Top 10 Worst Nostalgia Critic Episodes

The Top Ten

1 Let's Play Bart's Nightmare

Yeah. A lot of people hate this but when I watch it, it wasn’t horrible but I mostly found it to be boring.

2 Top 11 Nostalgia Critic F*** Ups Part 3
3 Hocus Pocus

Talk about a major disappointment, like how can you prove a movies bad when they aren't any clips not one just this review if you can even call it that just couldn't bear with me

This was the most boring episode he ever made, and I usually love all of his videos. Sadly,this one dragged on a little way too long and sort of isolated fans who were unfamiliar with what the movie was even about. And the songs that kept getting too much focus weren't that entertaining.

This wasn't even a review, it was just basically low budget parody of the movie. Hell it was basically him saying "I hate this movie and it;s stupid", but it never really gave us an idea WHY he hated it.

First Jurrassic World, Then this, Then Mad Max, then Pixels, then Star Wars, has he still not caught on that we don't like these kind of reviews?

4 Ernest Saves Christmas

The Autism Joke Made Me Quit Watching Him Until His Apology Came Out.

5 Full House

I thought he made a lot of good points, and it was funny

Nostalgia Critic's final thoughts are similar to mine. - The Ultimate Daredevil, who sees NO APPEAL AT ALL TO FULL HOUSE! >8(

I Love The Nostalgic Critic But I absolutely Hate This episode because I Love Full House it's a little Corny & Chessey but it's wasn't like it back in the day. So Yeah I Love The Nostalgia Critic But This Episode SUCKS In My Opinion

6 Master of Disguise

I actually think this is one of the best. Why all the hate? - nickdoritosyum

7 Star Wars Episode VII: The Force Awakens

Boring clipless review he thinks another Star Wars holiday special would work but it won’t

He doesn't learned anything for the hocus pocus review?

8 Jurassic Park III

The Spinosaurus's neck and jawline was made more for catching fish. It certainly wouldn't be powerful enough to break the neck of a T-Rex like the movie made it out to be.
A better complaint though would be his over-usage of the "Alan" joke.

Why was he so worked up over the T-Rex losing to the Spinosaurus? I thought that scene was awesome. The way the Spinosaurus crunched the T-Rex's neck was epic. And he had to make a big deal over it? He really doesn't know how the animal kingdom works.

I know that the Spinosaurus wouldn't have been able to win the fight with the T-Rex, but the Nostalgia Critic should've explained it better instead of out over the T-Rex losing the fight. So this technically counts as a f*** up.

9 Eight Crazy Nights

I also punched Rod dainel in the balls for making Home Alone 4!

What? This was a hilarious episode!

It was basically just half an hour of him complaining about Whitey's voice and the poop jokes. There wasn't anything insightful about this review.

While he has criticized other films that I've enjoyed before too, those reviews were at least insightful and funny. For example I love Space Jam, but I also enjoyed the review of it. It was insightful, he defended his positions and was hilarious.

The Eight Crazy Nights review was the equivalent of him just sitting for a half hour saying "this sucks, this sucks, this sucks".

The sketches dragged on for too long, and it relied on shock humor which really is in no way classier than toilet humor. An irony I don't think was intended.

10 Sailor Moon Sailor Moon is a Japanese shōjo manga series by Naoko Takeuchi. It was originally serialized in Nakayoshi from 1991 to 1997; the 52 individual chapters were published in 18 tankōbon volumes. more.

"The show is popular because of its strict formula! "

*The formula literally changes ten episodes in.* - regularshowman

He didn't even watch the entire series, stopped the review in its tracks to do that pointless Japan rant, and he only saw the terrible English dub, he basically gave people the wrong impression of the show. - SailorSedna

This review came off as crude. He spent more time focusing on the characters' appearances than the actual plot. And don't even get me started on the talking dick scene.

Not only does he show a extremely biased opinion of the show due to the fact he doesn't watch much Anime (Should've gotten someone like MarzGurl or JesuOtaku to do the Review with him) he decides to dissect the show based upon the infamously awful DiC English Dub.

The Contenders

11 The Lost World: Jurassic Park

I bet he only made this episode just to piss people off!

I along with many others thought that this was a good movie and Nostalgia Critic here wasn't really thinking it through and seemed to just harp on the movie for the sake of harping on it.

I agree on some of his points in this review but this was better then jp3. The only one he should have done a review for

12 The Lorax

Oh boy a nostalgia critic fanboy

Ass-hole, it had strong heart

The movie was good, why did he get super mad at it

Since I Like This Movie
I Got Really Pissed At Him

13 Deadpool 2

Way worse than the Ernest Saves Christmas review (I actually thought that was decent, I don't get why it is so high)

When will he learn that we don't want clipless reviews anymore. This one was awful!

This one was so awful
When will he ever learn that we don’t want clipless reviews want clipless reviews anymore

14 Last Action Hero
15 The Wall

This review was garbage and it should be number 1. I wouldn't even call it a review. It was a horribly done parody of The Wall with awful singing and Doug missing the entire point of the album and movie. He also calls Goodbye Blue Sky an Oscar bait song when the album came out a few years before the movie. He spends the entire video bashing on the album and calling it pretentious and whiny but claims it was a love letter to Pink Floyd and he gives a half assed opinion saying he "liked it okay but it was a little full of itself" Let's not forget Corey Taylor's insulting role in the video. They just have him sitting around doing nothing only for him to sing the Spongebob theme song at the end. This "review" was a spit to the face to Pink Floyd and especially to Roger Waters and also a complete waste of 40 minutes. Skip this one at all costs. As what Phantomstrider says, "this falls under the category of ROTTEN"

16 Gordy

Funny thing this was the first NC review I ever saw

It's not THAT terrible. It at least has heart and catchy hip-hop in it!

17 Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom
18 Nicktoons

No matter how much you love Classic Nickelodeon as a whole, I will admit that Nostalgia Critic was so right about Nickelodeon's flaws, even back then. Doug isn't that terrible. Its animation is traditionally breathtaking, yet it looks amateurish. I at least see where the crap jokes from Rugrats comes from. Ben T. Looney said why he dislikes Rugrats. And about Mrs. Bighead... OH GOD, WHAT THE HELL IS HER PROBLEM?! And about these girls commenting Arnold in the theme song together... - The Ultimate Daredevil

19 Alvin and the Chipmunks: The Squeakquel

One of the best reviews. - 445956

Stop with making Alvin chipmunks movies

The critic is a complete jerk in this one.

20 Jurassic World

I bet he only made this episode just to piss people off!

This is when the clipless reviews started and boy did this episode suck the story he got is wrong and the way he poetrays the characters is so wrong
He thinks that the Indominus rex is a giant raptor but it’s not and the ne name he gives the indominus coke2 is just stupid this episode is start of the downfall of the critic

21 Final Fantasy: The Spirits Within

Oh my crap where do I start? Well first off this was terrible and don’t even get me started on that terrible Notre Dame Fire joke! OH YEAH he actually made a joke about Notre Dame burning down only a few weeks after the tragedy. He should be ashamed of himself for doing a joke like that! That joke is an insult to religious people and to the church itself

22 Jurassic World: Fallen Kingdom

OH MY CRRRAP! This review was so horrible all of the jokes he makes in this review are flat don’t make sense and cheaply insulting to the viewers! NO EFFORT WAS PUT INTO THIS IT JUST FEELS LIKE HE WENT ON AUTOPLAY FOR THE MAJORITY OF THIS REVIEW. This movie is actually pretty good but everyone fails to see it because we all have the STUPID internet critics to blame for it. And he calls the indoraptor coke3😡 Crap you doug

23 Disneycember: The Aristocats

This was not a Nostalgia Critic episode, Doug was reviewing this movie as himself and not as NC. - MegaSoulhero

24 Dreamworks-uary: Shrek

Nostalgia Critic actually does not hate Shrek. He does not like Shrek, but he gave it a generally mixed reception.

25 Cats and Dogs

With him criticizing all the minuscule things like the sound the dog makes when he shakes his head, it seemed like he was so desperate to find something to make fun of

He seemed really out of it with this one cause it just wasn't funny, and the constant remarks about the main kid were kinda annoying

26 Disney Afternoon
27 Old vs New Willy Wonka vs Charlie

The whole episode is essentially why the old one is better. The new one is far superior because it stays close to the original book and has more likable characters.

28 Frozen - Disneycember

Nostalgia Critic was wrong. The whole story of Frozen was rushed. I NEVER HAD TO PUT FROZEN ON MY LIST OF BEST DISNEY MOVIES! EVER!

Why? Because he didn’t give it a negative review?

29 The Jungle Book (2016)

Why does even hate every live action Disney movie some are them are good like the jungle book and beauty and the beast

30 Ghost Dad

Literally never said a word about Bill Cosby's sex assault allegations.

31 Beauty and the Beast (2017)

This should be the first place. It's a very rushed review. The Nostalgia Critic judged many scenes and elements of the film including the live action version of the film's characters with so LIMITED REFLECTION on his statements and claimed that the movie received mixed reviews while ignoring the facts that it has 71% in Rotten Tomatoes with 80% in Audience, about 27 awards/nominations and it's current 15th place in the highest grossing films of all time. - Akuseru

Seriously why does he still hate every live action disney movie? This live action adaptation was awesome but he continues to hate them. He needs to learn that some of these can be good.
But this episode is pure crap

32 Bridge to Terabithia

He says that the only good part in the movie was the leslie's death, and when she or jess sunshine, he say that isn't nothing to sunshine in every moment

33 The Cell

Some of the inside gags was way too convoluted and
Very dry including ones about placing Jennifer Lopez
In liquorice catsuit's was overused not one of his best episodes.
Frankie Ninja Smales
Smales T.V. uk

34 Dreamworks-uary: Over The Hedge

Why Doug!?
Why Do You Hate It!?
It's A Good Movie!
It's Very Underrated!?

35 Pixels
36 Face/Off

He Offended Rio(Which Is One Of My Favorite Animated Films)
That "Joke" Pissed Me Off So Much That I Quit Watching Nostalgia Critic For 2 Months

37 Top 11 Hottest Animated Women

He accidentally put a 14-year-old girl on the list.

38 Christmas With The Kranks

The review itself is actually quite good, but the stuff that goes on in between it is just painful, it was basically just Doug being butthurt about people saying they don't like his new style and him saying how he thinks the new style is better, and most people, even if they like their new work better, will acknowledge their old work as something they're proud of, but in the case of this, he seems like he's trashing his old style and saying they were "too repetitive" he even said "Christ, I thought all these repetitive traditions would be a good thing but I'm sorry, I gotta return to effort"...So he's saying his newer reviews are the only ones that have effort put into them? And with all the things he said in this review and the constant uproar of skit reviews it seems like Doug is trying to make us like this new style by constantly shoving it down our throats

39 Snick
40 Bart's Nightmare
41 South Park South Park is an American adult animated sitcom created by Trey Parker and Matt Stone for the Comedy Central television network. The show is about four boys, who are Stan Marsh, Kyle Broflovski, Eric Cartman, and Kenny McCormick, and their adventures in South Park, Colorado.

I Hate Britney's New Look, This Episode Is Bad As I'm With Stupid - Noah02

42 Alvin and the Chipmunks
43 Disneycember: Hercules
44 Foodfight!
45 The Swan Princess
46 Big Hero 6 - Disneycember
47 Let It Go Videos
48 Adventures of Pluto Nash
49 Conquest of the Commercials
50 Home Alone 2: Lost in New York

The big negative of this review was that it had yet another painfully forced political joke, I really wish he’d stop with these, they’re not funny and they just seem desperate, like he’s trying way too hard to relevant

8Load More
PSearch List