Top 10 Most Mysterious Warrior Cats
Bramblestar or Hawkfrost? Mistystar or Bluestar? Here is a list of the most mysterious Warrior Cats ever created in the series!
During his life, Hawkfrost was at the border between evil and good. Kind of evil, as he followed his father, but kind of good, because he was a good friend to Brambleclaw.
After his death, however, he moved to the Dark Forest, but even then, he managed to fall in love, which shows that he was the only one remaining with a heart. Mysterious, I agree.
He is actually really nice with Sasha, which was one reason I kinda admired him. He's mysterious and wants to follow Tigerstar more than all of his siblings: Mothwing, Brambleclaw, and Tawnypelt.
He was basically the reason Mothwing became a medicine cat, but I hated him when he threatened her with that moth's wing secret. Plus, he got his own prophecy with Brambleclaw: Before there is peace, blood will spill blood, and the lake will run red.
~Owlpaw

It's confusing how he drags or touches cats. They say he can't.
Plus, how does he have the power to control dead cats with his mind?
(Spoiler alert) He apparently helped Hawkfrost, but that's barely mentioned. It also isn't explained how he got into StarClan or what made him try to murder.
Ashfur is creepy. He always gets ready for a fight, and to me, he's just weird.

He was seen leaving camp. A few days later, Princess gives Fireheart Cloudtail, and Darkstripe is against keeping him. Maybe he is against kittypets because he was in love with one. One named Princess...
Darkstripe is the barrier between good and evil. He tried to murder Sorrelkit and yet he declined Tigerstar. Mysterious...
He was never mentioned in Bluestar's Prophecy, yet he is in Into the Wild.
Known to have a crush on Tigerstar, we barely see this cat!

Her birth broke the warrior code, and she killed Ashfur in fear of him revealing the truth over her family. She lived in the tunnels for a while, before rejoining ThunderClan. Hollyleaf was slain by Hawkfrost and spent her last... read more
Hollyleaf is a kind cat, but she can get vicious when cats don't understand her. But she never should've died! Hollyleaf is just really creepy to me...
I just love Hollyleaf. I play with my friends, and I am Hollyleaf all the time!
Yes, she just hid in a tunnel and popped out to save Ivypool's life.

Tigerstar, leader of TraitorClan and ShadowClan, is really creepy. Hawkfrost is kinda like him. Same pelt, same attitude! Come on, Tigerstar, you made your own Clan and called it TraitorClan? Really? (TigerClan is TraitorClan.)

Yellowfang is probably just depressed. She is mysterious. Yellowfang is just an awkward cat. I have no idea why, but I do think like this...

Brokenstar is SO creepy. Always kills, always is like a Tigerstar Jr... Weird...

Crowfeather is an unknown kind of cat. He is always grumpy, it seems like... Weird. Whatever, he's just odd...
In other words, literally me.
When I get mad, no one ever knows why. Not even me.
Rock is very mysterious. He has existed since...well...time began. He is very old, has no fur left, and is blind.
He is the oldest warrior cat, cursed to live forever. He is friends with a badger, Midnight, and is very interesting. Jayfeather knows the most about him and knows very little...
Rock was very creepy in my opinion. The way they described him and the way he sounded? Very creepy.
Rock should be #1! All we know is he is a cat who has existed forever!

Bramblestar is kinda odd. I guess he has a little of creepy Tigerstar in him. Also, Bramblestar does have creepy eyes like his father... I dunno... He's just odd...
Bramblestar: Hi, Squirrelflight, wanna go boss everyone around?
Squirrelflight: No.
Bramblestar: Okay, I'm going to leave you for a kittypet I just met because you were loyal to your sister!
In The Broken Code, his soul turns out to be Ashfur taking revenge on Squirrelflight.
The Newcomers

I don't know. We just don't know much about him!

Sol (SPOILER) apparently has SkyClan roots! And he even looks like a lion and talks in an oddly calm voice (shaped like a lion).
He wants cats to not obey the warrior code and to not believe in StarClan. That is kind of weird.

He is older than the Clans, yet he hasn't faded. Also, any dead cat in love with the living I consider slightly mysterious. I just see a mystery x living pattern.
Why is his spirit in the tunnels? Why not the other cats who died in there? Why isn't he with StarClan or some type of warrior ancestor?
What a confusing character! He was somewhat alive while trapped in the tunnels, yet a spirit.
Yes. The mysterious Jay's Wing. He and Lion's Roar, as well as Dove's Wing, are part of an old prophecy, the oldest of them all (for now).
He is Jayfeather's alternate body, which Jayfeather switches to at mysterious times, like when sleeping, or in certain locations. The love of Half Moon's heart, when he disappeared back into Jayfeather, she was devastated. He lives now, as Jayfeather.
Disappeared in the middle of a journey?!

Hawkheart was a WindClan medicine cat under Heatherstar’s leadership in the forest territories. He originally served as a warrior before becoming a medicine cat. He was said to have an unusually... read more
Is he evil? Is he in the Dark Forest?


SpottedLeaf did not deserve to die twice. She was a good cat! And where is she now? I hope it is someplace good!


We know a lot about Scourge, but not Bone.
We know nothing about the poor kit. She never needed to die. It's not her fault her mother (Yellowfang) took a forbidden mate.
All we know about her is that she never opened her eyes to the real world. It's more sad than mysterious, really.


Who are his parents? Who are his littermates?


His mentor is Darkstripe, and he was friends with Tigerstar. He also made fun of Firestar.