Top Ten Best Baseball Players of All Time
Yes best player ever to play the game because he hit in the dead ball era and hit the ball with power to all fields. He would of had another 40 to 50 home-runs in the 1925 season if he was not suspended because he was having marriage problems with his first wife. Thank God his second wife helped him and he hit the record of 60 home runs in the 1927 season a record that stood until Roger Maris hit 61 in 1961 as a Yankee. Henry Aaron came to bat 2000 times more than the babe and if they did not walk Ruth so much he would of hit 800 or more home runs. He would of been a great manager as well but was never given the opportunity because of prejudice. He was as good as a pitcher as anyone in either league at the time in his career as a Boston Red Sox pitcher. He saved the game because of the 1919 Chicago White Sox scandal where people would of lost interest in the game if it were not for the Babe hitting home runs when others were not hitting them. He made the game our "NATIONAL PASTIME" ...more
Ruth, ah, Babe Ruth. The single greatest player of all time bar none. Number two and so forth really begin at number three at best. May's, Aaron, Mantle, Williams, etc. Very, very good players. Ask what any of them couldn't do? They couldn't pitch. Young, Alexander, Seaver, etc. Couldn't hit. RUTH did it ALL. That's right, he could do it all. How many players had three 20 win pitching seasons and lead the league in batting average and home runs LIFETIME? Yes players lost time to War time service, but RUTH, lost at bats because he was a pitcher for his early years. Take Clemons or Feller or Gibson and tell him "great job pitching, now become one of the greatest hitters, Lifetime Average, Home Runs, etc., not happening, ask Mays, Williams, Aaron, etc., stop hitting and win us 20 games as a pitcher. RUTH, BEST EVER ALL TIME, all who follow are good, only good.
This isn't even close. If you pick anyone else, you're just trying to be different and not going with the obvious answer. He was hitting more home runs than entire teams. hitting 60 Home runs in the 1920's would be like hitting well over 100 home runs today. it was unheard of. And really he still holds the record, as they played 10 fewer games in those days (152) and Maris didn't hit #61 till the 162nd game of the season. The only other players to hit 60 were all on steroids. He had a whopping 342 lifetime batting average routinely hit over 50 home runs, even had another year where he hit 59.. And on top of all that he was one of the greatest pitchers of all time. Even if he never picked up a bat, he'd be in the hall of fame as a pitcher. This isn't even a debate
This isn't even close. He's a career 342 hitter with 714 Home Runs. hit 60 home runs in a season, 59 in another, 54 2 other times. And this was when they played 152 games, not 162. That's why when Maris broke the record they didn't recognize it for years, because he had 10 more games to do it. And the 714 HR's, he wasn't even a starting hitter for his first 5 years in the league - He was a pitcher. And he was a phenomenal pitcher, one of the best in baseball. He had pitching records that stood for decades (might still have a couple). He lead Boston to championships, before NY. He'd be in the hall of fame even if he never picked up the bat. This isn't close at all. Choosing anyone else is just silly
Its hard to decide who is better but there all really amazing but based on overall it is about skills and athleticism. Willie Mays and Jackie Robinson were so fast for baseball players baseball does not take as much speed as some other sports but it takes speed too and Willie also has lots of strength and endurance. Athletes like Babe Ruth would naturally have more strength. Also willie mays was more athletic and he had the best skills. He is an amazing legend he could hit more home runs on a regular basis he could be a little better than babe ruth there both so good. Willie Mays had better hitting than pitching and better pitching than catching. He was really good for all of that. A record can always be broken in every 60 years however it is also about trying your best and passion for sports.
The best--could do it all. He wasn't just a home run hitter. Trout will be on this list in ten years. He is, by far, the best player of this generation.
Best all-around player of all time. Most others on this list aren't five tool players. Some are but most aren't. (I will say that Ruth was a great pitcher which might count as a sixth tool.) Willie was the best or nearly the best at each of the five tools. Mays was popular with teammates and acclaimed by all contemporaries. He rarely missed games, and he loved to entertain the fans. Willie Mays is in the top five of more statistical categories than anyone, career and single season, old school stats and modern stats. Mays had to play his home games in huge ballparks, Polo Grounds and then windy Candlestick. That made it harder to rack up home runs, and harder to play defense in those huge center fields. He played in a pitchers era. Mays lost two prime years to military service. If his Negro Leagues stats could be added to his MLB stats, his case would only be stronger.
To me, Mays was the best player to ever to put on a uniform. One fundamental mistake fans make is that they look solely at career stats and fail to look at context. Career stats only tell part of the story. Mays was clearly a better player than Aaron. Peers of both Aaron and Mays almost universally say that Mays was the better player. And actually Clemente was a better player than Aaron. Mays was a much better fielder and base runner than Aaron. Their hitting prowess is comparable. However, Willie had the disadvantage of 1) playing in the Polo Grounds; 2) playing at windy Candlestick Park; 3) being drafted for military service, interupting his career. If Mays had played his career in Milwaukee's County Stadium and in Atlanta and Aaron had played where Willie played most of their career hitting stats would be reversed (ie. Mays would have 755 HRs and Aaron would have 660 HRs).
I think Aaron should be above Willie Mays because Aaron was three times better than Mays. Of course, he never hit 50 homers in a season, but he had lots of 40 homer seasons. What's surprising is that even though Henry Aaron had more total bases than anyone else, he had a lower slugging percentage than guys like Mays, Hank Greenberg, and Ted Williams. While Babe Ruth was a great player, Aaron was the greatest hitter of all time. Because Ruth was a great hitter and a great pitcher, and Aaron was a great all-around player. If you take away all of his 755 home runs, he would still have 3,000 career hits because he had 3,771 hits in his career and you subtract the total number of home runs from that and he would have 3,016 hits in his career. He had a huge amount of doubles and he had nearly 100 triples in his career. Aaron had more power than Ruth and Mays. I'd say he would still have the home run record because I don't think Barry Bonds deserves it. When he was with the Pirates Bonds was ...more
Hammering Hank was great however because he hardly never hit more than 40 home runs a year none of the pitchers ever decided to walk him that much! The fact that he averaged 40 home runs a year for 15 years was amazing and hit 35 home runs for at least 5 of his 22 year career to go on and top Ruth all time home run record. He did this with death threats to his life and much prejudiced against him and he is to be commended for going on to beat the Babe. Arron came to bat more than 2000 more than Ruth however he is to be con-graduated because he never sustained any major injuries that sidelined him for part or all of any season compared to Mickey Mantle. Henry was also a better right fielder than Ruth and has his gold gloves to prove this. He deserves great respect and honor for his service to the game even after his playing days were over.
Hank had amazing instincts at all phases of the game; fielding, running & batting. Nonchalant, it looked like the game came second hand to him & he was confident, but never showed off or showed up a fellow ball player. After going through the process of breaking Ruth's home run record, he represents what sports should be and Hank Aaron should be taught to the youth of our country.
Aaron certainly has the numbers to back up his lofty status. But no where near the number 3 ranking. He played in very friendly hitter parks and was not as complete a player as some purport he was.
His bitter attitude after retiring towards the younger players and obvious racist overtones tarnished his image.
I can't argue Babe Ruth as #1 for the fact that his pitching was as elite as his hitting. As far as #2 that's tougher. Hank Aaron #3 no way, and don't get it twisted I love Hank Aaron. But you see there's an unrecognized stat that I can understand my generation (born '79) not knowing, but it disappoints me that our elders ignore this and don't ever mention it to younger generations! That is that Ted Williams stopped playing baseball and enlisted in the AirForce as a fighter pilot for 6 years in the prime of his baseball career. So as far as my logic tells me the question is who is #2. I have to put Mays & Williams as a tie as Williams was the greatest hitter EVER and if you were to modestly calculate what his stats would have been if he didn't miss 6 years he blows everyone away period bar none. Yet Mays was a greater fielder one of the best ever so it's hard for me to decipher which was better because I can only look at stats and a little film. It's up to unbiased knowledgeable ...more
Ted WiIlliams has the highest OBP ever. He would have had the best OBP season if not for a cheater named Barry Bonds. He would have beaten Ruth's home run record if he didn't go to WWII and the Korean War. He hit everything. He drew a ton of walks, only behind Bonds and two players who played a lot more than him. His rookie season was amazing. He lead the league in RBIs and extra base hits, came second in total bases and runs scored, and was up on the list in every other hitting category except for batting average. His 1940 season was also great. 1941 doesn't even have to be discussed. Every season after that was also great. He homered in his last at bat. All time great without a doubt. Incredible seasons. Incredible career. Williams was the greatest hitter of all time. He was also the greatest player.
If Ted did not serve in the USA AirForce as a fighter pilot for 6 years he would of hit 715 or more home runs to beat Ruth and maybe come close to the 800 home run mark. Henry would have had to play another year or so and hit another 50 home runs to top Ted if Williams did not serve in the US military for those 6 years. My dad the late Salvatore Blumette who made the Boston Red Sox as a starting pitcher in 1938 season told me Thomas Blumette, Sr. that if Ted Williams did not serve in the military he would of been the greatest home run hitter of all time. Ted is one of the greatest pure hitters the game as ever seen and he may be the last batter to play and bat 400 for the whole season. I do not believe this record will ever be broken!
Let me run through Ted's stats. Ted had one of the greatest rookie seasons of all time in 1939, with 31 home runs, a .327 average, and perhaps most impressively, a league best 145 RBIs. Ted Williams still gets criticism for his 1940 season, and I'm not sure why. He hit .344. In 1941 Ted had insane stats. 38 home runs, a .406 average, 145 walks, a.553 OBP, a 1.2+ OPS, and a .735 slugging percentage. In 1942 he won the triple crown, while hitting .356 with 39 homers. He served in the military from 1943-1945, and judging by his 1940's achievements, these would've been monster seasons. When he came back in 1946, all he did was hit .346, smacked 38 home runs, win the A.L. MVP, and lead his team to the World Series. Unfortunately he got injured. In 1947 he won the triple crown. In 1948 he hit .370. In 1949 he set the record for most consecutive games on base (89), hit .342, hammered 43 home runs, all while winning his 2nd MVP.
Throughout the 50s he was plagued by 2 more more years of ...more
Cobb is number 1 end of debate. Look at just about every offensive statistical category out there and this Tiger great retired atop or near the top of almost all of them when he retired. Who else can say that? Ruth? No. Bonds? No. Mays? No. Aaron? No. Rose? No. How many of these guys hit over.400? A. None. Cobb did it 3 different times. Cobb also retired near the top of the all time putouts & assists records for outfielders so he wasn't just a great hitter who couldn't play defense (ala Ted Williams). I don't know what the official "criteria or template" is to determine who the greatest player ever is-but there isn't a single player who excelled in more areas of the game than Ty Cobb.
Ty Cobb held almost every record aside from pitching. Batting average still stands, and most likely will stand way into the future. Stolen bases, no longer holds record but how long did he have it 40 yrs? How about slugging %, fielding, doubles, triples, hit for cycle, above all devotion to the game and team. Win at all costs, but did not cheat, whine or cry, just played hard. Did not have the benefit of modern tech on swing or body position, study of opponents pitching, game films, scouting reports, etc etc etc, Developed all on his own or just pure natural talent. Pete Rose has most hits, but at many more at bats than Ty. Ty was honest when he said now days he would hit less than 300, against modern pitching, because he was over 70 yrs old at the time, and at that age let Rose,Ruth Mayes,even A Rod try
Cobb is second to no one, let alone 3rd! Cobb only batted under.300 once and that was his first season! He stole home when he was 42 years old, Aaron was great but has become overrated in hindsight. Ruth was great but began the downfall of baseball being tactical, beginning of the crowd pleaser brand of ball/instead of talented base hit & steal players. Ty Cobb was and is the greatest... PERIOD.
Ty holds all the records except a few. If you leave his personal life out of the conservation and just judge him based on his stats he is easily hands down the best there ever was. None of us are perfect with our behaviors. there are plenty of big leaguers out there today who are much worse and I mean black and white and whatever. So back off of Ty and judge him on his playing ability.
Was the best. Played better than most on here while having ALS and not knowing until he finially started having severe muscle weakness and was only then diagnosed with the disease. Average life span with AlS is three years after diagnosis. Many people have it years before being diagnosed.
If Gehrig hadn't gotten sick and continued on his trajectory, he would have broken all of Ruth's records and would be considered the gold standard bearer of baseball. He did it all, played sick, hurt and in the shadow of Ruth but still made an indelible name for himself.
Will someone please look at Gehrig's 14 FULL consecutive seasons (25-38) and compare them to the BEST 14 seasons of any player keeping in mind that these years were basically his career contributions. The production of this player is staggering!
This guy is my all time favorite player he just will never quit in life not only was he a great hall of fame first baseman he was also a great teammate and a great courageous player with a positive attitude.
It is difficult to compare an outfielder like Mantle to an infielder or a pitcher or catcher but Mickey Mantle had great speed along with a strong arm in centre and terrorized both left and right handed pitchers with his power and average from both sides of the plate. The fact that he played in Yankee Stadium with its short fences doesn't factor into his homerun numbers due to the fact that he consistently hit tape measure home runs and still has three that have never been duplicated. He also hit under pressure in key playoff situations. Playing injured and compromised by his destructive lifestyle (that he admitted) throughout the second half of his career he was still one of the most dominant players in the game. He was a charismatic athlete and if you were old enough to remember his playing days then you know what I mean. The only other player who looked superhuman almost on a daily basis was Bo Jackson. I wish I had watched him play live because they say that you could hear the ...more
Mickey Mantle is easily in the top three list of the greatest baseball players of all time. Had he been healthy throughout his illustrious career, there is little doubt that he would have hit 800 or more home runs. He was unquestionably the most powerful home run hitter ever. The fastest player ever--especially to first base. He could do it all!
In my view, he was a better player than Mays and Aaron. If Mantle had played in a smaller ball park, like Ebbets Field or Wrigley Field, he likely would have hit 100 home runs in a season! Perhaps, close to 1,000 for his career!
The Mick was one of the fastest players during his time. He invented tape measure home runs by himself! He was constantly playing in pain. Everybody looked up too and respected him. If he didn't get injured he could of beat Roger Maris in the Home run race. Mickey was the silent hero of Don Larsens perfect game in 1956. He also won the triple crown in 1956. The best switch hitter there ever was. Mickey was the ultimate team player and carried the team on his back. The best thing about him is that he didn't use or need steroids to be such an amazing player. 7.
Mantle hit 536 Homeruns on gimpy legs. If Yankee Stadium hadn't had drain pipes to get cleats caught in that destroyed one of his knees, no telling what numbers he would have put up. He also had osteomyelitis, a painful bone disease. Still the fastest home to first in history. Great center fielder. His personal demons likely caused him to lose five years worth of baseball. Only year he was completely without injury he won the triple crown and would have won a second crown if Ted Williams hadn't hit.388. Definitely belongs in the top ten all time.
I could easily vote for Willie Mays, but no baseball player changed the game today, made everyone play together, not separated, Jackie Robinson earns everyone's respect. As a Giants fan I think Jackie Robinson should be the only athlete in the world to be idolized because of what he did, the pain he went through alone tells you that he's a revolutionary athlete. He's the grandfather of modern sports. Without him there would only be white players in Mlb and not just Mlb but in all other professional sports as well. Because he broke the color barrier, history has changed forever. Thank you Jackie Robinson.
Because he changed the game, he made the game possible for blacks, and players like Roberto Clemente, The kid, Albert pujols and Ichiro and other great players from South America, Mexico, even Asian and Japanese players believe they could play in the MLB. I honestly think he is the greatest for his sportsmanship for the game and especially breaking the color barrier of the MLB. Plus he was a great all around player.
No question that Robinson's impact on the game was and remains huge. But, as a player I don't see where the stats support Jackie being on the top 10. I admit though that Robinson transcends the norm and should be idolized for his phenomenal character that helped him persevere the ugliness of the times. Perhaps in today's game-without all the pressure placed on him, he would have been a number one contender.
This is a complete joke. Robinson deserves a high rank, but top 10? Gimme a break! If a sense of social justice/courage is driving selection (which seems to be the case), then JR should be #1. If it's baseball talent, there are dozens better. Rogers Hornsby should be in this slot or higher. Musial, Dimaggio, Wagner, Johnson, Frank Robinson, Joe Morgan, Yogi Berra, Jeter, Griffey Jr. and many others were better and more strategic players.
Think about this look at his numbers now and think he had five prime years taken away from him. There is no doubt about it he would have literally have had every record in the book hrs, rbi's, hits and maybe gold gloves. He also changed the way baseball was marketed the way magic and bird did in the nba he made baseball relevant and cool again. And forget bonds and everyone else he was the best player of his generation not to mention he just got the highest voting percentage in the history of the hall of fame what does that tell you.
If not for injuries he has over 800 home runs, 3300 base hits, and at least three more gold gloves. Losing 4 and 1/2 years to injury not including the time he missed in Seattle and still hit 630 home runs,.284 batting average, and over 1800 rbi's. That being said Ruth, Williams, Arron, Cobb, and Gehrig are still the greatest but Griffey is at least the six greatest of all time and anyone who knows baseball should agree.
And anyone who thinks using steroids doesn't make people a more dominant person that is just stupid and no users deserve a spot on this list.
I played with Junior as a kid and it was all natural. He was born to play ball. If not for the injuries we would all be talking about him before Willie, Hank and Mickey! Admit it. He could do it all. And his average only dropped a bit late in his career when the lower body and leg injuries took over. Junior and Thome are the only two this generation to crack 600 Homers steroid free. I know Pujols will do it but that only makes 3 in the last how many years?
In my opinion Jr. was one of the greatest pure athletes... Amazing at all aspects of the game...5 tool player... Respected by many of the games top tier players... Like Jeter he had an amazing presence off the field as well... Prettiest swing in baseball history; fluid, powerful, razor sharp... Unbelievably resilient... A kid favorite (which in my opinion makes a huge difference)... One of the most prolific hitters of all time... I could go on for days but you get the idea.
No doubt Walter Johnson was the better pitcher between himself & cy young. I have read probably 25 biographies of hall of famers, mostly notable hitters between 1880's - 1930's. All of them told of Walter Johnson & Christi Mathewson Not 1 mentioned how tough it was hitting off cy young. Plus the guy pitched nearly every other game, giving him more opportunities to win games. Just imagine how many games Walter could have won if he were not in a 3 or 4 man rotation.
The greatest pitcher ever, and remember pitching is 90% of the game. Don't get starstruck by the Babe's homers or Ty's hits. Johnson did more for his team than any other player. For an entire decade (1910-1919) he won 265 games, which was 34% of all the games won by the Senators. He won 417 total games as a Senator. No pitcher or ball player was more valuable to their team.
Walter Johnson was nicknamed the "Big Train" for his durability, and he is considered by many to be the fastest pitcher who ever lived. He retired as the all-time leader in strikeouts (with 3,509; his record got surpassed later on), and the all-time leader in shutouts (with 110). Johnson is also my favorite player of all-time.
Every way I have looked at his stats, he is by far the greatest pitcher of all time. He just kept doing it year after year. Batters of his time spoke of him as almost unhitable.
Wagner is by far greatest SS in history. Rogers Hornsby 2B Mike Schmidt 3B Gehrig 1B Johnny Bench C Mays Ruth T.Williams and Cobb Aaron too 5 OF.I think I juicer stats are a joke. Palmeiro had as much power as Mark Grace until he juiced up. Look at ARod's juiced years in Texas. Bonds and Sosa and McGuire looked like swollen up freaks as they juiced up for 5-10 years. All juicers should be on a separate record list and have asterisks. NONE should ever be in the HOF ESPECIALLY BONDS whose stats this last 10 years are ludicrous and bizarre and out of keeping with his first 10 years. He may be the original juicer. Look at the laughable list of bums who hit 45-50 HR a year in the juicer era. Leadoff hitter for the Orioles hit 51 HR...
The only players who should be above Wagner are Ruth and Gehrig. For Pujols to be above him is sacrilege, this list is a joke.
WAGNER: One of the greatest hitters of all time, on of the greatest fielding SS of all time, could pitch a few quality innings if needed. A true gentleman, an extremely positive presence in the clubhouse.
His career stats make you shake your head in awe. Greatest shortstop ever to play, one of the best ever. He came in second place tied with Babe Ruth, behind only Ty Cobb in the inaugural MLB hall of fame voting in 1936. 'enough said!
Wagner is better than most of the other players rated above him (like pujols, mantle and Gehrig) He was a great shortstop and those giant hands of his let him scoop up those balls like crazy.
The most balanced hitter of all time should not be stuck at number 13. The guy had the exact same amount of hits on the road as he did at home in his career. That is the definition of balance when it is used in this sense. A 24 time All Star (there were two years, the first two of his career, where he was elected twice because back at that point in baseball history there was a spring all star game and a fall all star game. This changed after his second year), a WW2 veteran (during his playing career), a congressional Medal of Honor recipient, and one of the nicest and most down to earth ball players that you could've met: this man deserves to be higher on this list.
All-around 5-tool Great. Holds record for All Star Games, along with Mays (or Aaron? ). Held National League rrcord for hits, 3630, until Rose. Mays, Clemente, Griffey are only ones probably better 5-tool players who hit for average but not as high lifetime as Stan's.331, which is in top 10 all time. Second all time in doubles. Has most triples of any player since about 1935, could run. RBI all time about # 6. Ruth, Williams, Gehrig, Wagner, Cobb, Mantle, Mays are among top hitters all time, but only Mays had the 5 tools also. I'll concede #1 and 2 to Ruth and Mays best all time players. Then I put Musial, with best lifetime stats of any other 5 tool player!
Wherever Ted Williams is ranked - and on this list it's 4th - you'd almost have to place his contemporary, Stan Musial, if not in a virtual tie, then immediately after him. Few experts following baseball during the time they played would've found it easy to say who was the better.
Disgusting how overlooked he is. Top 3 hitter of all time, multiple World Series wins, and the greatest MAN to ever play the sport. He's a top 5 player of all time, easily. Sorry liberals, but Robinson couldn't hold his jock strap. Neither could Griffey, Dimaggio, Johnson, or Wagner.
Even Lou Gehrig did not match the consistency of performance that Albert Pujols has demonstrated over his first 10 years in MLB. Albert has not benefitted from having the level of players around him that Babe Ruth and Lou Gehrig had. In his early years, Albert had Mcquire, Rollins and Edmonds. Currently he has Holliday, Ramus and Ludwick. These do not match up with the players Ruth and Gehrig had on thier teams,
Even Lou Gehrig did not match the consistency of performance that Albert Pujols has demonstrated over his first 10 years in MLB. Albert has not benefited from having the level of players around him that Babe Ruth and Lou Gehrig had. In his early years, Albert had Mcquire, Rollins and Edmonds. Currently he has Holliday, Ramus and Ludwick. These do not match up with the players Ruth and Gehrig had on their teams,
Albert's first 11 seasons in MLB is the best 11 year stretch in MLB history, that alone should put him in top 10. If it wasn't for that juicehead Bonds, Pujols would easily have 6 or 7 MVP awards. His accomplishments get overlooked because his era was tainted due to cheaters like bonds, sosa, a-rod, manny, etc. Also, the nicest human being I've ever met.
Albert is on performance enhancing medications. No questionn in my mind. You can always tell when they take the easy, non-chalant swing, and the ball goes out of the park. Wrist speed too. Don't kid your self; he keeps his weight under control, but he's on stuff. He wont be on any of my lists.
The ''KING'' of HITS! Yep. Charlie Hustle is the HITS KING! And I'll tell you what ... this MAN has more HITS than any other player in baseball history! There is NO OTHER MAN in the Majors to be in the 4,000 HITS CLUB, other than PETE ROSE and the Legendary -- TY COBB! Yep. That's it! And TY COBB was once named THE GREATEST BASEBALL PLAYER OF ALL TIME! So, yeah! IF Ty Cobb is the Greatest and if BIG PETE has more hits in his career than Ty Cobb ... well then ... if ya do the MATH correctly -- Wouldn't that put PETE ROSE on top of the Mountain? Yep. Me thinks so! So, yeah ... if they had a MOUNT RUSHMORE for Baseball ... Pete Rose belongs there! PERIOD. Remember, you can't win a game or a world series, without hitting that ball ... and Pete Rose always hit the ball -- Always! After all, he is the KING OF HITS -- Right? ... RIGHT?!?!
... 'enough SAID!
Who cares if he gambled at least he was a tough ball player and was not afraid to get his shoes dirty like the players now who are traded to different teams every couple of years. He deserves to be in the hall of fame not like cal Rippen jr who nobody even knows about or gives a hoot about. I know a lot about baseball and my statement is very true. I am not saying Pete rose should be first place but at least give 3 place or something like that.
Pete Rose should never gave been banned from baseball for life. Other players have done much more to damage the game then Rose and never been banned for LIFE. His sentence was the most disproportionate punishment in the history of baseball, with the exception of the Black Sox scandal.
Pete Rose belongs in the Hall. MLB is turning into the NCAA. They're the holier than thou. If you took all the players in the Hall of Fame out because of infractions that are a detriment to the game, there wouldn't be many left in the Hall.
Arguably the most consistent player of all time, not the greatest.
DiMaggio- 13? His 56 game hitting streak will never be broken. He played for 13 years with 3 MVP wins. Also, he made the All-Star game every year! He won the World Series 9 times with 10 pennants. He was one of the greatest fielders to play and he had more home runs than strikeouts. Furthermore, his hitting was phenomenal. He led the AL in home runs and RBI's twice, and was the AL batting champion 2 times. He even stood out outside of baseball. He married Marilyn Monroe, went to war, got shot in his wrist, and proceeded to make the All-Star game... again. He should not be 1 but somewhere in the top 5!
Joe DiMaggio would of had well over 500 to 600 home runs as a Yankee if he was not playing at the stadium that Ruth built with "Death Valley" in left center field which was 450 feet from home plate and a high wallthat players had to have the ball clear over to hit the home run. I heard Phil Rurrito the former Yankee shortstop tell us as he was a Yankee broadcaster for a long time that if DiMaggio did not have that death valley to face as a right handed hitter he would of hit 800 life time home runs!
I have watched and read old films and articles about Joe. When the Yankees use to have a score that is when Joe really shown.
He was good at coming through in the clutch situations. The Yankee Clipper is obviously one of the top ten greats of all time.
Joe DiMaggio 56 game hitting streak will never be broken! Its amazing that he was robbed of having at least 1 hits in what would of been his 57th game but after the hit streak ended then went on to hit safely in another 18 games.
He does not belong on this list. With all of the great baseball players over the past 100 some years who have put up ridiculous numbers without steroids he shouldn't even be in the top 200 in my mind. He was using steroids like crazy. At 40 years old his head was growing.. What does this tell you? Not only was he juicing but he was juicing like crazy. Sure he was good before steroids but 17th of all time good? Probably not so if that's your argument you need to reevaluate it some. You can't rank this man as the 17th best of all time because "He was good even before steroids! " Yes he was good.. But you can't rank him 17th without knowing how good he actually would've been and how age would have affected his muscles without a performance enhancing drug preserving and improving them. The best of all time have usually found ways of staying good and in some cases even getting better with age. My guess is Bonds saw a noticeable decline in his baseball playing ability, and so he started ...more
Lets look at his situation logically. Early in Barry's career, more specifically the late '80s - early '90s, he was hitting 40 home runs and stealing 40 bases a year... all while striking out less than 100 times per year. This was when he was at least 50 lbs lighter than his 2001 physique (I.e. pre-roids). People, we cannot discredit his athletic achievements solely on the fact that he doped. In the early 2000s, we saw his home run totals drastically rise and his stolen base numbers fall as he migrated to more of a pure power hitter. This man's strength was unreal (look no further than his home run vs. Troy Percival in the 2002 WS). He was one of the greatest players of all time.
The greatest hitter of the modern era, whether or not he used PEDs he demanded more respect than any hitter ever, no one was more dominant and even in his Pittsburgh days before his head grew and his balls shrunk he was still putting up unbelievable numbers of home runs, rbis, batting average, and stolen bases. Personally I grew up hating his guts and continue to strongly dislike the guy, and the decisions I believe he made, and did make but I'm not going to deny him what he truly is and that is the greatest hitter of all time.
Hand eye coordination is not the issue. Every Major league player must have that to get in. When you are stronger in the late innings due to steroids you hit with power when those who don't use them are physically tired and unable to get that punch on the bat. By the way there is no way to measurement for hand eye coordination just because you say it's the best is junk science. Hand eye coordination is smoke and mirrors. He cheated should never be on any list.
Game 7 of the World Series, or even if the future of the planet hangs in the balance.
You can choose any pitcher in their absolute prime.
This is the guy you choose, period.
If your life depended on the outcome of a baseball game, you would want Sandy Koufax to pitch for you.
Sandy was the most dominant pitcher over a five year period that at any other time in the game!
Wish I saw more of him. Arguably the greatest stretch of pitching in the history of baseball.
Clemente was an all around player, 5 tool player, one of the best ever, period. It amazes me when "experts" avoid to mention this amazing player in whatever list is make. Best Right Fielder to ever lived, best arm that ever played the game, .317 career, 1305 RBI, 3000 hits, 12 GG (1 of 2 player), 15 All Star, 4 Batting Champs! (1 of 2 player), 2 WS, Nl MVP, WS MVP 1971. He was 37 years old when he played his last game (he still had some) , died at 38. He really was not a 5 tool player, he indeed was a 6 tool player, when we add his humanitarian spirit. I've never seen Clemente over Robinson in a list, well.. just compare their numbers and try to explain why is that so (not taking anything away from Jackie, one of the greats), but it makes no sense when some people even mention A (juiced) Rodriguez over THE GREAT Roberto Clemente, I understand to have Willie Mays over Clemente, but not many more players. #retire21.
To play baseball you need a glove. Roberto Clemente has 12 gold gloves, most for an outfielder. Simply the Great one in the outfield. To play baseball you need a bat. Roberto Clemente has 3,000 hits because a tragedy ended his career early. He is the first of that great 3,000 club that every baseball player wants to be in. All time.317 batting average, including 4 batting titles and two of them with.351 and.357 average. Not to mention 12 All Star games, 1966 NL MVP, 1971 World Series MVP, two World Series Championships. His 21 need to be the second number to be retired in the entire MLB. Robinson & Clemente. Roberto Clemente live Great, play Great and died Great. Roberto Clemente is simple, the GREATEST ONE in Baseball...
Roberto Clemente was a pioneering Latin & Black
Player. He was a 5 tool player who played in an era when both Latin & Black players wete routinely discriminated against. The Hallmark of Greatness
In MLB are 3000 hits & Clemente finished with exactly 3000. In truth, he was an even Hreater Man than he was a ball player as exemplified by his death while attempting to deliver relief supplies to earthquake stricken Nicuragua. And did I mention that he had arguably, the Greatest Arm of All Time!
He was an awesome baseball player he lived in Puerto Rico. Then he got a letter saying that he was invited him to America to play baseball. His team was in last place and Roberto dove caught and hit so hard. He is the one that led his team to the national team championship. He went back to his home in Puerto Rico. He heard about an earthquake and set of to sentrel America in the middle of the flight the engines failed and he died.
Maddux was incredible considering he didn't throw more than 90mph. Revolutionized pitching with his multitude of pitches and grips and finger pressure. Great fielder, great numbers, great teams!
Hall of Fame - YES. Top 25 - YES
I think Cy Young invented this award for Maddux. He certainly won his share. Pitched like David Copperfield, now you see it, now you don't. Great competitor.
If your gunna put Greg Maddux on this list you have to put tom glavin on this list.. They wer the best braves pitchers and maybe the best pitchers of all time... And yes I'm a braves fan
Best pitcher of my generation. Proved its all about location. Not power
The Derek Jeter of the West Coast as far as being a person. Great hitter. Never played with a winner but was a winner.
He is good but his son not so good on the Padres one of about 5 or less retired #s
Even a better person as he was a hitter rip mr padre
The greatest pure hitter to play the game
I'm a Yankee fan all my life. Jeter is a winner. But he is not even close to being the best Yankee. He wasn't even the best shortstop of his era or 2nd best. He had decent range not great. He had an accurate but so-so arm. For a 6'3 guy had little power. But he had all the intangibles and played the game intelligently. Incredibly hard worker and as humble a superstar as ever. He played in NY which helped his star power and got 5 rings because he was an integral part of some GREAT teams. Hall of Fame - NO DOUBT. Best Yankee ever - NO WAY. Top 25 players all-time - BIG ARGUMENT.
Derek Jeter is the best baseball player because he has a terrific swing, he also has a amazing fielding and never gives up and gives it his all. I bet you he would die for baseball because that is where his heart is just placed. So he is the guy I look up to, so that's why I voted for the number one base ball player, Derek Jeter.
Derek Jeter Should be on this list he is probobaly the best all around player that has ever lived. He could make plays and hit like no other. Jeter had stellar play and it was all through out his career. No one else has performed quite like Jeter he was quite astonishing to watch.
One of the greatest shortstops of all time as well as one of the greatest Yankees of all time. It will be interesting to see how much he helps the young players carry on the Yankee tradition as Yogi Berra helped him when he was young and coming up.
Satchel Paige is the greatest pitcher of all time PERIOD! Remember the negro league was competitive, and he dominated players like Robinson, Campanella, and Others. Mickey Mantle said that Paige was the best pitcher he ever faced. I'd like to see the pitchers above him on this list pitch at age 50.
Paige is a genuine legend! Played ball 12 months a year. Was an MLB "rookie" in his 40's and dominated batters effortlessly.
Had the fastest fastball ever 3rd black person elected into the hall of fame
I've read a book about him it's called king of the mound it's a good book
The ''KING'' of Stolen Bases ... fast ... faster ... fassstest ... as fasssst as LIGHTNING!
And a pitchers WORST NIGHTMARE!
IF ya walk him or if he hits the ball -- that's it!
He's GOING TO SCORE! And there is absolutely NOTHING that you can do about it! He WILL score! After all, Rickey Henderson was also the KING OF ''RUNS'' and most folks, don't know 'that' little statistical figure! Yep. He's got more RUNS than any other player in history! And ya can't win a game or a world series without RUNS ... and over-all this man was a super human ATHLETE ... very well balances player ... EXPLOSIVE SPEED and POWER ... over-all he was a solid and complete player both offensively and defensively ... on a bad day, he was still ABOVE AVERAGE over-all ... and if he got to 1st Base ... he would steal 2nd Base ... and then he would steal 3rd Base ... and then he would SCORE in a RUN ... and don't be surprised if he tried to steal home plate ... because that is what he did for a living ... ...more
THE best leadoff man in history. There will be a player(s) who eventually break the HR record by Bonds, all- time hits by Rose, and maybe even the 56 game hitting streak by Dimaggio. But no one will ever come close to the stolen base record. Turning a single or walk into a double and into scoring position must have driven opposing managers crazy. He made pitchers focus on him when on base, which was a complete distraction from the what the pitchers main focus should have been...the hitter. Easily top 5 all-time.
"#32" Are you kidding? Few on the list could single handily affect the outcome of a ballgame more than RICKEY. Like Cobb and Mays, Rickey rattle pitchers and fielders with his base running. I witnessed him tag up from second on a fly in front of the centterfielder scoring with out breaking stride. He stole more and scored more than anyone in history. No knock on Ruth,Aaron,Musial,Gehrig, Mantle etc, but these greats could be neutralized by a walk. With Rickey, Cobb or Mays not so. Rickey top 5 hands down!
Deserves to be higher, obviously he is the stolen base king and always will be, but this shouldn't distract from his outstanding OBP, OPS and Runs, and a great defender, something not taken into account much on these lists. Plus played in the modern era where pitching was consistently good, not to mention he had to stand out in an era in which players were unnaturally athletic.
When people think of great baseball players catcher doesn't usually come to mind first. It should. I am going to argue that it's the hardest position to play well. And bench played it well. He defiantly should be top 15 because he is that good. Also catcher is my favorite position in baseball.
Johnny Bench should be above Mickey Mantle. Mantle was great, but Johnny Bench was not only a good hitter, he was likely the best catcher of all time. He was a leader and influenced other players in a very positive way.
Greatest catcher to ever play the game hit for power and ave.Awesome golfer tooBest team ever fielded bench rose conception Morgan Perez Griffey senior foster and Geronimo with gullet on the mound BIG RED MACHINE.
Strongest, Smartest Catcher of all-time. I still remember when he caught a fast ball bare handed in a major league game.
Listen to player/broadcasters from that era... They speak in complete awe of this man... Fierce competitor... One of the greatest clutch World Series pitchers of all time... It is a joke that he is so low on this list behind some guys who aren't or weren't even the best of their era.. Never mind all time... I want to win a game... Bob Gibson is my starter... Saw him pitch three or four times at Shea stadium... You knew the game was going to be over in about two hours or less... I could list stats but it was the intangibles that made him one of the greatest... No batter wanted to face him
Starting a new team today, only one pitcher I would select before Gibson, that's Koufax
The Black Babe Ruth is just what it sounds like. Hits homers even off of Paige
Gibbywas great probably top five pitchers all time he could hit too.