Greatest NFL Players of All Time
The Contenders: Page 3
One of the most accurate of all time! He's not my favorite, but is one of the best at his position.
He was the star of madden 10 or 11...madden 11
Seriously, he isn't on here? He should be AT LEAST in the top 15. He broke to records set by some of the best hofers ever! - Alpha101
That's it he should be in the top 15V 3 Comments
His stats were amazing but he did kill his wife.
He is great besides being an insane killerV 4 Comments
Let's just throw Ryan Leaf on here and call it a day.
How is he on this list he should be in the garbageV 1 Comment
7 words leader of the greatest show on turf.
1 of the best safeties
Ed Reed is should be much higher than Troy.
Actually best safety In my opinion
He isn't as good as Sean Taylor was.V 2 Comments
Hah this guy is crap
To the guy that said Eli is the best because of his Super Bowl rings, I guess you're forgetting about Dan Marino, Jim Kelly, Fran Tarkenton, and Warren Moon. All of them are HoFers who either never appeared and never won a SB. And all of them are 20x better than Eli. - DWHutchII
Wow, Eli is one of the worst QBs to win not one but 2 SBs..
I am Eli Mannings greatest fan he deserves the hall, he deserves respect. Remember it's not how good you are in the regular season but how many bowl rings you have on your hand and he has 2. Not many qbs can say they've won,one super bowl but nonetheless two. This guy's amazing.V 2 Comments
Three words BEST TIGHT END that is all
He really good
2nd best tight end
Antonio Gates was betterV 8 Comments
Hello world I'm famous. Whats my favorite donut machine you ate in one second?
I wouldn't even put him in the bengals hall of fame
What! He should at least be number 5. He has the 2nd most receptions of all time. Behind Rice.
How is Tebow higher than Tony Gonzalez Gonzalez is the best right end all time
Son of the best ever
Son of not the best ever
He is awesome
Julio should be 1
Favorite NFL player. That catch that beat the panthers was fantastic. And when he recked the panthers. wow he's a legend.
He is to goodV 2 Comments
Pretty good QB but not the best or near the best
2 seasons and he's on this list what people
Ohh, it's the best qb of all time! Did everyone forget that he won a super bowl for Seahawks! Come on at least top 30!V 2 Comments
Related ListsBest Soccer (Football) Players of All Time Best Basketball Players of All Time Top Ten NFL Teams of All Time Best NFL Wide Receivers of All Time Best Hockey Players of All Time
List StatsUpdated 26 Jul 2017
9 years, 306 days old
Top Remixes (51)
2. Lawrence Taylor
3. Jerry Rice
2. Walter Payton
3. Lawrence Taylor
2. Don Hutson
3. Joe Montana
View All 51