Top Ten Things Wrong With Warrior Cats

I LOVE the Warrior Cats series. It's a very good series, but there are things wrong with it. Here are some of them. I'm sorry if this list is kinda inacurrate

The Top Ten

1 Erin Hunter not giving Hollyleaf a power just because they couldn't think of a power for her

To be honest, Dovewing wasn't that bad. When Hollyleaf hid in the tunnels after the other cats think she died, Dovewing could become but the third cat. Then, Hollyleaf could become the fourth cat all along, instead of Firestar. Firestar is in many prophecies, which is utter nonsense.

Powers? As in Draikinator's video on the topic, Hollyleaf would be awesome with the power to know a cat's true intentions/when they're lying,


Why not communication with StarClan, but she loses it for a while after she kills Ashfur? - RoseWeasley

That is extremely annoying

Yeess! Dovewing totally ducked, and Hollyleaf would be much better! I wish Stupid ugly Dovewing died in the Battle instead of amazing Hollyleaf.

V 17 Comments
2 ThunderClan always being the hero while other clans especially ShadowClan are always the enemies

And that's why I love river clan

I agree. Every ThunderClan cat is always remembered (usually) but none of my friends can remember the other Clans warriors, but can their most recent leaders. Have respect, chirren.

I know! I totally AGREE! lol. I don't think Thunderclan should get ALL the glory! - WalkingMonster

Which clan introduced Warrior training? Windclan.
Which clan had the first medicine cat? Windclan.
Which clan has the only territory without trees? Windclan.
Windfall is the most unique clan. They should at least have a part in Broken Stars, but no. The Erins let the new clan have a point of view.

V 17 Comments
3 Dovewing being the third cat when she did almost nothing

I see the ones below this and think wow most of those are ridiculously stupid better vote for a less stupid one. For example 14 because the injury that scourge inflicted on firestar wasn't as fatal as the injury inflicted to tiger star it mentions IN THE BOOK that firestar dodged the blow that had taken all of tiger stars lives. Sorry for the hate but this is plain stupid. Now another example is 9 Sorry your argument actually goes against science! Cats can have many different colour pigments and patterns also there may be dormant genes so ya broke the myth. This last one the no gay couples one isn't stupid but let's think your right there should be gay couples it would add more plot and is just rude to ignore them as these cats are sentient cats from what in know are only sexually attracted to the opposite sex. Though these are sentient cats and I agree there should be gay couples. Now look at the others with a new understanding really the farther down you go the worse it gets. Sorry ...more

Dovewing just obsessed over this guy she liked. Every other cat in the entire kriffing SERIES actually did something. (Excluding Silverstream and Spottedleaf) - RiverClanRocks

Let's be real, she's just thrown in for more unnecessary token romance and drama...

Dovewing just do something chose bumlestripe or tigerheart! Make yourselt more than a hollyleaf replacement! (which you are )

V 3 Comments
4 Erin Hunter brought back Hollyleaf just to kill her in the next book

Really? That's not FAIR! - WalkingMonster

HECK YEAH! ALL HAIL HOLLYSTAR! This is OBVIOUSLY why HollyClan is a thing. Yeah, Hollyleaf deserves better, she doesn't even have a POWER! what.

This pissed me off so hard when I found out (through spoilers) that I actually refused to read the rest of the books. Why give her all of that development just to kill her off again? Lazy writing?

What was that for I thought it was going to be better. But once you think about it what did she every come back in the first place and Hawkfrost that kills her why not Tigerstar

V 3 Comments
5 Too many forbidden couples

The forbidden couple is an annoying trope in general. What makes it even worse is how cats never get any sort of punishment for it. A good example is Leafpool. She ruined the lives of other cats, and what happens? Nothing! And that's just one example. It happens too many times to count. It's almost like the writers are running out of ideas so they grip onto the same thing over and over.

- this is very, very repetitive. when I read a new warriors book, I often sense a possible future relationship, a very repetitive plot, cats from other clans with cats from other clans together. There might not even be a definitive sign, but you just know something forbidden or "special" is to happen ( says the repeating plot and character development and " last book problem resolved " kind of thing). So,...have alll the kits you want cats, "totally not forbidden and not known of" - sorry for long text, had to be quite honest

UGH YES. Why can't the cats just follow the warrior code? - RiverClanRocks

So overused. Everyone's forgiven if they fall in love over the border.

V 2 Comments
6 Ashfur being accepted by StarClan

Ashfur tries to kill four cats, yet is in StarClan. Thistleclaw kills no one yet is in the dark forest.

Thistleclaw is a pedophile. He was romantically interested in Spottedleaf when she was a young apprentice and manipulated her. He was the reason why she turned from a warrior apprentice to a med. cat apprentice

Yes, Squirrelflight admitted she didn't feel the same way about him as he did about her. And yes, that is a reason to feel bad. But no, that is not a reason to try and kill your ex's children.

He tried to kill four cats.

End of story.

7 Spottedleaf stalking Firestar even though she's dead

Spottedleaf is awesome and you all know it! SHE SAVED KITS FROM DYING, FOR PETE'S SAKE! Can we have a little respect? They both loved each other and Spottedleaf sacrificed herself so Firestar wouldn't have to choose between herself and Sandstorm. That deserves respect.

Spottedleaf is a pedophile..

Can we make a book where Spottedleaf dies... repeatedly?

Exactly. Spottedleaf sucks, and Sandstorm did something useful. - RiverClanRocks

V 5 Comments
8 Firestar being part of almost every prophecy

I hate this so much WHY is Firestar so important. WHY did he have to be part of everyone?! He can hardly fight!

Formula for when the series gets too boring: Battle, prophecy, Firestar wins. - RiverClanRocks


Come on Erin Firestar is an important cat almost every prophecy the power of 3 one shouldn't involve Firestar. Lets review Spottedleaf Cinderpelt and Skywatcher-Duskstormofthuunderclan

9 Impossible genes

They should've studied biology, or at least read a couple books about cats. - RiverClanRocks

Yep. I've seen a ton of these of the Wikia. One of them being Shellheart ( dappled gray tom ) X Rainflower ( pale gray she-cat ) apparently equals Crookedstar ( light brown tabby tom ) and Oakheart ( reddish brown tom ) There is also Larksong ( tortoiseshell she-cat ) X Flamenose ( ginger tom ) equals Featherwhisker ( gray tom ) There's Skystar ( pale gray tom ) X Storm ( gray tabby she-cat ) equals Thunderstar ( ginger tom with a white splash ) There's Stagleap ( dark brown tom ) X Wrenflight ( brown she-cat ) which equals Ashfoot ( gray tom ) There's Mistmouse ( brown she-cat ) X Hareflight ( brown tabby tom ) equals Ryestalk ( gray tabby she-cat ) Dawn Mist ( Yellow-and-ginger tabby she-cat ) X Moss Tail ( dark brown tom ) equals Drizzle ( gray-and-white she-kit ) This might come from the mother's or father's parents ( So sorry if I keep saying Dovewing and Ivypool's father might be Ashfur because I checked and it's confirmed that their father is Birchfall )


10 Cats being able to talk within days of birth

It's a FICTION book so cats CAN talk within days of birth.

I think that cats in the WarriorCats series can that and open their eyes so quickly, is because cats have shorter lives than humans, 1 moon for a cat is like 1 year for humans in terms of life span. This for some reason does not apply to Mistystar, though.

It does make sense cause cats meow like a day after birth.
Meow, Meow!
Milk, Milk!

If cats could talk if would take ages for them to learn how to talk.

V 1 Comment

The Contenders

11 Mapleshade going to the dark forest

She did murder 2 cats and tried to murder another sooo


Yes, and ASHFUR gets to starclan, what type of nonsense is this?

12 A very repetitive plot

One day in _________ Clan...
Tom: I love you!
She-cat: But I can never be with you *knows she'll end up with him anyway*
She-cat+Tom: *touch noses*
Moons later...
Tom: Hmm I say we give them to your clan:(
She-cat: Nuu can't leave u! :'(
She-cat: *has kits*
Tom: *goes back to _____Clan*
Kit 1: Mommy where's my dad?!
She-cat: *depressed.

13 Names that don't make sense

Billystorm is a great name, you do know that a Billy Club is a deadly weapon, don't you

Personally, I think there are a lot of repetitive possibilities with names (hey, I have an OC named Stormstorm). Mumblefoot? Harveymoon? My personal favorite...Daisytoe. "Oh wow! A daisy near my foot! IT MUST BE A SIGN."

It’s a book. Just like in real life, names don’t make sense

Like people have the name jack, but it doesn’t make sense

And twigbranch’s name does make sense. It represents her growth from a twig to a branch.

The all ready existing names kind of work but hear is a list of possible names that don’t make sense (based off the all ready existing names) FeatherFeather, LeafLeaf, StarStar, FrostFrost, WindWind, and my personal favorite RavenRaven

V 1 Comment
14 No gay couples

Well, the Erin's couldn't make a gay couple because the book series is worldwide and they couldn't make it because some countries don't allow gay marriage and people might get offended. Though, Ravenpaw and Barley are obviously together and Tallstar and Jake.
But they couldn't make any official gay couples as I said before.

1. Tallstar x Jake & Ravenpaw x Barley are considered to be canon.
2. Even if they weren't, it still wouldn't be bad. - RoseWeasley

That's good to me.

top gay couples I ship
1. Jake and Tallstar
2. Ivypool and Blossom fall
3. Dovewing and Briar light
4. Sasha and Leopardstar
5. Whitestorm and Tigerstar

V 1 Comment
15 Tigerstar losing all his lives when scourge killed him, yet firestar only loses one.

It is like they WANTED tigerstar dead

I just voted for this so I can set things straight... Tigerstar never got his nine lives from Starclan. He didn't actually randomly lose every single life when scourge killed him.

Ummm... how does this make sense? Tigerstar is more powerful than Firestar by a mile and Scourge kills him in one blow. Firestar then dies to Scourge and cheats death some how. Then kills Scourge because suprise attack. What the heck Erin’s make a more logical plot Line! -Stormshard

16 The warrior code itself

Yes, let's all get diseases from mating with cousins and relatives for YEARS and eventually mating your littermate (Yes, I'm looking at you, Willowpelt and Patchpelt)

It's gross

The cats will eventually all die from genetic mutations

Oh! Let’s keep separate all the clans so every clan can INBREED inside Itself and everyone can be related to everyone.


17 StarClan is biased

Mapleshade: Had a harsh life, and killed cats out of fury. I mean, her kits drowned, her mate rejected her, her Clan rejected her, and she had nowhere to go.
StarClan: Whelp, lol, Dark Forest for you! See ya!

Ashfart: Went insane due to getting dumped by Squirrelflight, and attempted to murder her family, also helped plot to kill Firestar.
StarClan: Welcome to StarClan! - Emberflight_of_StormClan

There’s a logical reason behind Thistleclaw going to the Dark Forest, but what about Mapleshade? Her mate replaced her, her kits died in front of her, her Clanmates betrayed her. She killed one cat and caused the blindness and eventual death of one. And she gets sent to the Dark Forest.
I mean, multiple signs point to insanity/schizophrenia!
If Ashfur tried to kill four cats ‘out of love’, then Mapleshade did too. The only reason she killed Ravenwing and Frecklewish was because she ‘saw’ her kits begging her to avenge them. It fhat’s not love, I don’t know what is!
Mapleshade was a depressed, insane mom avenging her children. Ashfur was a depressed, insane loser who was so angry that his girlfriend for two weeks dumped him, he decided to murder her family.

18 Names like FeatherFeather are possible


Featherfeather, storm storm, berryberry, clawclaw,starstar, leafleaf, cloudcloud, breezebreeze, there. That’s what I know.

It makes absolutely no sense at all! None! Also, names like StormStorm, StarStar, ClawClaw, WingWing, LeafLeaf, and CloudCloud are possible.

19 WAY too many books, not enough story!

This may be the reason immma stop reading warriors.

The first few books were great, but the Erin’s are just repeating the same old storyline over and over. Quit adding extra pointless books! And yes, read Wings of Fire! It is a great story! #Glorybringerrules

Man, it got repetative. Too many cats, too much drama, no sense. If u want a good read, try wings o fire. Same style of writing, but a more interesting and better thought out story.

20 Snowkit dies just to move Speckletail to the elders' den

Whey even have snowkit then?

That was depressing

21 Erin Hunter confused Thistlepaw, Sedgepaw and Swallowpaw's genders

Don't forget Rowanclaw!

Yes. Sedgepaw is a she-cat and now a tom. I mean SERIOUSLY

22 So many cats in thunderclan

Yes, I mean there must be like 40 or so now, I'm hoping for a huge purge in The Raging Storm because its getting ridiculous and I don't think the authors can keep track of them, let alone the readers.

23 Bloodclan


24 The Warrior Code is broken so many times

Cat 1: I'm gonna go marry this hawt cat from another Clan even though the law says not to. DERP
Cat 2: I LOVE you BABEH! *chases after cat 1*
Cat 1: We'll live happily ever after! Yay! - RiverClanRocks

I totally agree and Thundeclan has BROKEN the Warrior Code more times than I can remember. Why can't most cats follow the rules of the forest. I still don't und understand why did their ancestors even lay out the laws in the first place if every warrior we now has broken it! I can list nurmerous cats that have broken the Warrior Code:


Those are some rule-braking cats though I bet there's more out there.

25 Bizarre matings
26 Graystripe still thinks Mistystar is his daughter, who's actually his cousin in law that is older than him

Dude graystripe. Mistystar was a warrior when you were a kit

For me Mistystar is just like Feathertail and Stonefur is just like Stormfur.But,Sorry Erin but that mistake was ridiculous - cassiabez

27 Why is there even a Dark Forest

Sending cats to dark forest makes everything even worse

28 Firestar is somehow related to Tigerstar

Yes he is and he is half-brother to FRIKKEN SCOURGE WHY WORLD!

No he's not

29 Stupid names for things

Twolegs, Thunderpath, Monsters, Twoleg nests, etc. PLEASE PASS THE BLEACH

30 Spottedleaf having a gross crush on Firepaw

Think about it: Spottedleaf was about 4 years old/49 moons when she died, meaning she had been (If my reasoning correct) somewhere around 45 or 44 moons when Firepaw arrived. FIREPAW WAS 6 MOONS OLD AT THE TIME. Firepaw had just barely reached sexual maturity, whereas Spottedleaf would have likely retired to the elder's den in a year or so. THIS IS LITERAL PEDOPHILIA. The Erins are just horrible with relationships like that; revolting age gaps, love after very few interactions, incest (e.g. Graystripe's parents), etc. It's absolutely disgusting.


not sure how anyone sane can ship them

That’s not pedo cats are adults after 6 months

31 Cats changing genders

Well Shellheart did. - cassiabez

32 Bluestar's life sucked

Mom killed, Sister killed, gives up kits, tigerclaw/star is a traitor, goes insane, mistyfoot/stonefur hate her, dies by dogs (that is best part of her life technicaly) good afterlife in starclan

33 Hawkfrost is ugly

Yeh. If I were in the warriors world, I'd claw his ears off.

I hate him after killing Hollyleaf I even call him Dorkfrost because he is stupid. They shouldn't have added him, and if they did then BRAMBLESTAR IS DA BEST :D he killed him. I wish Hawkfrost would just vanish

34 Every Single Greencough Death

As moonkitti once said:

“Rest in peace offscreen casualties.”

35 Too Predictable

By the way read my username and my profile picture. :3 - WarriorCatsHater

36 The leaders lose their lives too often.

Firestar and Bluestar both died it is so sad but to be honest they would basically die of age nine times and suffer it all so it does make sense

37 For some reason the clans aren't united into one clan even though it would end all the drama in the series and make the group stronger.


38 Firestar dying

Well what's the matter of making him an elder then he move on the Elder's den then we would still see him in the books. - cassiabez

39 Pinestar is older than Leopardfoot, and her parents

It's just weird! Imagine something like that in real life though...

40 People like villains for no reason
41 The Erin's not being able to decide on colors (e.g. Crowfeather's eyes, Dovewing's eyes, Scourge's collar, Bone's collar...)
42 Obvious writing

I mean! Why do you have to write something that is obvious!

43 Everything changes every five minutes.
44 Too many Mary/Gary Sues

Seriously over half the characters...

Ahem ahem *alderheart* ahem ahem

45 The cats speak by meowing

Cats do not simply talk to each other by meowing.

46 The Dirtplace

This was my biggest problemo. Cats are clean animals, I know because I have one. WHO is cleaning up the dirtplace?!?!? Not them! After awile, it would smell so bad and be so full of uh dirt that they wouldn't want to go there!

47 Bark face living before Tallstar and dying after
48 Barkface living longer than Tallstar and being older than him.
49 Hollyleaf is a murderer


50 How much walking they do in The New Prophecy (TNP)


8Load More
PSearch List