Top 10 Things Firestar Shouldn't Have Done

I mean, that's really ThunderClan's purpose, but then three quarters of ThunderClan is loners and kittypets and stuff!

Firestar sucks one way or another

I hate millie

FIRESTAR SUCKS

This was so confusing in the book, like almost not forseeing anything, also the relationship with Sandstorm and him would have progressed just fine without being in love with Spottedleaf, she would have done a great side character without being in love with fire

I'm sorry, but there is WAY too much forbidden love. It's just annoying. It's like, why Thunderclan be always breaking the code. I know they didn't get together, but he didn't seem to care that it was wrong. - Lilycat14192

Was this UNNECESSARY! I mean they talked only one time than she died and he is all like oh no Spottedleaf thought we talked only once and I only love your beauty and sweet sent I will forever be sad that you died and annoy the people which reads the books to death because the Erins can't write love and I am gonna still love you doesn't matter that I and Sandstorm while we haven't even shared tounges

Ahem... he is mates with Sandstorm... if he is mates with Sandstorm... WHY THE HECC IS HE FALLING FOR HIS AUNT-IN-LAW?! WTHECK FIRESTAR?!?! Sandstorm and Firestar have the most DEVELOPED relationship in the series! I mean, Spottedleaf: In the book for like two seconds and only talks to Firestar ONCE- IS A DEVELOPED RELATIONSHIP?! Spottedxfire is almost as bad as Ashfur x Scourge. AND ASHFUR AND SCOURGE didn't EVEN KNOW EACHOTHER! Besides, med cat romances are boring if it's not DEVELOPED. HECK- EVEN I DO DEVELOPMENT IN RELATIONSHIPS IN MY FANFICS- and I HATE doing details vs. just going straight to my drama!

Yeah! I love Firestar, but why not a temporary dep?

Come on! Graystripe is too coool not to be dep again! - Torren33

If Bluestar just didn't know she would've not been as shocked (I hope) when Tigerclaw attacked her. - Torren33

I think that would've been necessary because bluestar never BELIEVED Fireheart/Firepaw/Firestar/Rusty. So why is this on the list?

Hollykit is my favorite but she did kill ashfur but ashfur was getting to jelly with bramble law was with squirrelflight but why would she do that it's insane

CALM DOWN FIRESTUPID THE PAST 3 PROPHECIES WERE FULLFILLED! - Torren33

Honestly Firestar worried about Bramblepaw and that's one of the reasons Tawnypaw left ThunderClan! - Torren33

NO! - ChickenQueen

Remember Firestar's main quote: "it doesn't matter who they were born from, it depends on loyalty to their Clan." Yeah say that to StarClan. - Torren33

He should’ve added something like, ‘When kitty pets enter the clan, the need to choose a new mate (if they had one) or (if they are a kit) change their name. You can’t have a kit growing up with a name like Ms Fuzzypants or Mr Sugarlips. A warrior can’t have a na,e like that. Ever. If a she cat has kits in a clan, the kits stay there and (if the mother leaves) if nursed by another queen.

No! WAY! - ChickenQueen

He led LionClan to save the clans! - spottedleafpool

What? Firestar was just trying to help get rid of Scourge. Plus, lionclan was only temporary. They didn't stay like that for the rest of the books. So what if they have to work together once? If I was in firestar's paws, I would do the same!

Poor Leopardstar, she should've led it. She deserved it. Or maybe Tallstar because he the best. I was so sad when he *WARNING SPOILER! * died. - Torren33

He didn't have time so it wasn't rly Firepaw's fault, but if he loved Spottedleaf, why not protect her? - Torren33

Scourge didn't deserve to die. But ruby does. Scourge was just a smol cat he's a kitten

I love Scourge, he shouldn't have killed him - WoofWolf

Well, because the quote for family’s is “Family Is Forever”, means that he shouldn’t have killed him. He was his family. And “No One Is Left Behind” hm, tell that to StarClan too, leaving dead cats behind! Anyway, Firestar killed his family. But he didn’t know. STILL your FAULT, FIRESTAR!

Why would FireStar leave his best friend for a few rag-tag cats in the forest? Just why? It's selfish and disgusting. All he wanted was fame and to become stronger and crap, when he LEAVES HIS BEST FRIEND for brand-new best friends.

Firestar shouldn’t have been leader, Whitestorm should’ve been leader himself. Firestar needed help from a warrior! (Whitestorm) and firestar was always doubted, why just- just-just I’m done, I’m to sad. DappleTail died in MoonRise, brightheart and cloudtail are missing, the forest is being destroyed. Tc, Sc, Wc, And Rc will be in memory.

Gray stripe was way wiser and would have been a way better leader

Well actually I read that he chose Brambleclaw because of the message Leafpool got from StarClan (you know her bramble dream, or was it a vision... idc) and since Firestar has a very strong faith in StarClan that’s why he kept Brambleclaw deputy. But Graystripe would still be a heck of a lot better than Brambleclaw!

He was ded inside

HE died to save his clanmates - spottedleafpool

NO!

Wa he died this is really sad I love him.

If Firestar was more stern with her about going to the thunder path then she’d be a happy skillful warrior

She could have died ivy pool could have

Ivypool, is Firestars granddaughter. So. firestar. Keep your grandchild away from ThunderClan borders. Keep her in camp. Back to the story. When Ivypool left- she met Mapleshade. (thanks clawface for killing spottedleaf by the way) then. IVYPOOL IS JEALOUS OF HER SISTER! She just wanted to be as strong as her sister. DoveWing hater’s. Go sink in a toilet. Your just jealous of her loyalty and bravery and Power!

Ivypool is not firestar’s grandchild. Still he shouldn’t have let her go. I messed up on the story.

I LOVE GrayXSilver! - ChickenQueen

I don’t mind Greyxsilver, it’s just that he knew what was going on and didn’t tell anyone, despite having more than a close friend in another clan is forbidden by StarClan. Fire knew but didn’t tell anyone, not even his med. cat or leader, who warriors usually trust. Overall, I think this was a mistake on Firestar’s part. I don’t hate him or anything, but that was kinda... stupid, really... even if Grey is his best friend...

It's tru

I hate mud claw, why bring tallstar and jerk claw home? They deserve to be tooken away. Later In the books, WindClan is caught stealing prey from ThunderClan. Why fireheart/firestar. Just why bring jerk claw home? Firestar caught them running on Rc with Tc prey. Talk jerk allowed his warriors to steal from firestar’s clan. Stupid star.

She only walked around border’s. Then what do ya know? She gets in mothwing’s buisness and ask’s: “is your father TigerStar? ” Then get’s Brambleclaw worried sick. He doesn’t want to be related to a guy that threats Brambleclaw’s leader.

WHY YOU WERE RIGHT THERE FIRESTAR

Bluestar did die because of the position fireheart put her, she was fighting the dogs with fireheart. Then a shi’zoo came and knocked her off balance and she landed in the river after she killed a Doberman Pincher. Oakheart saved her as well, here is what he said: “it’s like running through the forest, let your paws do the work. Raise your chin, let the water carry you up. That’s it! Keep going! ” She got to swim for a bit, fireheart jumped in because she ended up drowning. Fireheart: “bluestar! Raise your chin! ” She didn’t, fireheart needed help. “StoneFur! Mistyfoot! ” They splashed in and carried their mother up. She ended up dieing after when they carried bluestar up. Bluestar: “StoneFur? Mistyfoot? Forgive me for giving you up, I was deputy. And-and I needed to give you up unless, well. Ya had a sister. Mosskit. She died in the snow. I’m very proud of you, forgive me.” StoneFur exchanged a look at his sister, then looked back at his mother. “We ...more

Urr... you don’t get to choose who you’re related to. If this is talking about how the Erins made them related, then that’s on them, NOT fire. Also, post below me, how does this relate to a popular fan ship? AshxScourge has nothing to do with Firestar being related to him. Also, if fanfics scare you, why are you complaining about it? Fanfic reading / creating is optional in the Warriors fandom. And what’s wrong with the odd gay / crazy Warriors ship? Yeah, sure, AshXScourge might be popular, but that doesn’t mean people should complain about it IN ALL CAPS LIKE THIS.

Because, ASHFUR X SCOURGE SUCKS, FANFICTION SCARES ME T^T, AND SCOURGE IS A BAD BAD MAN... HE KILLED A GANGSTER! by the way: BLACK STAR’S TO WHITE AND NERDY �", OUR GANGSTERS ARE: “LeopardStar, FireStar, And TallStar! ” Congratulations gangsters! “They see me mowing, my front lawn thinking I’m to white and nerdy! ” ~from BlackStar the nerd

Tigerclaw was evil I don’t care about him!

All sandstorm does in the book I'm reading is moan about firestar not chose her to mentor tawnypaw.
Gets mad at him for everything he does that's against her or something she dislikes.

Firestar just HAD to tell about tigerclaw and Darkstripe talking about killing RAVENPAW! Couldn’t he mind his own buisness? That was tigerclaw’s and Darkstripe’s buisness, not his. Even though Ravenpaw was Firepaw’s/firestars best friend... he shouldn’t have told.

Fireheart/firestar lets GrayStripe go into Silverstream’s Camp. She died already GrayStripe! And ummm, all I’m trying to say is, don’t let GrayStripe go, EVER AGAIN!

He was trying to persuade LeapordStar to come with him and TallStar to find a new home. When She declines, almost all of ThunderClan’s apps died. Two kits died. And GrayStripe was stolen by twolegs. Then. Hawkfrost threating’s Firestar because he was chasing Sasha off ThunderClan territory. He and his mother walked across the River. Then, tawnypelt gets a fit that BlackStar gave up on every single cat in the forest. He was leaving with Tallstar and Firestar as well. Stupid LeapordStar doesn’t care about leaving as long as they have prey In the river. the monster’s are gonna reach ya soon, Leapordfart.