Top 10 Things that Shouldn't Have Happened in Warrior Cats

I don't really hold it against ThunderClan to exile Mapleshade. She lied to them and betrayed them by mating with the murderer of two of their clanmates and using the victims' names for her own selfish gain to protect herself.

However, they had no right to exile the kits. They're completely innocent. They can't control who their parents are. They're just as much victims of Mapleshade's lie as any other ThunderClan cat, thinking their father was dead when he was actually alive.

Exile Mapleshade, not the kits.

Haha. I'm glad some people agree with me. Spottedleaf is too dramatic, and Firestar is too good for her. Sandstorm goes much better with him. I love Sandstorm. This should say "Spottedleaf being born." They don't work out. Most people in the world are gonna hate me for this.

Erin Hunter, why the heck would this happen? Now my sister doesn't like Sandstorm. We see you, Erin. We see you. I watch you in your sleep. I watch you when you make Ashfur the worst villain ever. Begone, Spottedleaf!

It's like a middle school boy in love with a college kid that everyone (but me) likes. Then she notices he likes her and calls him at random times even when he is married and has kids, to flirt with him and try to steal him away.

Talk about ruined character potential. It would have been amazing to see the development of a deaf cat adapting to Clan life. If the Erins have the ability to write a blind character, they can write a deaf character. It just takes a bit of research and planning. Reducing a deaf kit's death as a way to move forward a subplot of a very minor character is lazy and possibly offensive.

Snowkit could have been so much more than just a deaf kit. He would have made for an interesting cat in the books! If any deaf people read it, it would encourage them that Snowkit survived. Snowkit was wasted potential. We could have seen him become a great medicine cat or even a warrior! Ugh. The Erins are infamous for throwing away good characters.

I honestly loved Hollyleaf! In my opinion, she was a great cat! I was so sad to see her die. I would rather have let Ivypool die than Hollyleaf (sorry to Ivypool lovers, but she's my fave character). I was devastated when Hollyleaf came back just to die in the last book!

Ugh, Hollyleaf was honestly an honorable cat that did almost nothing for her clan except save Ivypool. Although, lots of things wouldn't have happened without her. She is so overrated, and I hate her. I'm glad she died.

She did many bad things, but I loved her so much! She deserved to live again, with her friends, brothers, mother, and just her clan in general!

I could understand exiling Mapleshade. She did something wrong and was strong enough to survive on her own. But exiling three innocent kits? That would be the equivalent of arresting the children of a criminal even if the kids did nothing wrong!

It's not the kits' fault that their mother broke the warrior code. Oakstar made a terrible decision by exiling the kits. If Oakstar had kept the kits in ThunderClan, they wouldn't have drowned in the river. They could have been an asset to ThunderClan.

Hollyleaf should have kept her mouth shut and not said anything. Even if she had decided to blurt out the truth, it shouldn't have been at the Gathering. Instead, she should have confronted Squirrelflight and Leafpool and tried to understand why they lied in the first place. Her devotion to the Warrior Code was out of character and very hypocritical, as she had broken the code countless times in the past.

I just read Sunrise, and I can't think about this. She destroyed Leafpool and Squirrelflight's lives. They both loved those kits, and I hate Hollyleaf for this. Why at a gathering?

Also, why the hell did she kill Ashfur then? Leafpool lost her kits, her mate, and her role as a medicine cat. Squirrelflight lost her adopted kits and mate because of stupid, horrible Hollyleaf.

Poor Graystripe! His heart broke when his mate died. But this wasn't just a mate dying. It was a mate dying in a forbidden relationship that was the strongest love in the series while having kits.

She should've lived, then there wouldn't be that horrible Millie, and Blossomfall wouldn't be in the Dark Forest.

I agree it's sad. She died giving birth to her new kits. A life for two lives.

I agree that Firestar needs to die for the story to move on, but for Thor's sake, could they just make a character die of old age, peacefully, in his sleep, with his family with him? Is that too much to ask?

Actually, I like that this happened. It was sad at first, but now I realize that he's a player. I liked him as a warrior more than a leader. Plus, Bramblestar would never be leader, and I love him!

He was a good character, but I think he was better as a warrior. Also, it seemed like he had been leader for ages. We needed someone new.

Yellowfang should have just left Raggedstar and focused on being a medicine cat. In StarClan, she is very judgmental of those who have broken the code, especially Leafpool when she almost ran away with Crowfeather and had kits. She is also very hypocritical when she did the same thing.

I hate Raggedstar. Not just because he was her mate, but seriously, what did Yellowfang see in him? He was mean to her when she decided her destiny was healing, he had mood swings, and they probably would not have been good mates. I'll just say I was not sad when he died. If Brokenstar wasn't born, so many kits wouldn't have died.

Except for giving birth to Bristlefrost, her whole story is only rebellious alone. It just seems the writers wanted Dovewing to have a sibling by her side.

Alright. Why didn't StarClan say, "Hey, guys. She had a pretty terrible life, and everyone in the living world hates her. Let's give her another chance, maybe?" Blackstar, while he got his nine lives, got visions of the past to assure him that he was a good cat.

I think if StarClan did something like that for Mapleshade, she could have ended up in StarClan and been a better cat. Mapleshade was never bad, just broken, and StarClan did nothing to help her.
-Birdcreek's Opinion :)

She was not a good cat, and she deserved to go there, but she was an interesting character. I think she should have been able to redeem herself in some way. She wasn't evil at first, but she definitely didn't deserve to go to StarClan initially.

If it didn't happen, then Tigerstar would have lived, though.

Ok, Tigerstar was thinking like a total idiot. I mean, he could have lived.

That was his biggest mistake and downfall.

In my eyes, Cinderpelt always looked up to Firestar, and there was never any romance in it. It is very out of character for her to suddenly have romantic feelings for him.

I know you may not see this, but whoever said she didn't love Firestar is wrong. On the last page of River of Fire, A Vision of Shadows, she admits it to Alderheart, son of Squirrelflight and Bramblestar, after he nearly fell in love with a kittypet named Velvet. She said she gave up hope for him ever loving her because of her duty as a medicine cat.

When even the blind ones have some kind of use, why not the deaf ones? They just let him die because they did not know what to do with him.

This is right. Snowkit shouldn't have been taken away.

Make a decision, Erin Hunter! A kit gets taken away, then lives with some kittypet. I'm pointing at you, Princess! Princess, in her mind: Oh, I'm going to lie that Firestar is my brother to Snowkit and live on! Snowkit then feels betrayed and trains with some evil lady cat called Mapleshade. He trained with Brackenfur in the dark. Then Ashfur helped Hawkfrost set up some silly fox trap. Then the stupid fire starts.

Snowtuft (Snowkit) helps make the stupid fire. Then Snowtuft eventually wants to kill Firestar. Wow, Erin Hunter. Let's get back to my story. Sol works with Snowtuft. Ashfur gets slaughtered by a stone and Hollyleaf. Snowtuft tried to kill Jayfeather. Hollyleaf killed Snowtuft, and everyone's happy. Nope, Snowtuft died and went to StarClan and Dark Forest's border. He saw Firestar, Ferncloud, Speckletail, and... who was it? Oh, Ashfur.

Feathertail shouldn't have loved Crowfeather.

He would make Great and wise leader. I was expecting him to become leader After Firestar. Whitestar would be the best leader any clan could have wish for

Whitestorm was my fave character. I hate how he dies! I hate that he dies period!

Just... NO! She's a strong, independent woman. I'm okay with her having a mate, but KITTENS?! Do ALL female cats in ThunderClan need to make babies?

I actually like seeing a "bad girl" become someone who has a heart for someone...

Spottedleaf should have just stayed away from Firestar when she died and not huant his dreams repiadily as well as promise to be with him when he went to StarClan. It was very rude to both Firestar and Sandstorm when Spottedleaf was the one who gave Firestar the life for Love and had told him to love Sandstorm.