Greatest AFL Players Ever

The Contenders: Page 5

81 Ed Lower
82 Robbie Gray

Has always had rare and freakish talent. Since his injury however he has become a better all round player and is now one of the best and most consistent in the AFL.

I think he should be at least in the top 50

He is a legend

Absolute freak. even being spoken about in the top 5-10 players in the league... he's still underrated.

V 1 Comment
83 Tony Shaw
84 Luke Hodge

If achievement means anything Hodgy should be number 1. Who else has played in 4 winning Grand Finals, captaining 3, and winning 2 Norm Smiths for best Player in a girlfriend.? Hodgy is the leader and inspiration of the most successful club of the modern era deserves a bit better than 95..For results he should be number 1..

Ruthless the best captain I've ever seen play the game and I go for west coast

Never, ever lets his side down. Just about to become a 4 time premiership captain. The greatest leader of all time.

You put him in the 150s how dare you

V 3 Comments
85 Jim Stynes

One of the best. Can't believe he's been forgotten on this whole list.

Not growing up with the game what a great player

V 1 Comment
86 Lenny Hayes

Hayes DEFINITELY should be in the top ten. Better than Ablett, other Ablett, Judd and God damn Carey.

Bravest player of all. Also so agile. Best side step. Top ten for Lenny for sure

Everybody loves lenny

What a gun
Norm Smith medallist
Probably should've got a browlow

V 3 Comments
87 Tom Lamb
88 Jamie Elliott

Jamie Elliot is an absolute gun. He is one of the best marks in the competition and kicks plenty of goals as a small forward. Silent but deadly Elliot should be in the top 50 at least

V 3 Comments
89 Daniel Motlop

Motlop shouldn't be on this list, he was skillful and was a good forward when he wanted to be Kane cornes should be here a unrecognized work horse and legend of the port Adelaide football club

V 1 Comment
90 Majak Daw V 4 Comments
91 Kurt Tippett

Kurt Tippett will seriously be it soon such a great player strong, quick, tall, takes contested marks, good at ground level 10 times better then tex walker walker anit that good though tippo is better by far.

V 4 Comments
92 Haydn Bunton V 1 Comment
93 Jobe Watson

Should be ranked far higher up he is a huge player of the game and a massive asset to the club

Brownlow medal winner in 2012 and good player

Are you guys serious? Jobe Watson below Tom Swift? Really? Watson is a champion. Great captain, legend.

Great player to low for him

V 4 Comments
94 Peter Matera

Never seen a player who could paddle the ball out in front and be in complete control, like Peter Matera could. Anyone who saw him play will attest that on his day he was almost unbeatable.

Not only had blistering pace but the ability to kick long and accurate at blistering pace. Best goal kicking wingman ever, built like a racehorse.

Yes a very underrated player, I know, because he killed Geelong in one of the 90's premierships

He could play at any time in afl history, and still be a champion.

V 2 Comments
95 Scott Pendlebury Scott Pendlebury Scott Pendlebury is a professional Australian rules football player and current captain of the Collingwood Football Club in the Australian Football League.

He's a freak he's a ball magnet when Ryan Crowley tags him he still gets 30 disposals!

He is the captain and one of the best players in the afl.

He passes to team mates when not looking you freak

Best player ever.

V 9 Comments
96 Doug Hawkins

Amazing skills on both sides of his body

The best winger ever

Truly amazing!


97 Dane Rampe V 2 Comments
98 Dick Reynolds

Best player for the Essendon Football Club ever!

Full name: had a big, see above for the rest

Should br top 10.legend

Triple Brownlow medallist, number 1 in the all time Essendon list

99 Richard Tambling

Greatest player I've ever seen. Absolutely rocked the little league

100 Tom Swift

I am a mad eagles supporter but he was bad

You can't be serious...I'm an Eagles man and this guy was a spud at AFL level, had a good run in the WAFL but not much more than that.

V 2 Comments
PSearch List

Recommended Lists

Related Lists

Most Overrated AFL Players Greatest AFL Players of the 2000s Best AFL Players of 2012 Most Annoying AFL Players Ever Best AFL Players of 2010

List Stats

4,000 votes
182 listings
10 years, 3 days old

Top Remixes (31)

1. Gary Ablett
2. Gary Ablett Sr.
3. Leigh Matthews
1. Gary Ablett
2. Gary Ablett Sr.
3. Bobby Skilton
1. Gary Ablett
2. Dean Cox
3. NIck Maxwell

View All 31


Add Post

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.