Top Ten Greatest Toronto Maple Leafs Players

These include the best players in the team's history. Team builders are not inlcuded.

The Top Ten

1 Mats Sundin
2 Dave Keon
3 Darryl Sittler

Ten points in a night! Is that possable?!?

4 Borje Salming
5 Syl Apps

The man is a Stanley Cup champion, a captain, a 200 goal scorer (like getting more than 500 by today's standards), an Olympic Pole Vaulter (4th place), University of McMaster football star, CFLer and WWII vet. Apps was the biggest name in hockey and he gave up the prime of his career to fight the Nazis. His character alone should have him number one on this list. - cws480

6 Wendel Clark
7 Doug Gilmour
8 Ted Kennedy
9 Tim Horton

Love the coffee, love the player

10 Auston Matthews Auston Matthews is an American professional ice hockey player for the Toronto Maple Leafs of the National Hockey League.

The Contenders

11 Lanny McDonald Lanny King McDonald is a Canadian former professional ice hockey player for the Toronto Maple Leafs, Colorado Rockies and Calgary Flames of the National Hockey League.
12 'King' Clancy
13 Phil Kessel
14 Morgan Rielly
15 Mitch Marner
16 Frederik Andersen
17 John Tavares John Tavares is a Canadian professional ice hockey centre and an alternate captain for the Toronto Maple Leafs of the National Hockey League.
18 Frank Mahovlich
19 Nazem Kadri
20 Darcy Tucker
21 Dion Phaneuf

Haha, that's funny.

22 Ron Ellis
23 Paul Henderson
24 Red Kelly
25 Johnny Bower

I was surprised I had to add him to the list. I guess we don't think of goalies as often as skaters when it comes to all-time greats.

It's a shame he never saw the Leafs win a Cup after he retired. At least he did see what will hopefully be the start of another era of great hockey in Toronto.

Rest in peace, Johnny Bower: a great goalie and a greater person. - PetSounds

BAdd New Item