Best NFL Quarterbacks of 2011

Easily the best QB ever and its to the point where it isn't debatable.. And I am from California growing up as a 49er fan... A sad day to admit this, but yes, Brady is unmatched.

Brady should win at least more two super bowls as he emerges as the greatest quarterback of his generation. He's just that good on the turf.

Did you see that game against the broncos? He absolutely trashed them. And put Tebow Mania to bed once and for all!

Once he got some talent he proved that peyton manning was a overrated stooge.

Hello? Passer rating of 122.5. Easily best on the list. Brady is good but only because he has great protection and stand in the pocket all day. It seems like every time Brady throws it's to a wide open receiver, Rodgers routinely makes great passes into tight coverage.
Yes everyone on this list is very good, but Rodgers is the best (especially in 2011 :

Very well deserved. Aaron Rodgers is one of the greatest Quarterbacks of all time. The proof? When was the last time you saw the Packers reach 15-1 for a chance at a 2nd Superbowl victory?

He's way better than Brady! He should be number one!

If you vote Peyton Manning, there's no way he's the best because he doesn't even play, and he's playing on one of the worst teams of the league. Drew Brees beat his team and I bet he could beat the Patriots and most likely the Steelers. Go SAINTS!

This guy is a freak. Tim Lincecum should give him his nickname. Over 5,000 passing yards last season? wow

Ok, let's be serious here. Peyton Manning is the poster boy for the new millennium. He personifies everything the NFL stands for. Tom Brady broke his 49 TD record by 1 score. Brady took over 100 more attempts than Manning and played 1 more full game. Manning had 49 scores and over 4500 yards in 15 games. That's an average of 3.26 TDs a game and 300 yards a game. If he finished his 16th game instead of 2 attempts, he would have had 4800 yards and 52 - 53 TDs. Brady in a "Run Up The Score" offense scored 50 TDs and 4800 yards in 16 games. Manning had over a 121 passer rating and Brady had 117. Not to downplay Brady, but Manning was more efficient in his attempts. This kid was a quarterback savant since he was born. Heir to a Pro Bowl QB dad, he was nurtured into what would become the BEST QUARTERBACK EVER! He was a high school phenom and scouted by every college. He was a standout in college and finally drafted NUMBER 1 OVERALL. This stuff is what stories are made of, but this ...more

He made the most of a team without a rushing game or an offensive line for two years, being forced to pass when everyone knew he was throwing. Look at the team's record with out him.

There's no way you can vote against Manning. He's not only the best current QB, but when he's done he'll go down as the best QB in history.

Peyton Manning is so intelligent.
NEWS FLASH: Ben Rothlesburgher is so grossly overrated it sickens me. The Steelers won in spite of him.

I know that Rivers stepped into the QB position after Breese left. Truely he might not be the best ever but he sure as he'll has the heart and drive to win. I loved watching Cutler leave Denver. Also the SD win against the highest paid QB Eli Manning. Was SWEETER than HONEY.

Yes I am a San deigo fan and have been since late 80s. My soon to be husband a lifetime steelers fan. Life somedays really suck at my house. But at least we all know SD is playing to finish this year. With a team and backing that a QB needs. Wow. LT and our energizer bunny Sproles. What an athlete. God Bless.

No way is Romo or Manning or Mc Nabb or Roethlisberg higher than Rivers. Roethlisberger is tough to tackle, but the Steelers win more because of their defense. Rivers in 2010 operated with a slew of second string receivers and still set records and scored touchdowns (#1 passing and overall offense. ) If not for the Special Teams issues... I would tie him with Brees, at 3rd.

Matty Ice is the ultimate professional and clutch qb. Matt thrives in tense situations and does not get his do credit. He's already been in the pro-bowl in a very difficult nfc, but that's not enough PLEASE RESPECT THIS MAN!

The guys rushing is second to none just a freak of a player and thoroughly deserved to be the return player of the year. MVP next year for sure

"Ben is a tank" He probably takes some incredible hits and keeps on going. Whether his continuing to play when injured is the right thing in the long run is questionable, but you have to admire his courage and tanacity. His ability to extend the play keeps many P'burg drives alive.

Excellent player who has offensive skills. Give it a few years and he will be better than Peyton Manning.

Superman is probably the best rookie QB in the NFL ever! Cam Newton is slowly working his way into the hall of fame.

2nd highest rated qb of all time and he "sucks"? He had 102 rating this year, 4th in the NFL and he "sucks"? If a player has a 102 rating, HE is doing HIS job. If anyone had any type of brain, they would realize he isn't the problem. They get their sports information from he View or Espn which broadcast very similar sports information. Romo blew ONE game in the playoffs. The Seattle game. I'd love to know what other game he blew and it was all on him. Anyone? If you say the Giants, did you forget Pat Crayton dropping 2 4th quarter passes that would have sealed the game for Dallas? Look it up, Brandon Jacobs even admitted if Crayon catches those passes Dallas wins. People that don't know football just blame Romo though. Oh, and the Vikings playoff loss. Romo was sacked NINE times. So I guess he doesn't need an offensive line to win right? You tell me a qb that has been sacked 9 times and still won a game. I can't think of one right now. People just need to learn the facts, look at ...more

Romeo sucks. He's slow and totally unpredicatable, not to mention inaccurate the majority of the time. He's got the offensive line, just can't make the plays. Doesn't make my list.

He has better stats than half of these players, and also good in clutch