Top Ten Things That Shouldn't Have Happened In Warrior Cats

Things in the warrior cats universe would have been better without these events! Also has things that could have been done better.

The Top Ten

Twolegs shouldn't have destroyed the forest

I agree. Four trees was amazing to me, but... they were slowly dying where they lived forever. If the lived there still- the series would be dead COMPLETELY. Firestar the main character... makes the right choice to leave the forest. Besides. STORM X BROOK FOREVER!

I like the old territories better than the lake territories. Since this happened, we had to spend our time reading 4 books that basically covered the entire journey there.

Makes me hate humans more than I already do. But we're here to change things, so I ain't gonna be depressing no more.

Personally I like the original books more and I would like the others more if they lived in the old forest I really miss fourtrees

Thunderclan shouldn't have turned Mapleshade out

If ThunderClan didn't throw out Mapleshade
-Ravenwing will be alive
-Frecklewish will be alive
-Appledusk (Sucks) Will be alive
-Spottedleaf will be alive
-Crookedstar's family will be alive
-If she didn't rule the dark forest, Thistleclaw wouldn't have turn out so bad
-And if Thistleclaw wasn't soo mean, Tigerstar wouldn't.(I'm not sure, though)
-And if Tigerstar wasn't evil, Bluestar will be fine leader until she died
-Gorsepaw will be alive
-Firestar will be alive
= They shouldn't have exile Mapleshade

The time I cried was when Appledusk rejected Mapleshade. That was the only time I have ever cried while reading a book. Mapleshade lost EVERYTHING and ALL she had left was that trash Appledusk, and apparently he didn't care, so he rejected her. And then REEDSHINE started flirting with him in front of her! After reading her story, I hate:

Mapleshade is one of my favorite characters, along with Hollyleaf, Ivypool, Feathertail, and Honeyfern. What she had to go through is just so sad! (I hate Appledusk for that reason no offense.)

Yes, I was legit also crying. I hate that Reedshine..No, seriously. Reedshine; *Brushes against Appledusk* Go away, Mapleshad. You have caused enough trouble tonight. I also hate Ravenwing.

Hollyleaf dying

Hollyleaf is the best character ever. She shouldn't have died! Why doesn't she ever appear in starclan during the books? she should at least be able to deliver a prophecy or something .

Hollyleaf was one of the best characters I've seen in the series, it's just so unfair that she had to come back only to die in the next book...

Ugg, Hollyleaf was honestly a Honorable cat that did almost nothing for her clan except save Ivypool. Although, lots of things wouldn't have happened with out her. She is so overrated and I hate her, I'm glad she died.

She made some bad decisions, but she is a great cat. She even forgave her mother after all the terrible things Leafpool did. (Breaking the code, lying, etc)

Firestar loving Spottedleaf

The whole Fire x Spotted thing should never had happend he talked with her 3 times only because he needed medicine and then she died yet they showed to love eachother right after she died?!

The whole love story is with her stalking him and the reason why this should never had happend is because of how annoying the love story is and that this made Firestar not being able to decide between a childhood love which doesn't make sense and the cat he had kits with and spended his whole life with

Firestar became so stupid at romance which annoyed not only me but many other people the only right thing about this story is that she died at the end and they never saw eachother again

Fire star and spotted leaf would have never work, many reasons
1.spottedleaf is and forever be a medicine cat
2.spotted leaf is a medicine cat, the will be breaking the warrior code
3.Spotted is Moons older then Firestar... Imagine a six year old in love with yo grandma

Spottedleaf is like double Firestar's age and barely talked to him before his death. And now she stalks him in his dream! Seriously...I can imagine how irritated Sandstorm was!

Seriously! It was so disgusting! Spottedleaf was an adult cat, but Fireheart was barely more than a kit. It's DISGUSTING.

Yellowfang should have stopped meeting Raggedstar

I hate Raggedstar. Not just because he was her mate, but seriously, what did Yellowfang see in him? He was mean to her when she decided her destiny was healing, he had mood swings, they probably would not have been good mates. I'll just say I was not SAD when he died. If Brokenstar wasn't born then so many kits wouldn't have died *sniff*

I love the Raggedstar and Yellowfang couple and even though them not meeting would prevent Brokenstar. He was one of the main plot points in the series and a lot of stuff would not have happened including Firestar joining the clans.

Yellowfang and Raggedstar are an OK couple, they should have just been friends, not mates. Then Brokenstar/tail wouldn't have come along! Yay!

Yeah, but it's like saying Tigerstar shouldn't have been born. Then, where would the plot be?
- Lightningstar

Tigerstar should have died and one of his sisters live

If that happened he would have gone to starclan! And mistkit might have been good. But think about it. If nightkit or mistkit lived... Thistlclaw may have to mentor one of them. I mean ferncloud was a good cat. Darkstripe was her mentor and dustpelt was her mate and she's a good cat! Tiny wouldn't become scourge because Nightpaw wouldn't have hurt him.

But if he died, who would be the leader of Thunderclan? Bramblestar would never have existed. Tigerstar did produce 3 good characters, Bramblestar, Tawnypelt, and Mothwing.

Maybe one of his sisters would have been evil? Think of Mapleshade, SHE was evil. One of his sisters might have been. Goosefeather was right, though, Tigerkit should not have been born.

I hate Tigerstar too but I think he should'nt have died instead of his sisters. I mean, I wish both of them alive. It can't have only good cats in warrior cats, right?

If hollyleaf hadn't announced the truth at the gathering

I mean Ashfur was going to reveal it anyways... But NOOO hollyleaf killed him and then told the gathering herself!
I love hollyleaf but that was awful! I admire her because she always felt bad about it in the caves with fallen leaves.

She should not have. But, I know Squirrelflight had to tell Ashfur. It was the only way to save their lives. Afterward, she could have at least told them she lied to save them.

I love Hollyleaf so much! She loved the code, and couldn't live with lying to the clans anymore!

Dude, you killed Ashfur, who was going to tell the truth, to announce the truth ANYWAY! Why?!

Snowkit dies just to move Speckletail to the elders' den

Well, she wanted to think her kit was perfect, absolutely perfect. Like there was nothing wrong with him and he'd be the best at whatever he became. I think lots of queens think like that. Scratch that. Every queen except Rainflower ( well she thought that, formally ) or anyone else who had some reason not to love their kits. I think Fireheart or someone else asked him something and he replied, " S'all again? " I don't know. Haven't read that in awhile. But yes he was caught by eagles and died. And then... Speckletail, with extreme kit depression, becomes an elder. Considering Snowkit was an only kit, he was spoiled. When Speckletail found out her son was deaf, she snapped. She even tried teaching Snowkit a little bit before he was carried off. But there are a LOT more cats that have gone through worse with kits. One of the most obvious. Bluestar! Her kits, Mistystar and Stonefur, were given up. Bluestar's ambition forced her to take the life of a deputy and eventually leader. ...more

The "snowkit is snowtuft" theory isn't true, he was carried off by an eagle. there's no way he could've survived. 1. the eagle's talons would've left really deep wounds in him, which would make him die of blood loss 2. even if he didn't die the eagle would've killed him before eating it 3. even if he did somehow fall out of the eagle's grasp, he would have fallen to death. he was all the way up in the sky and he's a tiny kit no way he could have survived a fall at that point

Talk about ruined character potential. It would of been amazing to see the development of a deaf cat adapting Clanlife. If the Erins have the ability/skill to write a blind a blind character, they can write a deaf character, it just takes a bit of research and planning. Reducing a deaf kit's death as a way to move forward a subplot of a very minor character is lazy and possibly offensive.

Snowkit could have been so much more than just a deaf kit. He would have made for an interesting cat in the books! And, if any deaf people read it, it'd encourage them that Snowkit survived. Snowkit was wasted potential. We could have seen him become a great medicine cat, even a warrior! Ugh. The Erins, though, are infamous for throwing away good characters.

Dovewing being born

Dovewing could have been written better...and her "special name" makes me think she's some sort of reborn Spottedleaf.

And the whole "forbidden love" thing...all I can say to that is, hey, what else can you do to keep your obsessive fans flocking back to your lacking novels? Forbidden romances! They'll suck it up faster than a tick on an elder's pelt!

I mean I used to think dovewing was ok... but now I hate dovewing for joining shadowclan like she could've stayed in thunderclan. And what is it with every warrior's series having some sort of forbidden love? And Dovewing is really just a mary sue like she was the "perfect sister". If she hadn't fallen in love with tigerheart/star I think I would've still kinda enjoyed her character. Seariously did they have to make every series about some sort of couple running off together then coming back to the clans or breaking the warrior code to love? The new series with shadowkit is not really interesting to read, and WHAT is up with the new warriors names, Flipkit? Pouncekit? Shadowkit!? Seriously!? I do think they are running out of names but they could name them like they used to, these new names are really strange and what other names are they gonna come up with? Preykit?! I think the Erins are just trying to continue the series, I understand that lots of people enjoy the warriors series ...more

Yeah, she had no use in the slightest. She was used to make a dumb love triangle! Ivypool and Hollyleaf did more than she did, Hollyleaf deserved that spot! DIE DOVEWING!

yeah shes just a replacment for a cooler cat like ivypool or hollyleaf

Leafpool being shipped with Mothwing

I hate this god forsaken ship so much because it’s overrated, just dumb, and the only evidence I’ve ever heard that makes people think leafpool loves mothwing was that “she thought of her as beautiful”, hey, I think my friend is beautiful, but not in a lovey dovey way!

uhhh...what the $%^&* is this?
1. They are both MED CATS (no mates/kits)
2. They are both SHE-CATS
3. They are in different clans



The Contenders

If Cinderheart/Cinderpelt thing had been easier

Cinderpelt should have gone to StarClan at her death, not gone into Cinderheart. I'm glad Cinderheart is her own warrior now though, not thinking she wasn't mean to be a warrior.

Yeah... What happens when cinderheart dies? Does she become cinderpelt or something? And if she does... Would that make her cinderpelt or cinderheart?

Yeah... I mean it's gonna be kinda awkward in StarClan. But I'd still want Cinderheart to be born, she's like my sister!

How about Cinderpelt goes to StarClan and Cinderheart is her own cat. How's that idea?

Silverstream's death

Then there would be now Millie, and I love Millie. Silverstream was a sweet cat, she had a sad death, but it was best for everyone.

This if silverstream didn't die. I'm okay with silverstream not dying, but that would mean no briarlight. I like silverstream and briarlight.

This was too tragic..

She should’ve lived, then there wouldn’t be that horrible Millie, and Blossomfall wouldn’t be in the DarkForest.

If Crookedstar had appointed SOMEONE else deputy

Why does everybody hate Leopardstar, she was a great lead, she let ThunderClan take refuge when their camp was on fire. She appointed Mistyfoot as her deputy because she felt sorry for her because she had watched her brother die. But I would like people to name one bad thing that any leader hasn't done except for joining Tigerstar.

Leopardstar was at least a decent leader. The one mistake she made was allying with Tigerstar, but she was young. Leopardstar did many great things for her Clan, and was an interesting character to have while she was around.

Like his daughter! Before she was pregnant I mean... Leopardstar sucks. She turned down graystripe and never let him go to gatherings! Graystripe saved mistyfoot's kits! But leopardfur wouldn't allow it

Leopardstar wasn't a bad leader. She should have been picked by Crookedstar, but I love Mistystar the best of the RiverClan cats. Well, her, Stonefur, Stormfur, and Feathertail.

Firestar died

Cats need to die at some point. Besides, Firestar lost all his personality when he became leader. Bramblestar is a great leader, and there need to be more leaders after Firestar. I know he's nostalgic for all of us, but he needed to die at some point. Besides, he head such a heroic death! What more could you want for him?

Actally I like that this happened. It was sad at first but now I realize that he's a player.I liked him as a warrior more than a leader. Plus bramblestar would never be leader and I love him!

Firestar shouldn't have died but truth is, he led Thunderclan for long enough. It was the right time for him to go

Firestar was my number 1 cat but he died a good death

Mapleshades kits being thrown out.

I could understand exiling Mapleshade, she did something wrong and was strong enough to survive on her own, but exiling three innocent kits? That would be the equivalent of arresting the children of a criminal even if the kids did nothing wrong!

I mean, three kits. Any three kits could have been trouble. But no. Some three specific kits right now, why not those three! Innocent little kits, kicked out. They didn't do evil! Ravenwing is as bad as tigerclaw, kicking out halfbloods. Yeesh. -dawnheart

YES! You can punish Mapleshade, but not her kits! That's against the warrior code! The kits had no control over it!

It's actually breaking the warrior code.

Cinderpelt loving Firestar

I know you may not see this, but whoever said she didn't love Firestar is wrong. Last page of River of Fire, A Vision of Shadows. She admits it to Alderheart, son of Squirrelflight and Bramblestar, after he nearly fell in love with a kittypet named Velvet. She said she gave up hope for him ever loving her because of her duty as a medicine cat.

There's almost no platonic relationships in warrior cats so it annoyed me when I found out Cinderpelt loved Firestar. No offense to CinderXFire lovers.

We need more platonic relationships in Warriors! Honestly, it should have just been like a teacher-student friendship.

Cinderpelt did love Firestar. Last page of River of Fire.

SkyClan getting kicked out

This was so stupid! I mean seriously, both times they could have just adjusted their borders a little the first time. In AVOS they didn’t even care for SkyClan even after StarClan specifically told the Clans that they needed to stay. All every Clan cared about was what the other Clans did. And the first time, they didn’t even think about it, just cast them out and didn’t care. Bluestar’s reasoning is even stupider. “There are only four trees.” So now your letting trees decide the fate of the Clans? If your Clan was struggling during leaf bare, and there were only 20 trees surrounding your camp, but 24 cats, would you kick four of them out?

YES! I read dawn of the clans first and I was so sad when I realised there was no sky clan!

SkyClan is better in the gorge, that's just the way that is.

CindherpeltandCinderheart, I just think they shouldn't of been kicked out in the first place, but then no Hawkwing, but I mean there wouldn't be names like BILLYSTORM or MACGYVVER or EBONYCLAW! Like what the heck? No hate to you...

Feathertail Dies

She sould have just gone to a closer ledge and kicked it, the she would not have died :(

Tigerstar shouldn't have brought blood clan into the forest

He brought bloodclan to the forest. And that's how he died! He caused many deaths with that! Including my baby whitestorm! :(
Anyways scourge took one of firestar's lives.I'm not a big fan of firestar, but it was still sad!

If it didn't happen then Tigerstar would have lived, though.

Ok Tigerstar was thinking like a total idiot I mean like he could have lived.

That was his biggest mistake and downfall.

The tree falling on thunder clan camp

That was sad! Longtail shouldn't have died and Briarlight shouldn't have been paralyzed! She teaches a lot of courage this the tree we are talking about?

1 death, 1 injure and a destroyed camp... A lot of destruction for one little tree!

That should not have happened. Then Briarlight would have had a better future.

Scourge and Ashfur Being Shipped.

I don’t think they even personally met throughout the entire series.

I don't like this :[

Mapleshade going to the dark forest

She was a not a good cat, she deserved to go there, but she was an interesting character. I think she should have been able to redeem herself in some way, though. She wasn't evil at first, but she definitely didn't deserve to go to StarClan at first.

Mapleshade did want to be in the Dark Forest. And she wanted blood to rule the forest, so she did deserve to go to the dark forest.

She definitely deserved to go there. But it would have never happened if it weren't for her stupid clan kicking her out.

She so deserves to be, after betraying her Clan! I feel sorry for her kits, and her kits only!

The name Maggottail

What horrible cat named him? Imagine naming your child Maggot.

It’s a terribly cruel name. What kind of mother wakes up one day and decides she’s going to name her child Maggot?

Snowkit shouldn’t have been taken away


Make a decision Erin Hunter, a kit will get taken away, then lives by some KITTYPET, I'm POINTING AT YOU PRINCESS! Princess in her mind: ‘OH IMA LIE THAT FIRESTAR IS MY BROTHER TO SNOW KIT AND LIVE ON! ’ Snowkit then feels betrayed, and then trains with some evil lady cat called mapleshade. Then, he trained with brackenfur in the dark. Then ashfur helped hawkfrost do some silly fox trap, than the stupid fire takes in. ‘Snow tuft’ (snowkit! ) helps make the stupid fire. Than, snow tuft eventually wants to kill firestar. WOW ERIN HUNTER. JUST- LETS GET BACK TO MY STORY. Than sol works with snowtuft, ashfur gets slaughtered by a stone and hollyleaf. Snow tuft tried to kill jayfeather, holly leaf killed snowtuft and everyone’s happy. NOPE, snowtuft died and went to StarClan and Dark Forest's border, he saw firestar, ferncloud, Speckletail, and... who was it... OH, ASHFUR.

wot this happend in what book?!

The fire destroying the Thunderclan camp

Then the two elders and Yellowfang could have lived

Yellowfang wouldn't have died!

YElLOWFANG! I lover you!
U were a great mama mia to cinderpelt!

8Load More
PSearch List