Worst My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic Episodesrainbowdashrules
The Top Ten
I absolutely loathed this episode. Easily my least favorite of season 2. Mysterious Mare Do Well was bad, don't get me wrong, but this was beyond aggravating. Don't get me started with Angel abusing Fluttershy. At one point she kicks her out of her own house! Almost all of the background ponies here are turned into complete jerks! Fluttershy loses all logic while she's in assertive mode in the second part and the first few minutes of the third part. At one point she kicks the garbage wagons, getting the two ponies covered in trash, instead of flying over them! But the absolute worst part was when Fluttershy completely chews out two of her closet friends, Rarity and Pinkie Pie, verbally! Then, they just forgive her and put the blame on Iron Will instead! This was irritating to watch! UGH! Only season 5's What About Discord is worse than this. I am never watching this episode again. - TexasBro93
OH MY GOSH! WHERE DO I BEGIN WITH THIS AWFUL EPISODE! What kind of bossy pet is Angel? Poor Flutter shy gets the ingredients at the store, everyone was an idiot and boom! She makes it with no cherry! NO CHERRY? Angel calm down it is just a stupid cherry! There is no reason for you to beat her up and make her leave her house! Then comes Iron Will... The ugliest snob ever. Turning nice personality ponies into BAD BAD IDIOTS! After, she goes around insulting everyone, including Pinkie and Rarity! The worst part is she insults and yells at them. OH. MY. GOSH. THIS. IS. THE. WORST. PART. EVER! Flutter shy realizes she is the monster. Oh don't be sad Flutter shy, it's not your fault, it's Iron Will's. Who agrees with me that this is a horrible episode?
Putting your hoof down is the most mean-spirited episode. First Fluttershy gets abused by angel bunny, and he gets no punishment. The market ponies are also cruel, and when Fluttershy can't get a cherry angel throws her out of her house. Then we meet Iron will who gives her bad advice about how to deal with being a pushover. The worst part is when Fluttershy tells Rarity and Pinkie that their life's are pointless. There is nothing positive about this episode, is even worse than The mysterious mare do well for being more cruel and have nothing funny or enjoyable about it.
Terrible episode - ElSherlock
Am I the only one that doesn't mind how rude Rainbow Dash was at the beginning of the episode, or how mean spirited it was to Rainbow Dash later on? I don't dislike this episode for being man spirited or anything, I dislike it because the episode is BORING. Seriously, the fact that it is so boring, and nothing happens should be the reason why this episode gets hated, not for being "mean spirited". - scienceLover10
This episode is just a 22 minute fight to see who can be the most unlikable. I wasn't rooting for anybody by the end! Yeah, some of Rainbow's pranks were very mean-spirited (I'm looking at you, brick sandwich), but others like the sewing machine cake were harmless and funny, but everyone reacted just as negatively, which makes them look uptight and petty.
The townsfolk took it REALLY far in response. I mean, making someone think they made an entire town sick, possibly without a known cure? So you'd think I'd end up feeling sorry for Rainbow? But she continues to try and justify the prank by saying "it was supposed to be funny" until literally a second before the town reveal they were pranking her.
The entire ending just screamed "Status Quo Is God" cliche with that forced laughter from everyone, and I can't believe how patronizing Rainbow's apology scene felt, even for a kids' show. I don't know if the writers think Rainbow is a bit dense or the ...more
Honestly, this episode deserves more hate than the Starlight episodes, and this is coming from a Starlight defender. Yep, you can get angry at me all you want, but this was one of the worst written episodes in the whole series. They butchered pretty much everyone's character here, Rainbow Dash's pranks were mostly mean-spirited, and worst of all, Rarity actually encouraged Rainbow Dash to put more effort into her pranks instead of just stopping. Even the pranks I thought were actually funny weren't funny to Rarity or Applejack, apparently. Oh! And don't even get me started about the opening where Rainbow Dash completely forgot that Fluttershy is sensitive to pranks. Sorry zombie fans, the zombie apocalypse scene may have been fun for a while, but it gets old quickly. This episode belonged in season 1.
Do you like Rainbow Dash? Well this episode punishes you for it
So, I'm supposed to dislike Rainbow Dash for bragging a little because she saved someone's life? What!? Cause that's apparently what the writers think I should feel. Rainbow Dash was just punished by her closest friends for no good reason, and the only thing I can feel throughout this episode is pity and rage. I feel bad for Rainbow Dash, and am angry at the writers for thinking this was a good idea. This and 28 Pranks Later are without a doubt the most revolting, mean spirited, piles of garbage the writers have ever created.
OK- after rethinking things, here's what I think:
This episode is terrible because it's completely mean-spirited, and it's a pathetic attempt to ruin the fan-favorite that is Rainbow Dash. Here's what should have been done:
-Mare-Do-Well should have been some other heroic pony on the scene that tries to take Dash's spot as the town's biggest hero.
-The Mane Six should have shut up, because when you save someone's life, you have every right to brag. You've earned it. It's not like a walk-off homer in the bottom of the ninth. In this case, you can completely say truthfully," If it weren't for me, this person would be dead."
-If Rainbow Dash was feeling as depressed as she was, it should NOT be at the hands of her own friends.
-Twilight should have sat down, kept calm, and TALKED it out with Rainbow Dash.
Here's what The Mane 6 did:
-Bragged about themselves like hypocrites
-Nearly got Rainbow Dash killed
I honestly done see where people got party of one, fall weather friends, Sweet and Elite, Too Many Pinkie Pies, Magical Mystery Cure, and May the Best Pet Win from, those episodes are truly amazing and build upon characters. They are written accurately and make sense with the show! On the other hand... The Mysterious Mare Do Well is awful and stupid. Nothing makes sense and everyone is horrible here, they forced rainbow dash to learn the lesson that she didn't even really need to learn in the first place. A story with a narrative like this should have been given to Rarity.
I don't really HATE this one. It isn't good, it's a little bad, but it's not AWFUL, like SpongeBob's "One Coarse Meal", Fairly Oddparents'
"Fairly Odd-Pet", Sanjay and Craig's "Fart Baby", or Family Guy's "Screams of Silence".
The humor is pretty good, but a little short on timing, everything else is average, but to put it all on Rainbow Dash is just unfair. This episode got its priorities mixed up. Rainbow Dash should be able to get a little arrogant if she wants to; it's who she is, and she's got every right to do it, considering she's saved a
crud-ton of lives. The other Mane 6 should have sat down, stayed calm, and had a talk, and not upstage her to the point where everyone forgets about her and she gets depressed. Instead, they almost get her KILLED to try and teach her a lesson that she doesn't need, they brag about themselves (which wasn't revealed to be them yet) when Rainbow's clearly upset, and they make HER seem like the bad person here. I don't hate this one, but ...more
The design they made for older Spike in this episode is horrendous! Nor does it make any sense because he's supposed to be younger than Smolder in the show. Yet here they made him suddenly for no apparent reason look like he aged over twice her post time skip age in the future!? - FireMarshallBillBurns
Twilight's new design is laughably bad. It's basically just a re-color of Celestia.
Since the entire final season beforehand has given Twilight the biggest role in Equestria that makes her worry so much, you'd think it'd all go logically well to see how it all makes sense now, right? Well, if you ask me, you'd be wrong. Instead of spreading all of what's revealed here from the beginning of the season, we're given a bunch of unnecessary SHOEHORNS worth of plot points put in out of nowhere at the VERY LAST SECOND! Everything wrong with this catastrophic disaster of a series finale feels so rushed that apparently no one had time to think, “Hey, maybe we should do an entire rewrite on the finale itself... or on the final season as a whole! ”
I'll just say: Worst Cartoon Finale EVER! - TylertheTitan
I Have No Idea Why Dragon Quest Isn't Number One, honestly Who's Going To Sit Through This Monstrosity Again? First Of All The Plot Is Predictable Spike Is Obviously Going To Return To Ponyville, Second Fluttershy Doesn't Want To Pay Back Rainbow Dash, So She Kicks Her On The Floor And Leaves Without Mercy, Third, The Dragons Are All Stereotypical Teenage Bullies, That's Quite Offensive, Fourth "The Fight Scene" When Twilight, Rainbow Dash, And Rarity Reveal Themselves Ready To Defend Spike and Peewee, It's Like "Oh My Gosh! The Best Flyer, The Best Magical Unicorn, And The Drama Queen, Are About To Fight Three Guys Who Were Outsmarted By Three Baby Phoenixes" But No Spike Just Said "RUN AWAY" And That's all It Took For Them To Do That! " SERIOUSLY!?! They Could Have Taken Them Easily!, Again The Show Judges Them Based On Their Appearance, Again Stereotypical and Offensive, This Episode Ends With a Cliche Moral And Sad Fans Who Will Never Watch This Episode Again, It's Worse Then ...more
Three quotes can show how horrendous this episode is...
"'I don't act like other dragons? '"
"'Oh, not even close.'"
"'But why would you want to, Spike? '"
1) The main six show no respect for Spike and are in the right 2) "All dragons are bad, all ponies are good"
3) Rainbow Dash gets beaten up by Fluttershy 4) Flanderization 5) "One group represents a whole" 6) "Dragons are too rare to study" 7) Cruelty to Spike 8) Filler 9) Predictable Plot 10) "Boys<Girls" "Teenagers<Adults"
Cringe-Inducing Audio: 0
Cringe-Inducing Visuals: 0
Lackluster Writing: 6
Disturbing Content (Out of Place): 2
Unnecessary Cruelty: 5
Rancid Morals: 4
Low Production Values: 0
Unfortunate Implications: 10
Character Derailment: 9
Animated Atrocity Points: 42/100
How is this NOT the most hated episode of My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic?!
My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic May Be Targeted For Girls, So It Makes Sense For The Show To 6 Strong Female Leads as The Main Characters.
However, That Doesn't Mean The Show Should Completely Downgrade Every Male Character, To Be Portrayed as An Idiot, Bully, or Unhelpful Background Character.
Garble and His Friends are No Acception, They Literally Represent Brute Jerky Adolescent Males Putting a Bad Influence on A Character Who's Gotten GOOD Advice From Females.
Even If Bronies Weren't A Thing, This STILL Wouldn't Be a Good Thing To Teach Little Girls Watching, If This Show Teaches Lessons About Harmony and Friendship, Shouldn't They Equalize BOTH Genders?
Okay before the intro in this episode Rainbow Dash was dragging Fluttershy by her tail and then Rainbow Dash was pushing her across the floor and pushing her out the door at her cottage which is the part I did not like. - andrewteel
Literally, Twilight has THE worst character development in Season 9, and this episode certainly doesn't help as she's literally a selfish idiot in every sense of the way throughout! - TylertheTitan
I really hate this episode, the only 2 reasons is Twilight making all those stupid creepy faces and her becoming a massively unholy cheating idiot!
Just the fact that some people would actually DEFEND Twilight's awful behavior in this episode sickens me.
I know I'm not the only one who wanted to see everyone beat the living crap out of Twilight at the end.
The implications of Scootaloo's parents being child neglecters really brings this episode to a huge low.
Like Stare Master and Make New Friends but Keep Discord, I find the Crusaders to be OOC here. - TylertheTitan
To be fair, this was actually pretty good. We finally get to know Scootaloo's parents.
This is an episode that knows what it wants to do, but it has absolutely no idea how to do it. It seems to want to teach two morals, and it fails miserably at both.
First, there's the moral that two wrongs don't make a right. Well, if that's the case, then why did Babs get off scot free for bullying the CMC? And don't say it was because she was being bullied back at home because 1) the CMC technically have the same excuse, and 2) Babs was shown to take things even further than DT or SS without their influence. Babs' background explains her actions, but it in no way excuses them, which is not a sentiment that the episode shares.
Then there's the moral that if someone is bullying you, you should tell someone about it instead of fight back. Okay, fair enough, but here's my question: what if that doesn't work? What if the adults don't believe you, thus leaving you helpless, or what if the bully decides to retaliate again because you were a snitch? Sometimes standing up to a ...more
A character that bullies likeable characters for a full episode
Finally, someone who hates this episode!
Babs seed made me so angry the first 20 minutes of the episode.
What was the moral of this episode again? Oh right, encourage someone to do something that makes them happy even if that something is making everyone else miserable. Also, Pinkie has never overreacted to this degree! She's never actually started to lose her color! This is so stupid and makes Pinkie look really selfish. The only saving grace this episode had was the scene where the main 6 minus Pinkie ask Maud where Pinkie went, but even then the episode is still the worst I can think of off the top of my head.
This episode deserves to be much higher on the list.
Solidified Pinkie Pie as the the worst pony of the season.
I'm pretty sure she has lost her color before, remember the Discord 2 parter?
One of my favorites why does everyone hate it?
Diamond tiara forsing the cmc to right bad things about there friends and threatening to embarrass them if they does make it a bad episodes
Those stupid writers can do better than this and that, can't they?
One if the best writers makes this abusive crap!? I despise this episode and needs to be hated. Diamond tiara ruined this episode. And I wish a pony with similar feelings was in the scene like they caused world war II.
This episode is just wrong. Seriously seriously wrong. The Mane 6 were acting like jackasses as a pathetic attempt to villify Trixie, not to mention they acted like hypocrites, (Hey, let's 1-up the show-off by being an even BIGGER show-off! :D). Also, Spike's constant fanboying in this episode gets really grating REALLY fast. This episode also introduced Snips and Snails, my most hated characters in the whole show, (Yes, I hate them more than Diamond Tiara, SUE ME! ). Finally, the ending where these two earn mustaches is so insulting it would fit better in a modern SpongeBob episode, not to mention sends out some highly unfortunate implications, (Hey kids, if you send a gigantic monster into town to attempt to destroy it, you get rewarded for it! )
I am honestly baffled how an episode this bad can even exist. BY FAR the show's worst episode.
Despite my bias, I really enjoy magician characters, I will agree that arrogance is annoying. However that wasn't the problem, the problem was that Applejack, Rarity and RD were doing the same exact thing. I was actually glad when Trixie humiliated them as it taught them a lesson. Also it was not her fault that the Ursa Minor attacked, it was Snips and Snails and their punishment was so stupid. Mustaches, what the heck? 1
At least I could relate to Fluttershy in Putting your Hoof Down. Also Mysterious Mare Do Well at least also had a good moral. Just it wasn't executed very well. Boast Busters however sucks in EVERY regard. Rarity, Appleajck and Rainbow Dash acted reprehensible. Instead of leaving Trixie's show, they heckled her and challenged her doing what they do best. At least the showoff Trixie managed to 1up the offensive showoffs. And Spike is just so annoying trying to get Twilight to do something when SHE CAN and Twilight isn't any better. She isn't doing something when she very well can and end this whole charade. It also ends with a stupid anticlimax and... ugh. The stupid dipspits Snips and Snails. I hate these 2 and I know lots of others do as well. I HATE THIS EPISODE SO MUCH!
The ponies attitudes were terrible in this episode, Trixie was just trying to put on a show, but NO the ponies still insulted her and she was just trying to do her job (Yes. The bragging was a BITT overboard, but we all have our moments)
This episode has got problems of it's own, first of all, I know Fluttershy has to be kind and care for animals, but even she would know VERY better to ask Celestia if she could borrow Philomena rather than KIDNAPPING HER! Not to forget, Philomena was CRUEL to pretend to be dying AND eventually "die" and suddenly just manifest, revealing that it was just a stupid stunt. Maybe it was to teach Fluttershy a lesson not steal, but it already KILLED the episode for me.
I don't hate any episodes or anything, but this one is really boring. I've watched it about 3 or 4 times and I still don't completely understand why this is even a thing.
We were just watching a sick bird no real storyline here
Well this episode is about Fluttershy so it is gonna be bad their so boring Fluttershy's episodes are about facing your fears or animals and that's it.
The baby designs were hideous, some scenes were actually creepy, making pinkie cry makes me want to punch them in the face, logic is thrown out the window in favor of saying screw that unicorns are OP, and most importantly, the lesson is said over and over again! Responsibility. Keep hammering it in, episode!
I HATED this episode. It was painful to watch. I mean, the babies were cute at first, but then they became annoying and even cruel. When they made Pinkie cry, I wanted to kick ther bottos. I was very disappointed in this episode.
The cakes making Pinkie cry is what ruined it... For me. I hate them. - TylertheTitan
The Princesses pretty much learned nothing from A Royal Problem. Their fighting just came off as even more petty and childish.
SPOILERS: This episode is ungodly derivative of Pinkie Apple Pie, A Royal Problem, Once Upon a Zeppelin, and Road to Friendship. (The writers, like I said are STILL out of ideas! )
(NOTE: I watched this just recently when it leaked online) - TylertheTitan
This episode just proves that making Twilight the new ruler of Equestria is a terrible idea.
I'm really sick of those facial expressions that are supposed to be "meme-worthy." They're so ugly that they don't even look like they belong in a show like this.
Ugh it was a coincidence that Twilight was actually right about Cadence. She was completely disrespectful to her brother and Cadence and she was so quick to judge, just because she was jealous that Cadence was getting married to her brother! THIS IS WHY I HATE TWILIGHT WITH A PASSION. AND WHY DID SHE HAVE TO TURN INTO AN ALICORN AT THE END OF THE SEASON MY GOD SHE IS THE WORST CHARACTER EVER
The concept of the finale was pretty nice, though I despised the fact that everyone around Twilight abandoned and ridiculed her all for the attention of a princess... Especially since she knows that Cadence is much more than just Shining Armor's girlfriend who wants the perfect wedding. Part 1 was meh, but Part 2 was pretty epic and I liked it.
They should have known better than to not believe Twilight after all they have been through with her. Rainbow is supposed to be the element of Loyalty, for crying out loud! Even if the rest of them weren't always shallow from the start of the episode, I'm pretty sure Rarity was the worst derailed of all since she was the only one who really swooned about the wedding being in Canterlot, she was the last to take off her dress when the other 5 ponies left to go fight the Changelings, and she hogged the flowers away from the other bridesmaids at the end of the episode.
I hate Shining Armour with a passion!
Worst episode of the show. This plot was done way better with Amending Fences! It is simply pointless in EVERY possible way. (Just goes to show Friendship Is Magic's crew/writers really HAVE run out of ideas after all) - TylertheTitan
The moral does not make up for this boring train wreck!
I'm seriously getting tired of Twilight out over every little thing! I seriously just want to slap her in the face multiple times and tell her to knock it off and get a hold of herself.
As much as I didn't like Sparkle's Seven, at least I can see why people enjoyed it. This episode, however, has nothing to enjoy. The story is boring and unoriginal, the cameos made by Moondancer and Derpy are just there to pander to the older fans, the humor with Twilight panicking is unfunny (as usual), and the message (while okay) feels rather forced. It just feels pointless!
You know it's going to be a bad episode if the title card doesn't sound like it's excited. Anyway, it's just another "Rainbow Dash is a moron" episode (at least she didn't put the students lives in danger this time). And if that weren't enough, we also get to see Twilight manipulate Rainbow Dash, and was put in the right for doing so.
Yeah Rainbow Dash's character portrayal in this episode was kinda embarrassing. - FireMarshallBillBurns
Hey, characters like Discord and Tempest have done well, but how many villain redemptions do we seriously need before this gets agonizingly old?!?! - TylertheTitan
I've found a new worst episode of the entire show right here! Reforming Caballeron is one thing, but reforming Ahuizotl?! REALLY! I'm gonna echo off VoiceOfReason and Thespio on this one: "This is without a Daring Doubt (pun intended) the WORST way you could have had a final Daring Do episode! It fails from a story standpoint, it fails from a character standpoint, it fails from a moral standpoint, it's just all-around horrendous! "
Yeah, my thoughts, exactly. Worst. Episode. Ever. - TexasBro93
Its solo funny and great
Uhh...did you watch the episode...its awesome
Yuck the most worst.this onei s the most I hate
What's worse than a catastrophic episode about villainous characters pacing around (The Mean 6)? An unneeded spinoff to a catastrophic episode about villainous characters pacing around. Tirek, Chrysalis, & Cozy were all immature and argumentative idiots, the song (Better Way to Be Bad) derails the former two for the worst (since the very latter was already terrible to begin with), and learning a friendship moral like what they learned at the end should NOT be something done on villains who are NOT destined to be reformed! - TylertheTitan
Not destined to be reformed? What are they destined for then? Apparently, you're the writer, so explain! - DiamondTiara
I don't get why people enjoy this episode. There was literally nothing in there for me to enjoy! The only entertaining thing was watching Tirek shaking Cozy Glow violently (I hate that little abomination).
Boring, unfunny, stupid, and painful. Way to go making the villains lame, writers. Season 9, so far, is just a huge disappointment. This episode, along with Sparkle's Seven and The Point of No Return were the just the worst. The only episodes that I actually found good so far were Uprooted, Common Ground, and She's All Yak.
Funniest episode ever, villains trying to interact with each other but can't even handle it! Love it!
This is my least favorite episode for many reasons. The jokes would've made sense if we actually knew what discord and the others did. Sure, we get told about two, but how are they funny? And the peanut butter thing? No explanation because I don't know. Every second discord was on screen, he made me feel hatred for him. He was an annoying, unlikeable in this episode. The ending wasn't funny, made little sense, the joke there wasn't funny either, twilight was being stupid, spike barely even did anything to try and calm her down, and to be honest, the ending would've been much better if discord didn't get a happy ending. This was a train wreck, and the new writer definitely messed up.
Bad. Remarkably bad. The worst episode in the history of the show. Discord was portrayed poorly here. He was more tolerable in Three's A Crowd, not here. Starlight episodes get WAY too much undeserved and unnecessary hate. This episode deserves all the hate it gets. - TexasBro93
I don't like this episode, I didn't think any of the jokes were funny, looks like the rest of the Mane six is trying to make Twilight jealous the entire episode, and the entire idea for the episode was a junction of "A character is jealous" with "A character don't trust in the reformed villain", and I dislike both of them.
Seriously? The Mane 5 almost picked Discord, the villain and trickster, over Twilight. Not only do the others 5 act completely out of character, but Discord pits into question whether he's even reformed, and his punishment is not severe enough. This episode makes me hate Discord.
I suppose the moral was "learn from others' mistakes and make it better". But instead we got an episode about two irresponsible teachers who endangered the lives of their students. In real life, they would be fired and never allowed to work ever again. But in MLP, they only get a mild slap on the wrist and left in charge, even though Twilight knew they were competing all along. That could easily be misinterpreted by kids as "the end justifies the means", and that's a horrible moral to teach!
This episode is what I call Fall Weather Friends done horribly wrong. Especially since Rainbow Dash and Applejack clearly should've know by now (for over seven years) NOT TO BE SO IMMATURELY COMPETITIVE! - TylertheTitan
Spongebob did this right, Rainbow and AJ should have grown out of their competitive nature so to me they are completely out of character - Fazbear97
Yeah, this one was a waste of time...
Yes, it was a lot of fanservice, but it wasn't the mess you're saying it is. Seeing all those different alternate futures was very interesting. The reason the future was different each time was because Starlight's way of stopping the Rainboom was slightly different each time. I also hear other complaints such as why a different villain was ruling each time. Well, a number of things could have happened. In one timeline, Celestia may have successfully been able to rebanish Nightmare Moon, but not in the other one. Or perhaps Tirek or Chrysalis overpowered her. Perhaps her timeline in which she was ruling also took place before they tried to take their rule. Remember, Nightmare Moon was all the way back in season 1, and Chrysalis and Sombra weren't until seasons 2 and 3.
Sure Starlight may have been overpowered and her redemption rushed, but those were the only two real problems. Those of you complaining that this was a "sloppy mess" probably haven't watched very many ...more - MLPSpikeDragon
This episode felt like it was just a massive ego trip for the main 6. It's basically saying that without the bond that Twilight and her friends share, Equestria is doomed in one way or another. Most of the big episodes have had a subtle hint of "Twilight and her friends are better than literally everyone else," but this episode takes that subtext and puts it into the text itself. It also shows just how useless Celestia really is as a ruler. Without Twilight as her student, Celestia gets bested by Sombra, Discord, Tirek, even the Flim-Flam Brothers. How sad is it that the princess of the sun gets bested by two idiot con men?! If Nightmare Moon was able to maintain her rule and defeat the other threats, there's no excuse for Celestia.
On top of that, this episode confirms that Starlight Glimmer is the most pathetic "villain" we've ever had. Seriously, one friend of hers gets his cutie mark and sent to Canterlot, and that's all it took to get Starlight on the path the eventually ...more
While I feel that mare do well is worse, this is without a doubt the worst episode writing wise. The pacing is a joke, it's more focused in fan service than an actual story, there's practically no tension, 90%. Of it is just filler since neither the timelines or the fights in the past matter, and it just show how pathetic, stupid, boring, cliche, and down right cringe worthy star was as a Villain.
I honestly thought this was the worst season finale. Yes, I thought it was worse than "magical mystery cure". It was rushed, and season five was a great season, but a horrible way to end the season.
In my opinion, this epsisode should be number 1 on this list. Applejack was disgracefully out-of-character, I mean, the way she treats Apple Bloom is unbelievably ridiculous and against her nature! This episode contradicts the other episodes in the past involving the relationship of these sisters. This episode was a horrid portrayal of Applejack and obviously it was not a smart idea for the creators of the show to hire a brand new writer that clearly has no idea about the personalities of the characters. I can't believe his script was even accepted considering the awful out-of-character Applejack he created. "Somepony to Watch Over Me" should be NUMBER ONE. End of story. /:(
Applejack was SO out of character in this episode. It made me furious to see how the makers ruined such an amazing pony, and it contradicts everything that has ever happened between AJ and Apple Bloom. It's my fourth least favourite episode after Shadow Play, Horse Play and Friendship University.
To be honest, I couldn't get through this episode. The only other episode that I stopped watching halfway through was Putting Your Hoof Down, and that's deservingly at number 1. However, I'm frankly surprised this isn't higher on the list. Applejack is supposed to be the practical one in the group, not some freaky stalker! Besides, Applebloom has gotten herself into plenty of situations way worse than simply being left home alone, so Applejack's behavior is irrational and stupid. It was just grating to watch. I could buy Applejack being a little bit apprehensive, but nowhere near this level. NOTHING warranted this behavior. This is paranoia I would expect from Twilight, not Applejack. It wasn't funny at all. In fact, nothing in this episode was funny in the slightest. I'm done. This episode sucks.
This episode is absolutely TERRIBLE! I can't see why Applejack has to act like a absent minded jerk. I mean, Apple Bloom has been here for FOUR seasons at the point this aired. This is why Applejack is now by far the worst pony in the episode. And that song that's so short- "Make My Sister See": I would like to hear at least one verse. That part where Applejack goes Kung Fu Panda was ok, but Terrible
The song didn't appeal to me, and the silly-talk was extremely fitting for this episode, but for the most part, it made my face cringe with agony. I don't necessarily hate it, it's just that it doesn't appeal to me. It's the same thoughts on what Scootaloo thinks of songs. I didn't like it.
The song was terrible and they dumbed the synopsis down immensely
This is teaching kids don't force love but the only problem is little kids won't know about boyfriend and girlfriends until they're in middle school
So much about love for such little kids
I don't like this episode! It shows how greedy the ponds can get! Pinky pie, applejack, rainbow dash, rarity, EVEN FLUTTERSHY! She was honest and kind about it but still! They learned a lesson in the end and I know that's what they do every episode but this was not so good
Disney's Weekenders already did this plot, and it was just as stupid, because the characters acted stupid. Like in this one. Here's an idea: "Dear Princess Celestia. Thanks for these wonderful tickets, but I've already made more than one best friend here in Ponyville (as you should know, because you've already met them at the end of Friendship is Magic pt. 2). Could you send me 4 more tickets, so we can all go? Thanks in advance. Your faithful student, Twilight Sparkle." Problem solved... oh wait, we wouldn't have an episode then.
Man, any and any other writers of My Little Pony Friendship Is Magic didn't have to portray the negative girl friendship drama tension between the Mane Six just to easily affect us and make us complain, did they?
This episode made me so mad.
Because of the vitriolic friendship drama issues about being the ones go with Twilight and began giving her special treatment to earn her favor.
Seventy-seven. SEVENTY-SEVEN. You HAVE to be KIDDING me. This is by far the worst 'episode' ever next to The Last Problem! They don't even FEEL like episodes.
Many bronies were looking forward to seeing Grogar get his chance to shine as the ultimate evil of G4. It turns out, Grogar was Discord in disguise all along. All those years of buildup and hype for nothing. All those years of Discord's character development, gone in an instant. Worst writing decision in cartoon history. - shadomatrix
The fight scene against the changelings is so controversial. When you are a kid and you try to fight against other, there's a biggest reason the parents or teachers try to fix the manner. BUT, when you are a teenager, this thing goes right out the window, they put you into detention. The fight scene in part 2 is not epic and I'm scared rektless. DO SOMETHING! - MrEmerik2000
The only good things about parts 1 and 2 were the animation, the villain song and the changeling fight scene. That's it.
This was one of the best finales! And the best song in the show was in it!
What?!? This episode was better than part 1!
One word to describe this atrocity: Anticlimactic! The Mean 6 made of tree branches seems like a bizarre way to transform them into Chrysalis' minions, every other character felt like an idiot no matter how mislead they were by their cruel doppelgangers they never knew of that Chrysalis secretly created, Starlight was treated more unfairly than the others, and even with this episode's silver lining being Chrysalis not getting a stupid, forced, and unnecessary redemption, the less I say about the uncharming, ungodly, disgusting, and utterly disturbing scene of the Mean 6 melting to their demise, the better. - TylertheTitan
Are the Mane 6 THAT stupid enough to not notice the OOC moments and the awkward appearances of their "friends"? (Aka the tattered mane, the dull colors, the wrong cutie marks.) Chrysalis' "revenge plan" hardly made any sense, and the episode promo made it look so AWESOME and DRAMATIC and ACTION-FILLED. But NOPE! Just another slice of life episode with the Mane 6 just camping. CAMPING! None of them even SUSPECT anything unusual. Besides, WHY did they have to wait until the MIDDLE of the 8th season for Chrysalis to do her revenge plan anyways? Do they not know how much time is WASTED for a good BATTLE EPISODE? GOD!
Any episode that focuses on the Main Six as a whole nowadays is just boring.
While I was entertained by this episode, it felt a bit pointless. Evil Twilight was an excellent villain, and it was a shame that she, and the rest of the mean 6, were killed off so soon. Moreover, it really made Chrysalis look really incompetent.
Great job, Element of Laughter, making your friend cry by accentuating her worst fears.
I really want to say Pinkie was out of character in this episode, but actually it was slap bang in the middle of a pattern. For quite a lot of Season 4, Pinkie was either being obstructive (see also Castle Mania) or just pointlessly childish/distracted (see Three's a Crowd, getting distracted by a balloon for no reason. There was also an episode where the rest of the cast were searching for something and she was doing a colouring book instead of helping).
Pinkie Pride notwithstanding, Season 4 handled Pinkie's character pretty terribly, but this is the only episode where it felt genuinely mean-spirited, as opposed to just thoughtless or childish.
Even without Pinkie, this episode is terrible. I didn't find Fluttershy to be sympathetic here.The songs were vapid, dull, and were about nothing. The use of the poison joke in this episode is pure pandering.
Hurricane Fluttershy is one of the best episodes in the show, and Filli Vanilli is nothing more than a bad ripoff. It feels like the writers were simply to lazy to bother creating an interesting episode for Fluttershy, so the simply copied Hurricane Fluttershy but without the charm and emotional depth that makes Hurricane Fluttershy great.
Pinkie Pie simply took what was already a bad episode and made it worse.
This episode gets really start to hate it. The story was Fluttershy was singing in the garden (that makes me cry for 24 hours) while her friends came her garden to scare her. Then she joins to Cheerilee's schoolhouse to get more worse. Afterall, Fluttershy has got male voice in the scene but the ponies are laugh to her voice (Most annoying scene). At Fluttershy's House, Pinkie tries to scare her like Putting Your Hoof Down, Pinkie make Fluttershy cry (Very boring scene). THIS EPISODE SHOULD BE NUMBER #1!
Pinkie is really out of character in this episode.
My personal least favorite episode, Owl's Well That Ends Well is the main reason Spike is my least favorite of the main characters. Spike is unbearable, Twilight is neglectful, and Owliscious gets his origin. Even if I like Owliscious, this is not a very good start on him. I have a hard time relating to Spike, as he acts childish and immature and completely irrational. You may think that I'm overreacting, and that the Cutie Mark Crusaders have the same problems, but at least they have some character development, which I think poor Spike is lacking.
The first in a long line of Spike episodes where the little guy suffers undeserved abuse... Can he ever catch a break? Also, logical problems abound.
This episode plays WAY TOO MANY TIMES on television... I'm REALLY tired of seeing it... It's SO BORING! - gumballgal123
Finally, someone who agrees!
What the hell. Talk about a bad episode. A really, really terrible episode. This episode suffered from extremely lackluster writing that fell WAY below the show's usual, high standards. The dialogue in this episode was, dumb to say the least and was very weak. The conflict in this episode was rushed, predictable, and very poorly written. Never before have I hated the Wonderbolts this much. Continuity is thrown out the window, and this episode has the audacity to reference "Wonderbolts Academy", and then make Bulk Biceps a weak flier and makes Spitfire look like a complete ass who tried to manipulate Rainbow Dash, as if she never learned any thing from "Wonderbolts Academy". Almost no one is in character and just makes me confused and angry. Another problem is that episode just seems lazy, recycling animation from "Sonic Rainboom" and the soundtrack from "Wonderbolts Academy", which is just unacceptable to me, seeing as this episode is part of 2 ...more
I. HATE. THIS. EPISODE. This barely beats out Somepony To Watch Over Me for worst of season 4. This was a poorly written episode, top 3 worst in the whole series, that made me want to bang my head on the table. Everyone here, INCLUDING Bulk Biceps, is extremely annoying and way out of character. The Wonderbolts here are atrocious and manipulative of Rainbow Dash. UGH! Other than Derpy's return, this episode lacks any meaningful value. Skip this one if you haven't watched season 4! - TexasBro93
This episode doesn't make me angry, it makes me confused. What was Powell thinking when writing this? Almost nothing makes sense!
The Characters are at their worst, the humor is just not funny (the show isn't really funny half the time, to begin with, and it's just worse here), and Rainbow dash creates her own problem. And yes, a character creating their own problem is a good method of storytelling,the only way it works is if it's because of their major character flaw that they must overcome. Not a key characteristic that makes them who they are. Like, I dunno, loyalty.
Ok, this is going to surprise a lot of people here (unless you happen to be followers of Lily Orchard and Sketchy the Changeling, and I don't even like Lily). The episode where the writers decide to have Rockhoof want to commit what is essentially the T.V.-Y version of suicide! Surely, I wasn't the only one who screamed, "WHAT! " when Rockhoof told Twilight to cast the stone imprisoning spell on him, right? I'm sorry, but the writers went too far here. And what we end up getting here is a resolution where a serious psychological issue is treated as something that can be hugged away and forgotten about. And if that wasn't bad enough, Twilight only puts up minor resistance before finally giving in and agreeing to help Rockhoof go through with it, even if it was temporary! And Spike was completely nonchalant when he mentions it to the students! YOU DO NOT UNDER ANY CIRCUMSTANCES SHRUG OFF AN ISSUE THIS SERIOUS! I have not gone back to this episode since when I first watched it in ...more - TexasBro93
Honestly if she did so much work for the festival in such a short amount of time that she's exhausted, that's piss poor scheduling.
All this was was watching spike eat jewels and yell at ponies lol - BananaBrain
Awful. We are just watching spike telling ponies what to do, no real plot here.
This should be in the top 20, if not the top 10. Worst Spike episode in the whole series. - TexasBro93
Animals don't Love Fluttershy
Here's what I'm looking at. This episode was really gross and flat, And the songs sucked more than that, and there's this one song that does not shut up. This makes my eyeballs sore, I'd rather watch aqua teen hunger force. But that was made many years before this clunky piece of crap you worship so much.
More like the worst night ever.
This was the perfect conclusion to the first season.
In my opinion, from all the episodes when Spike is the main focus, this is the worst!
After Spiker ended getting lost in to the Everfree Forest and been chased by some timberwolves, Applejack do a ex-machina moment and saves the little dragon, which makes him now loyable to her. After that, instead of Spike been a good assistant, he's a living disaster and the only way to make it stop, its to make him save Applejack.
There is so many things wrong with this episodes that I don't know where I should start. The biggest problem about the episode, its Spike itself. Like I said before, instead of been a good assistant, he does nothing but trouble everywhere. If he is so good with Twilight, why he's not in this episode?
The plot about a character saving another and then letting themselves be saved to be even" is often used in cartoons, and it's plainly shown that they're following a script. Spike usually cooks and does chores for Twilight, but suddently he sucks at everything here. You just had to see this plot device in ONE other show and you could already predict everything that's gonna happen. It's lazy.
The episodes consists of a generic plot and generic jokes, and Spike's clumsiness makes absolutely no sense. After all, Twilight has called him her number one assistant.
A really boring and cliched episode. Literally everything that I thought would happen did happen!
Seriously, Rainbow Dash, why do you look up to these jerks?!? It would've been much more satisfying to see her beat the crap out of Spitfire at the end.
Bullying and name-calling aren't okay no matter what.
This episode should replace Boast Busters on the list. While that episode was just mediocre, THIS episode is just atrocious!
Poor Rainbow Dash... If I were her, I would kick their butts and shout to their names! Do you think bullying is GOOD?!?!?! Well, what is your feelings when I bullying and I call your names?!?!? ISN'T IT GOOD?!?!?! Rainbow Dash came to fulfil her dreams not to be bully by you losers! I feel sad for Rainbow Dash ( Although she is not my favourite... )
Worst season 5 episode. Still even when the 2nd half comes
This episode felt like a game to see how many plot elements they could rehash in one episode.
"Applejack at her absolute worst. - FireMarshallBillBurns
A.J and the whole town were acting really hypocritical and out of character in this episode!
The first MLP episode I really didn't like. I felt that the writer put some things at random - introducing ponies other than Rarity was useless as they in fact did nothing. Rarity's new and unique talent gets copied almost immediately. Dogs are simpy stupid brutes, they lived around for a long time (they built a lot of caves and had plenty of lackeys), but no one knew about it...
I liked it. It is in my top 10. Before this one I really didn't care for rarity.
This episode is worse than Green Isn't Your Color, because of Rarity who was whining. This episode should be CANCELLED!
This should be 1# because it has dog abuse! DOGS ARE ALWAYS BAD
Before there was Secrets and Pies, there was THIS! Now that I think about it, considering most of her roles, I'm starting to despise Pinkie. - TylertheTitan
Come on this was the worst, most boring episode ever. I love every episode of my little pony except for this one. and by the way I hate the donkey
While the song was the best scene of the episode, Pinkie just got flat-out annoying and nosy and should have understood Cranky's message: PISS OFF! I mean she HUMILIATED him in front of Ponyville!
The only thing good about this was the Smile Smile Smile song from Pinkie Pie. In season one however, I personally hated pinkie pie because of her season one songs. Fortunately, she is not being her usually random self in season one. She just to make everypony and everybody smile.
It took Baby Cakes and make it worse by replacing Pound and Pumpkin Cake with Flurry Heart!. and I am Owen Laura,Age 11. who wrote this comment
Ok, 11 year old me. you win.
A mean-spirited Pinkie Pie episode.
Aaaand that's how cupcakes originated - BananaBrain
I honestly can't understand why this is so high on the worst list, this was a pretty decent episode for the first season, and for good reason. This was at a time where Pinkie was still being developed as a character, and she seemed very one note, and creating this alter ego based on her past and her positive personality really widened the spectrum of how people saw Pinkie as a character. Most of the negativity surrounding this episode is due to the controversial Cupcakes fanfiction which really has absolutely nothing to do with this episode, except the already obvious fact that Pinkie is insane.
Hey everybody lets team up and kill pinkiemena
I'm not opposed to the idea of a kids show tackling self-harm, as it's a widespread problem around a lot of young people, some younger than you'd think. But they handled it absolutely terribly.
They really did a bad job of dealing with a subject as serious as self-harm.
I'm sorry, but Luna trying to hurt herself is really something that shouldn't be in a kids' show.
See Jerry Peet's video "Glass of Water: Self Destruction".
Definitely Twilight... Seriously, making HER a principal was the worst mistake EVER. It's not too surprising that this is so low on the list, since this episode aired not that long ago.. but still, Twilight was a jerk to the CMC. I don't see HOW she kept her job like that..
It's official. If Twilight is in an episode, she's obviously going to ruin it.
Just when I thought Twilight couldn't get any worse, this episode came along and proved me wrong.
Twilight - Geriolah7
Uh, wrong episode.
I hated the part where Rainbow Dash dragged Pinkie Pie to Applejack's barn - andrewteel
This is one of the only episodes that I enjoyed in Season 3, that season was a huge disappointment for me.
I put This episode it should be cancelled what I say
Quite possibly the most unrelentingly annoying episode of the series. - Revolution666
There is WAY too much singing.
"Follow your own destiny, but oh, Twilight, you're a princess now! Just because! " I like most of the episode but the ending was confusing and seemed to undermine the moral
Makes no sense whatsoever.
I don't think the moral is really about friendship, it's something completely different. Making Applejack, as a farmer look like an IDIOT and have to have ponies with 0 experience in farming ''help'' her make her chores easier.
This episode is a serious contender for the most boring episode of the show.
This felt like a G3 episode. Just a boring plot dragging it's feet for 22 minutes while hindsight punches Applejack in the face while she criticizes how others do things. Comedy gold, right? Whoever made this atrocious episode should be fired...
Another episode that deserves to be in the top 20. One of the most boring, dull, and unintelligible episodes in the whole series. The pacing is sooo slow and Applejack just looks like an idiot here. Rarity wasn't much better here, either. - TexasBro93
This is the episode that started the stupid "Twilight goes insane because of something little" trope that's been overused WAY too many times in future episodes (The Point of No Return and A Trivial Pursuit come to mind).
This episode was terrifying, unpleasant, intense, unfunny, and SCARY! I hate crazy Twilight I hope she dies. I am not a fn of the show, but this was one episodes I first saw, and I hated it. This episode should be taken off the air and taken off of all DVDs. Why did she show so many teeth? It's ' creepy! This is what kids should watch!?! It would give them nightmares. Also, screw you Tara Strong for making this episode so popular, you also suck at voice acting, PUT IN SOME EFFORT! I hate this show, and I extremely hate this episode.
If Sunset Shimmer lived in Ponyville and became Celestia's faithful student instead of that idiot Twilight, she would do anything this horrible! She would actually use her brain (which Twilight says she supposedly has) and write Celestia a letter about how she forgot about sending a message and ask if she could makeup for it tomorrow. After that, Celestia would reply by saying that mistakes can happen and that she forgives her. Sunset would then feel relieved and take a break by hanging out with Spike and the rest of the mane girls. Why did I type this? Because Sunset Shimmer is a better developed character than stupid Twilight Sparkle, so stop hating on her you jerks!
I don't know how anyone could find that terrifying image of that deranged unicorn freak pleasant to look at or find it child friendly. This is why I hate Twilight and Tara Strong.
I don't like Rarity episodes in general -_-
I HATE THE SONG IT THIS!
This feel more like a teen titan go ep
I just hate how at the ending the cut us off and the towns ponies get NO punishment for their behaviour.
Just why are you making an episode to scold your fans...like who is supposed to like this episode? It's so stupid and childish.
Yeah, this one is a stinker. I actually liked the Yak episode better than this. And that was the low point of this season so far for me. Okay, it's gonna be hard to top "Perfect Pear", but after giving us fans the long awaited answer to the Apple parents, they immediately kick us in the teeth with another episode about overly obsessive fans? Larson is just trolling right now, isn't he? Sorry but I feel offended for being a loyal fan to this for SEVEN SEASONS, just to get my face shoved in a mirror while someone says: "Look at you! This is how you act! " when I'm clearly not!