Top Ten Best Baseball Players of All Time


The Contenders: Page 8

141 Frank Thomas

He was one of the best hitters ever! He stepped it up against the best pitchers, too!

A total beast. The big hurt was disciplined, powerful(521 hr), and a nightmare for pitchers his entire career. Top five first baseman ever. This list is blowing my mind.

The best hitter never to do P.E.D.S. he didn't need to. He was huge in every way. His first eight year rank among the best ever!

142 Kirby Puckett

Top 60 easy. Was taken from his family and fans far to soon. I think he would have had as many hits as the great wade Boggs.

Kirby Puckett is a great baseball player he played well he should at least be at 50 or below

V 2 Comments
143 Hank Greenberg

This list is pathetic, didn't include Hank. One of the best players of all time. He served in World War II, not once but twice. Came back and hit a home run without spring training. In less than 1400 games, set more records than you can count, some still stand. How many players can hit 4 consecutive homers, hit a a grand slam in the dark to win a pennant, have 11 multi homer games in a season, they had to build walls to keep him from breaking Babe Ruth's single season record? Check his career stats, almost mythical. No one thought to put him on this list?

For some reason he gets no respect. Rbi and home run machine. Second best Jewish ball player behind Koufax and deserves to be so much higher.

V 4 Comments
144 Catfish Hunter

He threw a perfect game against the twins

I think he was my couisn

Way higher

145 Whitey Ford

Still not sure how you made this list, you apparently don't know baseball. Give me a break

Why do you have WHITY FORD below #100 he should be in the top 20at least

V 3 Comments
146 John Lackey John Lackey John Derran Lackey is an American professional baseball starting pitcher for the Chicago Cubs of Major League Baseball.

John lackey he is a very good player because his pitches are very good

V 1 Comment
147 Melky Cabrera

This guy is a cheater

He has a great ave
Amzing amount of hits
Come on!

148 Brandon Crawford

Great fielder and hitter!

149 Madison Bumgarner

VERY good pitcher, could easily make top 10 pitchers of 2015-2014 and I'm a Royals fan

V 2 Comments
150 Jeff Bagwell

It was unfair for him to play baseball because the only reason he got to play was because he was the greatest NBA player and there were plenty of farm league players that could of took his place that were serious about baseball - Sabbath

151 Everth Cabrera
152 Joc Pederson V 2 Comments
153 Willie Randolph V 1 Comment
154 Jason Varitek
155 Ivan Rodriguez

Greatest ranger of all time a great catcher and I'm a braves fan

156 Dale Murphy


157 Roger Clemens

Roger Clemens cheated move him off - mrwp111216

158 Tim Lincecum

Your high if you think he'll get to 300 wins

He will get 300 wins easily

159 Mark McGwire

This is mark McGwire he should be 100

V 1 Comment
160 Joe McGinnity

Pitcher: Won both ends of doubleheaders 3 times in one month August 1903, considered the most impossible sports record to beat. - johndumas

PSearch List

Recommended Lists

Related Lists

All Time Best Position Players in Baseball Best Soccer (Football) Players of All Time Best Basketball Players of All Time Best Hockey Players of All Time Best Real Madrid Players of All Time

List Stats

8,000 votes
256 listings
9 years, 263 days old

Top Remixes (90)

1. Babe Ruth
2. Ty Cobb
3. Walter Johnson
1. Babe Ruth
2. Ty Cobb
3. Hank Aaron
1. Babe Ruth
2. Hank Aaron
3. Ted Williams

View All 90


Add Post

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.