Top 10 Worst Things About the Nostalgia Critic

The Contenders: Page 3

41 Putting Sailor Moon in the Top 11 Hottest Animated Women List

She's not 16 years old yet. She has a body a little too scrawny as well.

Sailor Moon is 14. Luckily NC found out about that mistake and fixed it.

42 He Hates Every Blue Sky Studios Film (With The Exception Of The Peanuts Movie)


It is the only Blue Sky movie that I hate. Ice Age: Continental Drift is a mixed bag. Everything else is strong, especially Ice Age, The Peanuts Movie and Ferdinand.

43 He Doesn't Really Like Big Hero 6

Whoa. That was quick. - The Ultimate Daredevil, thankful even though he kinda sees why Nostalgia Critic finds Big Hero 6 to be a very average movie, but not with the visuals

44 The Lorax Review

Whoever put this on the list must die.

45 He Never Acknowledges or Apologizes for Any Mistake He Makes

Well he USED to acknowledge or apologize for mistakes he would make before, however after his return he sadly doesn't anymore.

46 He Hates The Flintstones Cartoon

Thanks to Doug Walker, The Flintstones got a lot of hate. The jokes were clever, the stories were imaginative, the characters are okay and the animation was unique albeit dull. The household appliances used for prehistoric animals is not the only great thing about The Flintstones. - The Ultimate Daredevil

47 He Hates Blue Sky Studios For No Real Good Reason

At the end of his swan princess review he said that he should probably stop being mean to Blue Sky Studios if they ever made anything good even though that isn't even remotely true for example their movie Rio is actually really good and yet he thinks it's bad and has never given any reason why. (Not that it would be a good reason but still) Even worse he had the nerve to say in his face off review that it's a movie NOBODY remembers even though that is far from the truth. His hatred of Blue Sky Studios and all their movies (with the exception of The Peanuts Movie) is one of several reasons why I don't watch him anymore because of how cruel he is to them.

So your comment is a specific reason why he hates Blue Sky Studios for no real good reason? Coming soon... Blue Sky Yuri and Pixar Yaoi! >8D

Please give me specific reasons why. I think I said that AniMat is not one of those Blue Sky haters.

48 He Hates Ice Age

We have more than one item that is about hating Ice Age being a flaw Nostalgia Critic has. I ask for no Ice Age at all. I'll always take a Rio/Robots/The Peanuts Movie sequel over an Ice Age sequel.

49 He Went Downhill Sometime After He Returned
50 He Hates White People

REALLY?! In "Disneycember - Dumbo", Nostalgia Critic said that he might as well be a dumb white guy. Despite my love towards Dumbo, I do think that the portrayal of the crow group from Dumbo is racially insensitive, albeit very convincing to be around. - The Ultimate Daredevil

51 His Obsession With Disney And Dreamworks

For anyone who had Disneycember/Dreamworks-uary exist, Nostalgia Critic is a little too obsessed with some of the strongest animation studios ever. But seriously, most Blue Sky movies are worthy. Screw Sony Pictures Animation.

52 He Thinks That Ghostbusters (2016) Is An Average Movie When It's Actually Really Bad

Hey, it's an opinion. Obviously, it's not a positive opinion. But either way, we all have opinions. I can't believe people are defending Ghostbusters (2016) aka Ghostbusters III and Sony in general. - The Ultimate Daredevil

53 He Hates Hercules
54 He's an Annoying Liberal
55 His Liberal Pandering, Anti Trump Joke In His Adventures of Pluto Nash Review

That "joke" he made in his review let's just say I didn't find it very funny because it is extremely leftist, it panders to liberals and was just extremely stupid and forced, (Comparing Trump to Hitler I mean come on, for goodness sake people you don't have to like Trump but please stop comparing him to Hitler) because it proves that Nostalgia Critic is one of those annoying liberals who (as already said) will go as far to pander to them with so called "jokes" like this. It really, really infuriates me and makes me glad I stopped watching him when I did because it just shows how he isn't any good anymore.

56 His Thomas and the Magic Railroad Review

Are you kidding me?! That movie sucks! Is it Postman Pat: The Movie or The Oogieloves in the Big Ballon Adventure? No, but why put babies' movies in theaters?! Nostalgia Critic was smart to have his negative take on Thomas and the Magic Railroad. >8(

57 He's A Fan Of Pretty Much Every Popular Cartoon Right Now Such As Steven Universe

I wasn't dissing Steven Universe I was only giving it as an example of a popular cartoon right now


58 He Is A Supporter Of Gay Rights


59 He Hates Princess Peach


60 His "Mommy, What's Sex?" Joke In His Jaws 4: The Revenge Review

The problem many people have with this "joke" is the fact that Judith Barsi would end getting murdered before she could ask that very question making it come off as forced and out of taste. That's why plenty of people hate the "joke" in question. To make matters worse he has never apologized for it, making this even more infuriating and tasteless. Moments like these make you question if the Nostalgia Critic was ever any good in the first place because this "joke" was made in his reviews before his return but either way moments like these make it difficult for me to watch his older reviews because (as already said) of how infuriating and tasteless they are.

PSearch List

Recommended Lists