Best New Super Mario Bros. Games

The Top Ten

1 New Super Mario Bros. New Super Mario Bros. Product Image

My favorite game ever for the last 13 and 1/2 years (+12 days)... say, that's also where it began!

The only good new Super Mario Bros game

Hands down the best game in the series.

I still have this game, it's awesome.

2 New Super Mario Bros. Wii New Super Mario Bros. Wii Product Image

This was the first game in the series Igot. So I guess it makes it the most nostalgic one. This game brought back Koopalings after such a long absense. I loved that! I remember fighting Larry Koopa for the first time. Such memories. The soundtracks are all so good! But they were almost all used in later NSMB games too. My biggest problem with it is that it is too generic. Not all levels were that memorable. The desert world was so annoying to get through, I was stuck on it weeks, Roy Koopa was so hard back then. But I really like this game.

Speed ran it in a few days straight

It was mediocre overall

Best NSMB Game!
My Ranking:
#5: NSMBDS (Meh)
#4: Luigi U (Like)
#3: 2 (Like)
#2: U (Love)
#1: Wii (Best)

3 New Super Mario Bros. U New Super Mario Bros. U Product Image

Many people consider this to be the best in the series. I think it's a great game. But I don't see how it can be better than the DS version. Even those here that despise Koopalings say this game is better than the DS version. Weird, since the DS version is way more unique. Well, I still respect opinions so anyway. Let's talk about this game. I still can see why people love the game. This game was at least more unique than Wii and 2. There are some new soundtracks. The levels are defintly great. The Koopalings were so cool in this game to be honest. I loved all boss battles in this game including Larry Koopa's. I liked they brought back Torpedo Teds and Sumo Bro's from Super Mario World, since those enemies were cool in my opinion. There's also some new characters and enemies. One of the most interesting new cvharacters in the game is Nabbit. A guy that kidnapps Toad in some levels. There's also an acorn suit, which is similar to the Racoon Suit, except it's better. I think it's a ...more - darthvadern

Decent but it’s still repetitive - Randomator

4 New Super Mario Bros. 2 New Super Mario Bros. 2 Product Image

New Super Mario Bros. 2 is my least favourite game in the NSMB series simply because of how bland and generic and lazy it is! This is pretty much a 3DS port of the Wii version but worse. You can tell they were rushing though the game while making it. There's only six worlds, SIX WORLDS! The three bonus worlds aren't any better either. But seriously though, there's only grass, desert, water, snow, sky and lava. Ok, the second half of the water world is jungle but the music doesn't change when you enter the jungle part. The Koopalings battles range from boring to unbearable. I guess Ludwig and Morton had cool boss fights but the rest where just bad. The soundtracks are all ported from the Wii version. The only new soundtracks are Reznor Theme, World Mushroom, World Flower and World Star. The rest are copied and pasted from the Wii version! It's not a horrible game though. I did enjoy playing the game and I enjoyed World Star-Castle. But the rest are just lazy work. It's an ok game I ...more - darthvadern

5 New Super Mario Bros.U Deluxe New Super Mario Bros.U Deluxe Product Image

Best for ages 3 and older and 5 and older


6 New Super Luigi U New Super Luigi U Product Image

It sucked. - B1ueNew

BAdd New Item