Top 10 Worst Warrior Cats Moments

Anybody here feel the same way about these moments? There are the ones that seem to drag on and the ones that are so sad you almost cry every time. If there are any sad ones here it's because it's sad, not that it's stupid or bad or THE WORST! They are just so sad I almost cry. Not that I have anything against these moments, I just don't like them too much.
The Top Ten
1 Hollyleaf's announcement

Okay, first of all, Hollyleaf is the worst. She is just a big idiot. Hollyleaf is so dumb, that she decided to blurt out the truth in a gathering. Like, seriously, she could've just told Firestar instead of just saying it in a gathering. Everyone describes Hollyleaf as a thinker and thoughtful in the warrior cat books. But, that is not true, because she doesn't think before she speaks. Yeah, and this incident proves it. Hollyleaf also, decided to try to kill Leafpool, one of my favorite cats. Now that is a real crime. I am surprised that she was not exiled, because she did deserve it at the time. She also killed Ashfur, oh, the Hollyleaf lovers always say that she didn't mean to kill Ashfur and everything like that. Yes, Ashfur was a very bad cat and everything, but that doesn't give you the right to kill him. Now, if he were evil like Tigerclaw/star, then yes, but Ashfur wasn't evil. He just loved too much. Again, Hollyleaf isn't really the thinker here either! Lastly, she ran away ...more

I thought Hollyleaf's announcement was pretty important because, if she hadn't, she probably would've ran away anyway because she couldn't handle her birth breaking the warrior code, which was everything to her. And yes, there were whispers about Leafpool, Squirrelflight, Brambleclaw, Jayfeather, and Lionblaze, but it didn't haunt them. By the time Hollyleaf came back, everyone had pretty much gotten over it. Also, Ashfur was going to reveal it just to spite Squirrelflight Hollyleaf did it because she thought she was doing the right thing. Quote unquote "I thought I was doing the right thing, but no one understands! "

BRUH SERIOUSLY?! Why are people hating on her so bad? All she did was say, "Hey, my parents lied to you all, they lied to us, and everyone here." WHAT IS SO WRONG ABOUT THAT?! Why is she not allowed to tell everyone the truth?! HUH?! Sure, it was dumb and probably not the best time to say it, but BRUH SQUIRREL AND LEAF shouldn't have lied about that, I'm not hating on them, I'm just saying that Hollyleaf didn't do anything wrong by revealing the truth. (Except it was the wrong time)

I hated it. From this, I have just pure hate now of Hollyleaf. Sorry to all of the lovers of Hollyleaf, but I hate her. First, she kills Ashfur because of the secret. But then, she tells everyone! So what was the point of killing Ashfur again? And then, she liked to see Squirrelflight suffer. I would at least still care for my foster mother! And then she tried to kill Leafpool, even after she lost the love of her kits, Crowfeather, and her position of a medicine cat. And then she ran off, like she didn't care.


2 The Thunderclan fire

Honestly, this for some reason was awful for me. Not for some reason them losing their camp or Yellowfang's death, but Halftail's. I remember him being one of the first cats to welcome Firestar to ThunderClan and my heart stayed with him until his death. I have not met another person who really mourns Halftail, if they mourn the fire it's Yellowfang. I wish he had lived, he was my favorite!

-Nightstar, leader of SkyClan

Yellow fang is a great cat. She did not deserve to die.

Poor HalfTail! And also poor PatchPelt! They didn't deserve to die! Also YellowFang is overrated

3 Firestar's death

Firestar should have lived longer. The author acted like his nine lives did not exist, killing one off at every moment possible.

Firestar, one of the most powerful leaders in the forest and defeats enemies such as Scourge and Tigerstar, dies an incredibly stupid death. I mean what would be a worse way to die than from a stupid tree?! I did like how Brambleclaw became leader but why is he choose his mate to be his deputy?

Just to clear something up, Firestar did NOT die from the tree. The tree happened to fall, yes, but he didn't die from it. He died from the wounds Tigerstar gave him while they battled, not a tree. Erin Hunter isn't stupid, and Firestar didn't die from a stupid tree.

Nah, whoever said the Gary-Stu thing, I kinda agree. But without him, there's no story at all. You can make your OC as crazy as you want, almost as perfect as Firestar. So, it's kinda 50/50 on him being alive. He is the grandfather of The Three, in almost every prophecy, started life as a kittypet, gave Longtail a nick in his ear, ( Should not have happened. He just go to ThunderClan. Literally. Just. Got. There. ) beat Graypaw the first time, ( Same as Longtail ) saved WindClan from exile, saved ShadowClan from Brokenstar, is related to Dovewing, his Clan wins most of the battles, all the books basically are spotlighted him, etc. He's not the main character in every book except maybe Firestar's Quest and the first series. TNP was thrown around to Brambleclaw, Squirrelpaw, Stormfur, and Leafpaw. Most of the other books like Super Editions are about ThunderClan ( Firestar's Quest, Leafpool's Wish, Hollyleaf's Story, Goosefeather's Curse, Bramblestar's Storm, Bluestar's Prophecy, and ...more

4 Treecutters come and ruin forest

"cOuLdn't ThEy jUsT lEaVe ThE pOoR kItTiEs AlOnE"
Tbh I do not like the treecutters, but how was they supposed to know that the cats lived there...I mean they found some cats but they probaly just thought that those were strays that just happend to be there...

Honestly, the Twolegs/Humans in these books are just evil and careless. Why couldn't they just leave the cats alone? The Twolegs had like NO IDEA how much damage they had done on the cats themselves and everything around them. :(

-RoseCloud of ThunderClan

Subsection of the sadness of the great journey, I wish they hadn't had to leave.

Why couldn't they have left the poor little kitties alone?

5 Briarlight breaks her backbone

Briarlight is stupid I hated this too because Millie stopped paying attention to poor Blossomfall for stupid Briarpoopbutt. Sorry but I really hate Briarlight!

That's just horrible! She can't walk! I would HATE having to have everyone start being sympathetic and I would be happy when they stopped!

This was just really sad. It caused Millie to neglect Bumblestripe and Blossomfall, and it was sad seeing that she could never be a warrior.

Briarlight never got a chance to actually hunt and fight along her clanmates when she was a warrior. Poor cat.

6 Snowkit's death

This was one of the saddest moments! It broke my heart when the eagle grabbed him taking him away. He didn't even know what was going on because he was deaf! I wish that he could be reincarnated or something! Poor Snowkit.

It was so sad, it bit right through my heart! I watched a video about snowkit's death that made me wanna cry! I think it really added something to the book for you to think about a lot. It really made the book sadder. It did the book some good but didn't do any good for snowkit or the super sad feeling thinking about him. It's not the worst, it's the SADDEST!

I really thought that he could be someone special in the book, like someone prophesied or something, maybe a medicine cat since he was deaf. I can't believe that he died!

WHY did Snowkit have to die? All disabled cats BUT THIS ONE get's to live, but not the best one of them all?

7 Jayfeather breaks his stick

Jayfeather destroyed the only memory of before the tribe of rushing water had been made. That stick was definitely important! The ancients may still be able to contact him along with the other ancients but now the memory isn't strong anymore.

I actually thought of this as a sad moment, if you think about it Jayfeather doesn't really have friends. He thought Rock was his friend... But... No

He broke the only memory of the ancients.

Jayfeather can be so dumb sometimes.

8 Skyclan gets chased out

Okay, first of all, let's get this straight. Skyclan is my favorite clan and it will always be my favorite Clan. I will forever be loyal to Skyclan. What I don't understand is why the clans had to be so greedy to kick Skyclan out! They had plenty of prey, Skyclan's territory was being destroyed by twolegs and they were starving. So the other clans decided that they couldn't share even though they could and they had to be greedy and force them out. And to make it worse ThunderClan took over Skyclan's old territory and pretended like nothing ever happened. I don't like that the Clans later realized what they did was wrong and instead of keeping Skyclan's memory alive, they forgot about Skyclan and pretended they didn't exist. I am so glad Skyclan came back to the lake territories and to give them another chance because what happened was so unfair. I really like Skyclan too because I feel like we don't know this clan as much and all the other clans have too much greedy and mean in ...more

It reminds me of the Urban Renewal and Highway Building.
Minorities were barely acknowledged by the cities, and their neighborhoods would get highways built through them, like how ThunderClan chased SkyClan out because they needed more territory.
For more info on this,
look it up dumbass.

I don't like skyclan to be honest so I'm kinda glad.

SkyClan is best in the gorge.

9 The great journey

This always makes me sad for some reason. The newer books aren't nearly as good In my opinion, but also because the clans had been living there for basically forever, and then treecutters go brrrr

This was probably the part that dragged in the most. It just got boring, that is until they killed sharp tooth and did all that but after that, it kinda just got boring. I would've skipped it if I didn't care if I missed an important part. That's why I put this on the list.

The great journey shouldn't have happened. They should have stayed in the forest all along and Power of Three should have taken place there.

I actually really liked the great journey. It wasn't just important in the storyline, it was also important for character development.

10 Firestar loses a life and Russetfur dies

Russet fur was born a rogue, but she has a warriors heart. She gave up her life as a rogue to be a warrior. Firestar losing his life was tragic too. It was a battle that should never have happened.

Two deaths in one battle? It went in this order: russetfur starts an attempt to kill Firestar (what a butt), lionblaze accidently kills russetfur, Firestar loses a life, shadowclan hates lionblaze mostly but thunderclan is also hated and flametail becomes an annoying bratty character. Just saying, it's true.

I hate this. I don't personally like firestar, but I didn't want him die. Why did russetfur tryto kill him? And why did that stupid Lionscrap, I mean lionblaze killed russet? Phh

That wasn't worth it for ShadowClan. The lost Russetfur and the battle.

The Contenders
11 Cinderpelt's death

I hated it when Cinderpelt died! She had been through so much already! I'll never forget how curious she was as an apprentice and how wise and calm she became when she was med. It broke my heart when she died.

I personally LOVED her and cried buckets when she died. It was so sad! I prefer the original to CinderHEART.

Cinderpelt had her whole life before her! She died a young age.

Any cat but Cinderpelt!

12 Scourge enters the forest

Why does everyone loves him? He's that cringe "depressed kid", I mean, yeah, he was bullied but that doesn't mean he had to do all of this :/

I hate scourge, Scourge fangirls are everywhere! He killed Tigerstar with dumb dog teeth! Scourge is the worst.
Firestar: I don't want to hurt your clan, just get out
Scourge: Never! I will stay and make the forest BloodForest!
starclan: ARGHh

Scourge is the best bad-guy in a series that is seriously lacking villains with motivations.

I don't like Scourge. I don't even know how the fandom can love him so much.

13 Bluestar's death

This part should no of happend! It was so sad. To be honest Fire Star got really boring after the Prophecy begins. Bluestar needed to live longer I don't think FireStar should of become leader. He was really young and did not have that much experince. TIGER STAR IS THE WORST!

Bluestar needed to die. She was a great character, but Firestar would never have gotten to be leader, so it kinda needed to happen.

Bluestar is the best character in the series and she didn't deserve to die!

*Bluestar licks her chest self-consciously*
Thanks guys!

14 Windclan gets chased out

Yeah, I guess this would be my second choice...But they do come back, so not that much...

15 Graystripe is kidnapped

Gray stripe, the thunderclan deputy, Is taken away and Firestar loses his best friend. How sad. Graystripe comes back, it's just bad he gets taken away.

Graystripe should have been kidnapped. If he hadn't he wouldn't have met Millie, and after all, he came back...

I was so angry about this! If he hadn't been kidnapped then Brambleclaw would never be leader and I would be happy

16 Feathertail's death

Why is Feathertail such a loved character, heck, she hardly did anything throughout her appearances. Her death wasn't sad in the slightest, dunno why everyone loved her so much.

Stupid Feathertail haters. She's so kind and patient. You're all the worst for hating her :l

So drawn out and ruined Crowfeather for way too long.

17 Hollyleaf's fake death and the real one

Hey! Remember that female character who died a while back?
You know, the one that everyone accepted, since bad stuff happens all the time in the wild, and they quickly replaced her with a better team member?
Guess what? SHE'S ALIVE
Hollyleaf's death was believable, and the clan lost nothing by losing her. She had no impact on the plot before she died, except being a side character. They just did this to get another girl in there.

Hollyleaf fake dies, and dies for real. It's just sad! This is the second saddest death I know of.

This was just stupid. They brought her back after 2 books just to kill her again!

I totally hate Hawkfrost for this, and I absolutely hated Leafpool for lying.

18 Bluestar calls Firestar a traitor

It's not Bluestar's fault. She didn't have a clear mind when it happened. Though, I did feel bad for Firestar when that happened.

WHY! At that moment when I read this all of my love for Bluestar went away and turned to hatred! She even betrayed starclan! like what the heck Bluestar!

He's not a traitor! I love Bluestar so much but I got really angry at her at this moment.

Wasn't Firestar Bluestar's like favorite cat?

19 The great battle

So many of my favorite characters died!

Eh,the great battle ended tiger star and the dark forest,so it wasn't all that bad even tho a bunch of cats died.

20 Dogs are let loose (by Tigerclaw)

Why does Tigerclaw have to e so evil?

21 Stormkit's accident and when his name changes to Crookedkit

So sad! He's only kit! how can you expect a young infant to obey all the rules! Rainflower was too mean! I can't seriously understnad why erins brought her to starclan; she should be assigned to dark forest where she sucks and rotts and probably attempts to bully other disabled kittens until she is chased away in the Great battle!

It was all Goosefeather's fault. If Crookedstar was still a Storm, he would be named Stormcloud or Stormclaw or something cool and his dream name, Stormstar.

So Sad! Give me a mug so I can drink my tears!

I'm actually reading Crookedstar's Promise right now as I write this so this hits extra hard

22 Tigerclaw becomes Tigerstar

So I was reading the books, everything going as normal, then suddenly, Tigerstar is apparently the leader of ShadowClan? I wanted to bang my head against a wall. ShadowClan is smarter than to put a murderous traitor as leader out of the blue. No, just no.

What the heck! He did not deserve to be leader!

23 Ivypaw's hatred of Dovepaw Ivypaw's hatred of Dovepaw

If Ivypaw had never hated Dovepaw, she would never have gone to the Dark Forest. If she never went to the Dark Forest, she couldn't have ruined her sister's relationship with Tigerheart. And I totally ship TigerheartxDovewing! Also, all over the internet I see people saying they hate Dovewing, or they hate Ivypool because of the sister's relationships. It's seriously not fair and it makes me sad because they become really close in the end and you shouldn't be taking sides because there are no sides!

If this had never happened, more people would like them the same. Because I feel like it's either you like Dovewing or you like Ivypool. And when I see harsh comments about them it makes me sad. So, if this had never happened, I feel like more people would like them around the same.


Yeah, I honestly wish that Ivypool didn't have a perspective with her reasoning so she doesn't convince all of the fans that her whining is justified.

I love Dovewing, I like Hollyleaf more, a lot of people find 'excuses' to hate her, though it was IVYPAW who started being a brat first! and Dovewing only snapped at her ONCE! Don't say you don't fight with your sister! but jealousy is so dumb, Squirrelflight was never jealous of everyone liking LEafpool and finding her annoying, Leafpool wasn't jealous of Squirrelflight for being allowed to have a mate, and kits not in secret, and Alderheart was a little jealous of Sparkpelt but he didn't shut her out and hiss at her all the time for it! they stayed close and she made him feel so special about being a medicine cat in that one scene!
Ivypaw is just the WORST her and Clear sky are the only main characters I hate, (I used to hate Violetshine and Jayfeather as Jaypaw but they DEFINITELY grew on me, Jaybean for life! )
And Ivypaw with her, "Why do you get to be special?! I wanna be special! " Then she is special and whines to her sister about it.
Like, how does everyone love ...more

24 Mapleshade chain

(My opinion)
It's not Reedshine's or Appledusk's fault that she became "evil"...
Like...I mean...Appleduk may have cheated or something but Mapleshade was like: wHaT! hE rEgReTs mEetInG mE? hOw CoUlD hE!?
And I mean Reedshine was rude, but Why shouldn't she be?
I mean she said like: Go Mapleshade, you have caused enough trouble,
But Mapleshade kinda overreacted...


It was so hard to choose from all of these sad moments but this one, I immediately thought I would vote for this. She didn't deserve what she got! Personally, I absolutely hate Appledusk. Just my opinion, I think he was cruel to Mapleshade.

Just really depressing.

Mapleshade suffered. It was all Appledusk and Reedshine's fault.

25 Breezepelt lives

Nah, l read Crowfeather's trail and the book is a redemption arc done right (for Breezepelt). I absolutely loved reading it and redeems Breezepelt and now l see him in a whole different light. Yes, it doesn't excuse him trying to (SPOILERS) kill Poppyfrost & Jayfeather but please just read the book

He would be dead on my watch...

He should've died...

Like, serisously? I don't want him to die, but he seriosuly went unpunished even though he tried to kill clan cats?

8Load More
PSearch List