Saddest Moments in Fairy Tail

There are so many sad moments in Fairy Tail. I can't wait to see what you guys will say is the #1 based on your opinions!
The Top Ten
1 Juvia dies for Gray

This was by far one of the saddest moments in Fairy Tail of all time. They were forced to fight each other until one of them died, but they both sacrificed their lives. But, Gray lived, all because Juvia gave him some of her blood. He realized how much he loved her, he wanted revenge, he defeated Invel. Gray had to suffer more because of this, even though he didn't even know Wendy had healed Juvia and that she was still alive. He released his inner demon because of her death, he was tired of having people sacrifice their lives for him. He cried, he loved her, he realized that, he finally realized that. It made me cry so much. It was so sad that I cried for 30 minutes straight. Gray and Juvia are my 2 favorite characters, so that scene just made me cry a lot.

2 Ultear sacrifice
3 Lisanna returns
4 Sherria gives up her magic
5 Cait Shelter disappears
6 Lucy breaks Aquarius' key
7 Silver death
8 Mavis finds out Zera is an illusion

Mavis and zera were childhood friends and had done almost everything together. that's all I need to say.

9 Michelle (Imitatia) death
10 Future Lucy death
The Contenders
11 Igneel dies
12 Gildarts finds out Cana is his daughter
BAdd New Item