Top 10 Worst Total Drama Eliminations

The Top Ten
1 Le'shawna's elimination (TDI)

Leshawna never has fair eliminations. First, the losers' mention of her name counts as a vote. Second, Harold had an easy task to vote out Duncan, but Cutthroat Courtney got to him. Thirdly, Alejandro took advantage of her, even though Heather was being honest.

I hated how they made the stupidest eliminations and saved Heather so many dam times from elimination it's like they lost their creativity or something!

LeShawna was a power house and a great character and this elimination was awful cause of that. If Heather or Owen were eliminated instead of LeShawna then I would be happy. But that didn't happen.

She could of won that season but the peanut gallery was so stupid that they voted her off. I thought Heather was going home and it would have been funny seeing her going home in that episode

2 Dawn's elimination (TDROTI)

Sure Dawn's elimination is a little sad, but it's not bad enough to be #1. Dawn is a good character, but a bit overrated.

Okay, come on! She was stuffed into a trash bag RIGHT BEFORE she could reveal to her teammates Scott's true nature!

It's not like Dawn to steal peoples things so why would people actually believe Scott?

Not cool. Everybody says she stole everything and nobody suspects a thing.

3 Ella's elimination (TDPI)

Ella couldn't get revenge for two reasons. One, she was too nice. Two, Chris would have kicked her because he prefers Sugar. The bastard can't appreciate a good singer.

Ella would stay longer if it weren't for Sugar kicking her out. Ella should've spurred revenge on Sugar sooner.

Sugar is the worst TD Villain ever. If RR is counted, then the Ice Dancers are the #1 Worst TD Villains.

It wasn't as bad as dawn or Noah's elimination but I was still sad

4 Noah's elimination (TDWT)

Alejandro should've been going home he was the first freaking person out! This is why I don't like him and was glad that Heather won instead. Or Tyler he was so dam useless in this episode plus the whole season!

His team should have WON the challenge. If anything Alejandro or Tyler should have been voted out because Alejandro was out first and Tyler is so useless.

Noah was WAY more help then Tyler he was lazy and almost cost the game! And why in the hell did they keep AL FOR!? He WAS the first one out!

First, I like to say that I was not angry with Duncan coming back nor do I think it was his fault.

Don't worry, I hate this elimination. If Chris wanted to have the cast find Duncan, he should have said it was the challenge. They were supposed to find Ezekiel, which is what Noah and Owen did. Even if they didn't, why did they not vote for Alejandro,who was the first caught, or Tyler, who did little to nothing and just slowing them down, like using his teeth even though no one told him he had to.

This eliminations the worst.

5 Lindsay’s elimination (TDA)

F-U! Duncan! You have no right in laughing at Lindsay's mistake. Sure, she was intended to be the finalist, but since her actress had other plans, they put Beth in Lindsay's place and give Lindsay a BS elimination.

In TDA, Beth shouldn't have looked at Lindsay like that, I HATE the fact that Duncan did not get eliminated. Did he have to win the million. I wanted Harold to. And it is even more stupid in TDAS when Courtney should have gotten eliminated for making Lindsay have to move the Carriage. Courtney had to get out of the carriage earlier anyways.

Because of owen

6 Lindsay's elimination (TDI)

Lindsay just proved she was a #queen. She went home in a blaze of glory, but it was still sad. I wish she won Action, to prove to Heather that she could win

At least Lindsay cussing at Heather was so… therapeutic. But this is made even dumber by the fact that in Sky Fall, Jasmine never crossed the line, so Sugar was last to cross the line. Anyhoo, the challenge was so poorly constructed. LeShawna and Izzy skipped the challenge! And what was the point of having everyone race for immunity if the last one in that race is eliminated. And the campers who made worse bikes literally got immunity. That is so unfair.

It kills me how this girl can't catch a break. TDI made crossing the finish line pointless, but I was happy she badmouthed Heather. Her World Tour elimination is something I hate. DJ wanted to go home, he didn't try to win, but Of course Lindsay go's home.

One of many cases of Chris making up rules to eliminate people. This was a really bad streak of it in TDI with DJ's elimination following it being possibly even worse. Some logic but still weird.

7 Sammy's elimination (TDPI)

Sammy was a decent character and he got kicked off cause he said a sentence that included evil in it. Okay if you watch episode 10 you will understand what I'm saying.

Like what was the point of making her and Jasmine friends if she got out so early and why the hell did they make Amy come back?

I used to think that TDPI finale would be "girl vs girl" instead TDROTI, and I REALLY wanted to see a finale between amy and sammy...

Sammy finally get it to Amy, but the latter comes back and whines then gets her sister kicked off.

8 Gwen's elimination (TDWT)

My gosh, did Chris even know that Gwen was allergic to eucalyptus plants? I was horrified with the allergic reaction she had and I even cried during her elimination. The scene where Gwen swells up due to her allergy to eucalyptus keeps me up at night.

It feels wrong eliminating her because she has an allergy. And worst part, got pushed out of an airplane up in the air

Wait, did Chris know she was allergic to eucalyptus?

Yeah, I'm sorry but having an allergy involved in a tiebreaker is just unfair

9 Courtney's elimination (TDI)

I think Courtney ´ s elimination was the saddest elimination in TDI. When I realized that her blooming romance with Duncan was interrupted so quickly and saw Duncan´s reaction, I started crying and when Duncan gave her a wooden skull as a parting gift, I completely lost it and sobbed loudly.

In all honesty, if Courtney would be eliminated in about this time in the competition, just have her do poorly in X-Treme Torture and have Harold get eliminated in Basic Straining. It makes sense. But they have this happen instead which was terribly thought out by the writers. Granted, Basic Straining is still my favorite episode, and Harold got eliminated in the next episode, but it could've been a win-win situation. But couldn't Chris disqualify Harold for trying to rig the votes? And if Harold was pissed off at Duncan, why not rig them against him? Anyways, it was also pretty clear that Harold would get eliminated soon, because no one would let him win after rigging the votes.

Pretty lazy writing, they could've done it better, if Harold just rigged the votes he should've been kicked off since he could just do it just to win, but nothing was wrong with that since...laziness

Courtney was so likable in this season! It's so unfair she got voted off!

10 Bridgette's elimination (TDI)

Actually you got your facts wrong! Owen, Dj, Duncan, and Leshawna voted for Bridgette. And when Bridgette left Geoff said I didn't vote for you! That's why Duncan made Geoff go home not so long after.

This is an elimination I loathe. The four guys (even Geoff) vote Bridgette off, because the girls could work with each other. And this is why Geoff is a terrible boyfriend: he lied to Bridgette, and said he didn't vote her off! This turned him from a great character to just plain unlikeable.

Ok, why Duncan? Why?! You are jealous of her, and she is my favorite character! "She's nice to everybody, good at sports, blah blah blah," so what do you do? You get a male alliance to vote her off! I don't know if this the the 1st or 2nd most unfair elimination, bc she is my favorite character!

The Contenders
11 Courtney's elimination (TDAS)

The writers were so lazy with Courtney's elimination, it was obvious she was gonna go sooner or later but the writing was so offensively lazy to the long time watchers of this show, they just made Courtney in one clip in one episode have a very awful plan than for no explained reason Mal found it and that got Courtney voted off, talk about lazy writing and destroying any character development.

This should've been how it went-
Mal reveals Gwen's diary that gets her out. Zoey and Mike fix up in the next episode and get eliminated for not turning up in time or whatever. Courtney Scott finale yaay! Helpers- Courtney: Gwen (they finally become friends for real) Duncan (seriously we need them all to be friends now) Scott: Alejandro and Heather (same as actual TDAS)
The season would've been so much better

I hate THAT episode. They torture all episode and even destroy her development around it.

Gwen and Mal got Courtney, my favorite character, eliminated for a ridiculous reason!

12 Zoey's elimination (TDROI)

Zoeys worse nightmare is to be eliminated by a jock and that happened.

Worst elimination, it sucked big time.

Even Cameron was shocked.

It definitely should have been Lightning and Zoey would have been a much better Finale

13 Cody's elimination (TDI)

IF I were the screaming gophers I would keep him around he may be useless but if you lose and have to vote some one off Cody is right there to take the vote if no one else is to blame. I'm a Cody fan and this would help with getting him more episodes

I felt bad for Cody in this episode; he ´ s too adorable to be mauled by a bear. I was seriously crying during his elimination.

14 Trent's elimination (TDI)

They just wasted his character he could've been so much more than a love interest! But all we know about him besides his relationship with Gwen is that he loves music and made a band with Justin, Harold, and Cody.

I could not believe that Heather Sabotaged Gwen and Trent ´ s relationship! Reading Gwen ´ s diary was one thing but kissing her boyfriend Trent really crossed the line big time. When I saw Heather kiss Trent and Gwen ´ s reaction, I was in tears. I know the other contestants could not vote off Heather because she had immunity, so they had no choice but to vote off Trent. I really wanted to hug Gwen after this episode.

That's why he started dating someone else, it said he dated an unknown fan and told Justin to text a breakup to her after he was done with his. TRENT is OVER love. Gwen choses friends over love to! So if you want to cosplay as her do not make her have a big crush! She even said herself she does not want to date anymore.

What if Trent competed in TDWT and TDAS? He would manipulate girls and eliminate them. In AS, Trent is on the same team as Heather. He finds her immunity idol and cancels out any votes he receives against him. With his vote, Heather is eliminated and Trent got even with her.

15 Geoff's elimination (TDI)

Who makes someone go away because they are to nice and chill! How stupid this whole thing was! And to make matters worse Gwen voted herself which is why she's a good friend to everyone. And I wouldn't be as chill and Geoff if my friends voted me out for something as stupid and dumb as this! Like what Duncan!

Everyone voted for him! Except his REAL friend Dj and his new buddy Gwen! Dj and Gwen weren't stupid people to begin with and they are smart to vote Heather! Like who gets out for being NICE! That's just stupid. I don't know if Leshawna voted for him or not. But it proves Dj is a better friend. Anyway Duncan laughs at Dj getting attacked by animals like who does that?!

The Reasoning behind this elimination is so stupid. Everyone hated Heather and they knew her tricks at this point, but somehow, it's Geoff's fault. The writers might as well have made a challenge that is a race, and whoever doesn't cross the Finish Line is automatically eliminated. And Geoff would lose that one.

I say this because the excuse was because he was too nice. But that makes no sense because Owen is WAY nicer than Geoff. So him being nice is one of the stupidest reasons I heard.

16 Silent B's elimination (TDROI)

I feel like someone (particularly Dawn) should've realised what was up. Big issue with Total Drama is how obvious most of the villain are.

B was so close to winning for the toxic rats! They could have finally get a win. But nope, noperooni, Scott had to sabotage his plan and blame it on B. He even told everyone to vote B off! And everyone obeyed him! Go your own paths, guys! What a jerk!

Voted off because he can't speak?! I can't believe this. Scott framed him good.

That did suck

17 Trent's elimination in (TDA)

OMG! 3:10 to Crazytown was the worst Total Drama episode because of bad things happening to Gwen and things went from bad to worse from there, including that scene where they made Gwen watch her ex get eliminated.

Well Trent DID deserve it for causing problems for Gwen but he shouldn't be out!

Trent was amazing to bad he got out. I don't blame Gwen for this tho.

Trent DID throw challenges for Gwen...

Also, this is on here twice.

18 Gwen's elimination (TDAS)

I don't get this. Unlike Scott, Gwen brought something back.

Chris really had a big factor in people getting eliminated in All Stars and I didn't like how he did it. For those that I remember, he had Duncan eliminated and sent to jail and he also changed a challenge last minute in which Courtney would have won if he didn't.

I did not like Chris this season at all.

All Stars is my least favorite season and the worst part are the characters and how predictable it is, Gwen in All Stars did not feel like the original Gwen from the 1st season, and it was so predictable to see Gwen go.

Gwen should have been kicked off third or fourth after getting better with Courtney. Also, why did they HAVE to put a butt joke in?

I will admit even if she was going home anyway she still brought back something. Mal brings back Scott and gets a freebee. Wow.

19 Mike's elimination (TDRR)

Scott blackmailed him over the course of the day and just dumped him at the end!

I hated his elimination but my friend your talking about the wrong season

Scott made him go.

Mike was in race?

20 Noah and Owen's elimination (TDRR)

Noah was DISTRACTED by Emma. They probably would have made it if the Nemma bs wasn't forced. Hell, Noah and Owen probably would have won that season.

Does it even need to be here? I thought it went without saying that this was the worst TDRR elimination.

21 Rock and Spud's elimination (TDRR)

They should have lasted way longer in the game!

22 Bridgette's elimination (TDWT)

Ok, this time, this elimination involves Alejandro instead of Duncan. This could have been Bridgette's time to shine! I love her singing voice! But she is your 1st victim of getting picked off! Why? And Chris should have helped Bridgette instead of leaving her! And how does Bridgette's team not notice what happened to her? Someone coulda asked what happened to her, she could explain, and they could probably vote DJ for crying and his curse! But no, plot twist, they vote off Bridgette instead. Not cool!

I absolutely despise this elimination. As she is my favorite character, it may be a petty reason but I don't care

Alejandro is an ass. DJ should have been eliminated in this episode

23 Noah's elimination (TDI)

Why didn't they vote Gwen out! Noah was right for not be athletic but Gwen didn't do anything either! Like when she first got on the court she got out! Noah did bad motivation tho.

Even if Noah had been in the dodgeball game the team still would have lost I mean look at him he"s not athletic personally they should not have voted him off.

Actually, the Killer Bass should have lost the challenge, because Harold technically didn't catch the ball. So in my opinion, Harold cheated to win the challenge, but nobody cared, not even Chris or Chef took notice of that. - Gehenna

Why? Way too early. Could of got out Owen. He lost the challenge!

24 Scott's elimination (TDAS)

Zoey should've chosen Mal to go cause he would kill her.

25 Izzy's elimination (TDWT)

She quit after the military needed her assistance.

8Load More
PSearch List