Top 10 Warrior Cats that Deserved to Be in StarclanMellowix Maybe some of the Dark Forest cat out there aren't as evil as we think they are and deserve their spot in Starclan.
The Top Ten
WHY IS BRIGHTFLOWER IN THE DARK FOREST? she is literally 50 times better than Ashfur. She didn't do anything wrong!
It's not fair that Ashfur went to StarClan after threatening to kill 4 cats, but good cats like Brightflower and Lilywhisker went to the Dark Forest for being mad at something that everyone else would've been mad at too!
Yellowfang's mother. According to Su, she couldn't handle the death of her two kits after she thought her older daughter murdered them. And when Brokenstar revealed it was him, she couldn't understand it because she wasn't "sane enough". What? So a cat is sent to the Dark Forest because they were emotionally unstable after their kits were murdered and they were made to believe it was older kits? That's just cruel. - Mellowix
Seriously erins really?!
Similar with Lilywhisker. She went to the Dark Forest because "she couldn't accept her fate" after her injured her back leg, sending her to the Elder's den too early. Su seems to quite insensitive when it comes to people with mental illnesses and life changing injuries. Because apparently those are enough to seen you to the Dark Forest. Not for murdering or betraying anyone but simply because you were angry for a justified reason. - Mellowix
Brokenstar's adopted brother and the son of Lizardstripe. What did he do? He never supported Brokenstar. And he was always a loyal warrior, doing his job. Never once, did we see him kill someone or anything like that. - Mellowix
I guess he really shouldn't have, but he kinda wanted to-? He said it was better then Starclan? Uh.., but I guess he sorta deserves to be here, but they might have sent hime to Starclan if he'd wanted to instead of da Dark Forest...
A Dark forest trainee. Killed by Thistleclaw and then a 2nd time by Ivypool. Was manipulated by the Dark Forest and Starclan never once tried to reach out and help him. Not to mention, there wasn't anything he could do to leave the Dark Forest training. Beetlewhisker tried it and instantly got killed off Brokenstar snapped his spine. There are many other Dark Forest trainees that got off scott-free, he why not him? - Mellowix
A Cat that appeared in Tallstar's revenge and Yellowfang's secret. Same with Deerfoot, what did he do wrong? - Mellowix
A Dark Forest trainee who fought one the Dark Forest's side in New Hope and got killed by Blackstar. Similar thing with Antpelt. Didn't do anything apart from fighting on the "wrong" side. I think when it's being decided where a cat should go after their deaths, they should be judged for their own individual actions, not the actions of their group or someone else, they happened to be loyal to. It shouldn't be a matter of sides or loyalty. Every group should be judged equally. - Mellowix
Ashfur managed to get into starclan and he didn't. Thistleclaw didn't kill anyone when ashfur attempted to kill 4!
He's battle hungry and arrogant, yes, but plenty of other "good" cats are the same way.
Mudclaw, who started a civil war because he was angry that Onestar was chosen as leader over him, and Blackstar, who followed Brokenstar and Tigerstar's orders to the letter despite them being horrific come to mind.
The vast majority of his "evil" comes from Bluestar's, very biased, point of view on him and late-series retcons to make him look worse done by Vicky, who's openly stated that she hates him for whatever reason.
The point is, Thistleclaw was screwed over by the writers bias against him.
So you're saying a cat who encouraged his apprentice to beat up a helpless kit & manipulated an underaged cat should be in StarClan? - RoseWeasley
I'd say the main reason people see Thistleclaw as evil is simply because the book he stared in "Bluestar's prophecy" and it's from Bluestar's point of view. Because she's the main character, it makes it seems the stuff she does is justified and everything Thistleclaw does is worse then anything she could ever do. Personally I think Bluefur and Thistleclaw are just as bad as each other. - Mellowix1 Comment
Was Brokenstar's adopted sister. I admit she was loyal to Brokenstar. However she was typically following the warrior code by following her leader. Not to mention, wasn't you follow your brother/sister if they were leader? Never killed anyone. Was forced to become a rouge against her will, with no fair trial. When Thunderclan attacked, she'd be expecting for her Clanmates to help defend their camp but imagine how confusing it must of been to have your trusted clanmates suddenly turn on you and treat you like an enemy.
That's one I've always been confused about. In the exile of Brokenstar and his followers, how was it decided who were "Brokenstar's followers"? Did cats go crazy and just accuse each other and drive out who ever they didn't like? - Mellowix
Maple shade is literally me when I'm hungry and need food.
Well you see I’m not sure if she will kill any more cats is she was in StarClan...I THINK
Mapleshade honestly deserves her place in the Dark Forest. - Mellowix
I'm only really putting her here because I have fill out ten spaces... - Mellowix
He thinks he's a tree - Murphypaw
Demented by hatred.
He had a tough childhood, I'll give him that. But that doesn't excuse him for; training and killing kits, banishing the elders and Yellowfang, driving out Windclan, Killing his own father and plotting with Tigerclaw. - Mellowix
He's not dead yet but he will probably go to the dark forest just for his thoughts,that's like not giving cloudtail an afterlife
Hollyleaf is in starclan because she -
Dies protecting ivypool from hawkfrost - Murphypaw
SHE REALLY SHOULD BE IN STARCLAN IF SHE IS NOT THERE WHERE IS SHE?
Holy leaf went to the dark forest?
She didn't go to the Dark Forest. Just because she didn't appear in Starclan doesn't mean she isn't out there somewhere.
Same as Mapleshade. - Mellowix
He is only evil because his mentor encouraged him. If he had a different mentor then he would probably be like white storm.
I know he is in StarClan
He was the best ThunderClan leader HE DOES NOT HAVE THE RIGHT TO BE IN STARCLAN!
YES - Hanjax70
Someone should really Change this image - Murphypaw
"Nightpaw recovered from his coughing fit and trotted over to her [Yellowfang]. Before he left, his brother Clawpaw touched his nose to the small apprentice's ear. "Get well soon! " he mewed." He was only obeying his Clan leader! And look at how kind he is to his brother!
One-eye one-eye - Murphypaw
He did go to starclan the butthole
Related ListsCats Who Deserved to Go to the Dark Forest (Warriors) Top Ten Made Up Clans that Could Also Represent StarClan Top Ten Deputies In Warriors Who Deserved to Be Leader Top Ten Movies That Deserved to Win an Academy Award for Best Animated Feature But Didn't Top 10 Game of Thrones Characters that Deserved Their Deaths
2 years, 57 days old