Jim Rice should be at least 7th best at the lowest he is a great player I like him!

132 Raul Ibanez

He is outstanding, he has 20 homeruns so far and he's 41, we also only about half way through the season. If he keeps this up he could get at least 40 homeruns in the season.

He is too low, shall I remind you that in the ALCS Game 4, he got the name the Babe, because of his walk off homer that saved the Yanks, almost... Not to mention the years with the Phillies and Mariners.

Raul Ibanez is awesome! Made the Phillies good Pinch hitting for A-Rod in the 2012 ALCS Whamm Walk off homerun!

133 Joe Morgan

Awesome second baseman. Bill James said he was the best to play that position. - Jman2021

V 2 Comments
134 Stephen Strasburg V 2 Comments
135 Ryan Raburn V 2 Comments
136 Rod Carew

Is everyone insane? This guy was a hitting machine. Tony G before Tony G.

One of the great pure hitters of all time. He's a top 50 player easily.

This guy is way higher than many people on this list

115! That is a joke top 50 easy. Did a toddler make this list?

V 2 Comments
137 Jim Palmer

How is the best rookie of the year of2000

V 3 Comments
138 Ryan Zimmerman

He is not as good as he was in 2005-2013

139 Frank Thomas

He was one of the best hitters ever! He stepped it up against the best pitchers, too!

A total beast. The big hurt was disciplined, powerful(521 hr), and a nightmare for pitchers his entire career. Top five first baseman ever. This list is blowing my mind.

The best hitter never to do P.E.D.S. he didn't need to. He was huge in every way. His first eight year rank among the best ever!

140 Hank Greenberg

This list is pathetic, didn't include Hank. One of the best players of all time. He served in World War II, not once but twice. Came back and hit a home run without spring training. In less than 1400 games, set more records than you can count, some still stand. How many players can hit 4 consecutive homers, hit a a grand slam in the dark to win a pennant, have 11 multi homer games in a season, they had to build walls to keep him from breaking Babe Ruth's single season record? Check his career stats, almost mythical. No one thought to put him on this list?

For some reason he gets no respect. Rbi and home run machine. Second best Jewish ball player behind Koufax and deserves to be so much higher.

V 4 Comments
PSearch List

Recommended Lists

Related Lists

All Time Best Position Players in Baseball Best Soccer (Football) Players of All Time Best Basketball Players of All Time Best Hockey Players of All Time Best Real Madrid Players of All Time

List StatsUpdated 25 May 2017

8,000 votes
255 listings
9 years, 80 days old

Top Remixes (88)

1. Babe Ruth
2. Ty Cobb
3. Hank Aaron
1. Babe Ruth
2. Hank Aaron
3. Ted Williams
1. Babe Ruth
2. Willie Mays
3. Ted Williams

View All 88


Add Post

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.