Warrior Cats that Should Go to the Dark Forest

The Top Ten Warrior Cats that Should Go to the Dark Forest

1 Ashfur

Yellowfang said: Ashfur didn't go in the Dark Forest because he didn't kill anyone. Darkstripe also didn't kill anyone but he went in the Dark Forest. So why? WHY? Is Ashfur in StarClan?

I HATE ashfur.
Just get over Squirrelflight. Get a new mate for goodness' sake

Maple shade was cast out of her clan back when cats actually cared when people broke the code. Her kits were drowned because she couldn't swim - which is not her fault because she was thunderclan. Then her mate cruelly abandons her, starts screwing another cat, she kills him, and is murdered by her apprentice. She goes to dark forest. IF ASHFUR GETS AWAY WENT ATTEMPTED MURDER because OF LOVE, WHY NOT MAPLESHADE!

I haven’t read about ashfur I have only watched the videos and like get OVER IT ALREADY like your sad I get but their are plenty she-cats get over it move on!

2 Mudclaw

I know that muclaw doesn't really deserve but still he's way worse than ashfur. I fell sorry for ashfur but I don't support his actions

How would you feel if a random cat came up to you and said "I'm leader now" while you were deputy? - Stormyblaze

He attempted to kill Onewhisker before he becomes Onestar. I say when he did that he bought his ticket to the Dark Forest.

He's not that bad but way worse than ashfur

3 Hawkheart

I don't care about the dumb herbs. Taking a cat's life was completely unnecessary and against the warrior code. He could've just chased her off, not KILLED her. Not only that, but he didn't even regret it! HE GLOATED OVER IT IN FRONT OF HIS VICTIM'S GRIEVING DAUGHTER! That's one of the cruelest things I can imagine. This is not a good cat and it's beyond me why anyone would stand up for him.

Hawk heart killed moonflower because she and some other cat were going to destroy the herb supply and that takes months to fix according to Brambleberry. Herbs are crucial especially in battle because they are used for wounds and any sickness passed on by other cats. Had the supply been destroyed, most of the cats wouldn't have livesd. Not to mention that the attack was unprovoked. Herbs are also used on kits and elders and they also play major roles in the clan. It was necessary for Hawkheart to kill Moonflower like is he going to just sit there and let her destroy the herb supply?

He killed Moonflower! and then, he didn't even try to deny it! Then he just goes ahead and acts casual and acts as if nothing happens!

And? Hawkheart was protecting his clan. Nearly his whole clan could have died if he didn't do something, he had to kill her. - BloodFang

I disagree! Am I the only person who really understands? Pinestar was wrong to send Thunderclan into war with Windclan and rip up all there herbs! If Hawkheart didn't kill Moonflower then Windclan could lose a lot of there cats out of Moonflower with no herbs to heal the sick and wounded! Even though I feel bad about Moonflower and Bluestar, Hawkheart did THE RIGHT THING! - BloodFang

4 Rainflower

I mean, she never killed anybody. However, she verbally abused her own son because of his injury. What kind of mother does that?

She is the reason why everything bad happened I hate Rainflower, GO TO THE DARKFOREST

She shouldn't go to the dark forest. It's such a minor offense according to star clan. Plus if she goes to the dark forest, so should Apple Dusk.

I hate this character. When I learned what she did to poor little crooked star, I cried some reason.

5 Appledusk

Appledusk was a traitor, lier, killer and the worst mate anyone could have. Appledusk deserved to go to the Dark Forest, not Mapleshade! - BloodFang

Appledusk had to choose his forbidden mate or his clan and other mate who was eventually going to have his kits. It was the right choice to choose and stay loyal to his clan. Would he really choose his forbidden mate who not only decided to bring her kits across the river during one of the worst floods in leaf bare but expected Appledusk to take her side when she was responsible for her kits deaths because she chose to bring them across a flooded river. Mapleshade decided to seek revenge on the clans and blames them for her kits deaths. She blamed everyone but herself for her kits deaths. It didn't help that she had hallucinations of her kits and said they were the real spirita of her kits. She chose to not let them go and live a healthier life. Appledusk didbrealize they're relationship was a mistake and that is valued in a warrior. He doesn't deserve the dark forest.


He didn't do anything to do deserve the Dark Forest - By that logic, every other Forbidden mate needs to go with him. - Mellowix

6 Liquidstripe

(Liquidstripe is a cool name, though.) - Pebblepaw

Who? - Aquastar_of_DewClan

7 Breezepelt

I actually really like breezepelt in if you read crowfeather's trial you'll know that he's a good cat - Murphypaw

I hate Breezepelt. He is now current mates with Heathertail and they only became mates to prove his loyalty to Windclan. Heathertail should 've been lionblazes mate. She didn't deserve him.Anyway Breezepelt does have Amber eyes
I HATE him because how he chose Dark forest over his mother, father, clan and STARCLAN.He shouldn't have been born.
If leafpool stayed Mates with crow then...
Sorry I just rant on and on about the cats I hate

Didn't he go to dark forest for a little. Well, he can't anymore. Breezepelt's not that bad. He just had weird parents. - Pebblepaw

He does not deserve a redemption. His motivations were unjust. - Stormyblaze

8 Sol

He didn't believe in the clans

He didn't believe in Starclan. - Stormyblaze

He sucks - ArcticWolf

oh I agree - spottedleafpool

9 Hollyleaf Hollyleaf was one of the rare, strictly loyal cats of ThunderClan. She cherished the warrior code as a kit and came back to her clan in a time of need to fight-- even though she was cast out for killing Ashfur.

SHE DIED FIGHTING HAWKFROST! How dare you put her in this list!
Oh and if I see Firestar on this, I WILL explode.

NO WAY! Just because she killed Ashfur, doesn't mean she was a bad cat. First of all, she didn't actually mean to kill him, the Hunters confirmed. Second, Ashfur gets to go to Starclan but she shouldn't? YES SHE SHOULD! Ashfur attempted to kill Firestar, Hollyleaf, Lionblaze, and Jayfeather, and sort of Squirrelflight but not entirely. He plotted with a cat from another clan, and tried to kill innocent cats. HE DESERVES DARK FOREST, NOT HOLLYLEAF!

I don't REALLY think she deserves the Dark Forest, but it totally pisses me of that people think Ashfur does while she gets to be totally innocent. They both did wrong, and if Ashfur "deserves" to rot in cat hell, she's going down with him!


10 Bluestar Bluestar is a character in the Warrior Cats series. She was one of the leaders of ThunderClan. She is mates with Oakheart of RiverClan and her kits, Stonefur and Mistyfoot, live in RiverClan. She has a deceased kit named Mosskit, a sister named Snowfur, a nephew named Whitestorm, a mother named Moonflower ...read more.

Bluestar is just dumb and stupid she should be number one
-she trusts no cat and denies the loyalty of several Warriors
-she didn't make swiftpaw warrior which leads to bright hearts face being injured and him dying
- she called brightheart lost face
-she hates thistleclaw
(Why?!?!?! )
Blue: that's right thistleclaw

Um...what did Bluestar do? - Pebblepaw

I hate her lol

What. Why da fudging fudge is she on here? - Darktail_of_FireClan

The Contenders

11 Oakstar

Ok. *deep breath*
Oakstar led attacks on kittypets in THEIR OWN HOMES!
He drove out Mapleshade, understandable. But he drove out HER VERY YOUNG KITS.
It's basically his fault Mapleshade became evil. - Pikafire

He literally sends three two-month kittens into the cold and rain for a crime they didn't commit.
He feels no remorse for this and it's extremely ironic that he exiles them and their mother for breaking the warrior code but, by exiling the three kittens, he himself broke the warrior code.

Oakstar sent attacks on kittypets in their gardens, he sent kits into the cold and rain for no reason, he helped to ruin Mapleshade!

Oakstar was his name? Oh...now I remember! - Pebblepaw

12 Gritclaw

Gritclaw had some dirty claws, in the end, he made people lick them, so he is bad, the end.

Umm... Who?!

OMG hahaha

Who now? - oceanbreezetheawesomewarrior

13 Shrewclaw

No, he was an ass in the beginning but was better in the end. - RoseWeasley

14 Squirrelflight

She never broke the warrior code. - Stormyblaze

I don't know why I voted-wait-she never killed anyone I'm dumb,so why,i she on here?

Who on earth put squirrelflight here!

What did she do! She never broke the code! This makes no sense

15 Firestar Firestar is a character in the Warrior Cats series. He's the leader of ThunderClan after Bluestar. He's mates with Sandstorm and has 2 kits: Squirrelflight and Leafpool. He was formerly a kittypet named Rusty.

This cat should definitely not go to the dark forest because he is a strong cat and proves himself that he will do anything to save his clan and always follows the warrior code and was the best clan leader.

I don't see why he should be on this list.

Why the heck is this here

I Hate That Sicko

16 Miststar

They say everyone (even the good people) on this list should be in the dark forest. Maybe they should try it out and stop being a narcissistic hypocrite.

Miststar took a taste of their medicine.

Not to be rude but I love however put them on this list. - cassiabez

Who is Miststar again? - Pebblepaw

Lel also true ):p jerk! What did Firestar or lionblaze do wrong?

17 Sleekwhisker

Yeah sleekwisker should be here - Duskstorm

18 Clear Sky

Clear Sky wanted what was best for his clan, and struggled as a leader. I don't agree with all of his decisions, but I think he is a pretty misunderstood cat. Grey Wing recognized this to the end. I am so glad Grey Wing followed his little brother because without him Clear Sky may have ended up with even more enemies. All leaders make mistakes.

Clear sky is such a boundary-obsessed idiot. If he didn’t love boundaries so much, he would be a pretty good leader. And, he should loath himself because of all the cats that he literally killed.-Shuddertail

Yes, yes, yes, yes - Pebblepaw

YAS. He deserves it. - Willow12

19 SpottedLeaf

I don't know how to comment without voting for her. But anyways- no. Minor stalking offenses aren't nearly as bad as those of some cats who got into StarClan.
Also, of COURSE she'd be weird around romantic feelings. She was a grooming and possibly csa victim. She was targeted by a hebephile while she was a brand new apprentice of course she'd get her wires crossed

She's a really annoying mary sue (at least to me she is) but I don't think she deserves it. - cassiabez

Spottedleaf is not a stalker! She dies a second time to save Sandstorm for Firestar! - Pebblepaw

MARY SUE ALERT... hate her..

20 Lionblaze Lionblaze is a character in the Warrior Cats series. He is part of The Three, along with Jayfeather and Dovewing, and has the power of being undefeated in battle. However, the power if removed from him after the Clans are saved from the Dark Forest.

He saved Firestar. - Stormyblaze

He has to many chapters. He's annoying

He killed russetfur and trained in the Dark forest. - Miststar


21 Ivypool

Really... She joined DF As a spy for her clan and you think she deserves this destiny

Another cat is on this list for silly reasons... - cassiabez

Yeah, what is going on now? - Pebblepaw


22 Lizardstripe

She could be the reason that Brokenstar turned out the way he did. He already had an unusual amount of hatred in him, but Lizardstripe nurtured that rage.

23 Foxheart

Foxheart was really annoying and I hate her. I know she probably dosen’t deserve to go to the Dark Forest but she was really cruel towards Yellowfang and I LOVE Yellowfang.


24 Dovewing Dovewing is a character in the Warriors series by Erin Hunter. She has light grey fur with Amber, green, or blue eyes. Her first appearance is in the fourth arc, know as Omen of the Stars, in the book The Fourth Apprentice. She was part of the Power of Three, and her power was to hear and see things ...read more.

I mean I don't like her but not so much that she needs to go to the DF. She didn't do anything like super terrible except betray her mate, but that happens in the Warrior world and in the human world

As much as I HATE dovewing, she shouldn't be in the dark forest - oceanbreezetheawesomewarrior

What did Dovewing do to you!?! - Pikafire

She dosen't deserve to go to the dark forest, she was in place of hollyleaf and she was really anoiying as a kit and paw but no. - SilverstarofIceclan

25 Graystripe

NEVER HE Is a warrior! Would YOU kill to save your family? MISTSTAR?! - sydneyhelget

Why is Graystripe on this list he killed Darkstripe and clawface to protect his clan


He killed darkstripe and clawface. if you kill 2 cats = should be straight to the dark forest for you. >:( - Miststar

26 Crowfeather

Why is he on this list he's GREAT I'm a GIRL and I like role-playing as him!
Dose NOT deserve to be in this list...

Hell naw! - rainshine

Crowfeather is an awful cat. he verbally abused his own son, only became mates with nightcloud so his clan would trust his sorry ass, and tried to put the blame on nightcloud when his actions were called out! he doesn't deserve to go to starclan. but also shouldn't go to the dark forest. I'm in the middle. he was a truly horrible dude, but not bad enough to go to d.f.

27 Clawface

Clawface DID kill Spottedleaf.. WITHOUT REGRET.

He's already in the Dark Forest, - Mellowix

28 Scourge

Scourge should have gone to the dark forest not for killing Tigerstar, he was evil, but for killing Whitestorm and trying to take over the forest he was just evil.

yea definitely

I'm really out! Scourge did not believe in StarClan, and therefor he couldn't believe in Dark Forest. - Pebblepaw

Scourge actually COULDN'T go to the Dark Forest. After he was killed, since he didn't believe in StarClan, Place Of No Stars and all that jazz, he just went 'poof'. And although Scourge was a menace to many cats, his siblings were the real cause of his evil. If it wasn't for Ruby, Scourge would still be a happy kittypet named Tiny. He doesn't deserve anything better or worse.

29 Silverstream SIlverstream is a character created by Erin Hunter to the book series named Warrior Cats. she is a sleek, silver tabby she-cat with delicate silver markings and bright blue eyes. She's the daughter of Crookedstar and Willowbreeze, former mate of Graystripe and mother of Feathertail and Stormfur. She ...read more.

Not Silverstream.
Her siblings and mother died when she's a kit - spottedleafpool

30 Bramblestar

He killed his brother to defend his clan and to avenge hollyleaf - Duskstorm

People, if u didn’t know, he killed hawkfrost to save firestar. Hawkfrost was planning to do something evil. So Bramblestar/claw had to stop him. So how is Bramblestar even on here?

He killed his brother, definitely deserves - spottedleafpool

31 Frecklewish
32 Perchpaw

Mapleshade was evil, though. - rainshine

Yeah, I agree! - oceanbreezetheawesomewarrior

The one who killed mapleshade. he murdered someone when they were seeking rightful justice! needs to go to the dark forest - Miststar


33 Heathertail

She still likes Lionblaze... AND ACTS LIKE HE MURDERED HER MOM. Jeez, Heathertail! What is done is done!

As much as I want to rip her throat out, gauge her eyes, and tear her heart, no ShE DoSeN't HaVe OnE, her organs and scatter her entrails all over the figgin place, no she she doesn't deserve to go to the dark forest. She would scare the pelt off Tigerstar himself! -Mapleshine of SunClan - sydneyhelget

She broke lionblaze heart..

She's like,100% innocent...why? - cassiabez

34 Millie Millie is a character in the Warriors series. She's a small, short-furred light gray tabby with blue eyes and a torn ear. Also current mate of Graystripe and mother of Bumblestripe, Blossomfall and Briarlight.

She rejected her blossomfall for no good reason. Even when blossomfall was missing, Millie turned her nose up at her - RavenHeart

Silverstream > millie

She is awful, but no. - sydneyhelget

HATE HATE HATE HATE HATE HATE HATE HER! I literally had a full-on debate with my friend and guess who won? ME. If you give my 10 reasons they will all be the same just rephrased!

35 Sandstorm

Why is she on here? She did nothing!

I think whoever made this is trying to mess with us. - rainshine

WHY IS SANDSTORM ON HERE? SHE WAS AMAZING - oceanbreezetheawesomewarrior

36 Dawnpelt

Well she got better in Vision of Shadows I suppose. - cassiabez

She had no proof that Jayfeather killed Flametail and she kept on prevoking border fights but... she's not evil.

37 Antpelt

Now remember Antpelt was first loyal to his clan, when he arrived at the dark forest he did not want to hurt the other cats training there, and just because a cat trains in the dark forest does not mean they are a bad cat. Many cats were tricked to turn away from their own clan. Thornclaw, blossemfall, and ivypool are just some cats that realized their mistake and ended up being loyal to their clan. If Tigerstar and the dark forest never existed antpelt would be a normal loyal clan cat.

This is a list for Starclan/living cats that need to go the Dark forest. Antpelt already went to the Dark Forest, after being killed by Thistleclaw. And is now faded away after Ivypool killed him in a training session. - Mellowix


38 Ravenwing


The medicine catbin Mapleshade’s vengeance? Yes, I agree - oceanbreezetheawesomewarrior


39 Mapleshade Mapleshade is a character in the Warriors series by Erin Hunter. She is a tortoiseshell she-cat with a white tail and mistakenly described as ginger-and-white.

Mapleshade had the right to kill those cats. She was sad and depressed, she had just watched her kits drown in a River! She should not be on this list! - oceanbreezetheawesomewarrior

She's already there - Pikafire

People really don't understand what this list is for... This is a list for Starclan/Living cats who deserve the Dark Forest. Mapleshade already there. If you think she's deserves to go the Starclan, I have an entire list for that. - Mellowix

40 Briarlight

I have so many questions!

She should not be on this list, she never did anything wrong! - oceanbreezetheawesomewarrior

41 Leopardstar

Teamed up with tigerstar and let the murder of her deputy. DARK FOREST FOR YOU! - Miststar

That was just a mistake doesn't means because of it she deserves it. - cassiabez

She didn't know Stonefur would be murdered. She regretted her decisions in her life and thought of Mistyfoot as her daughter. - Stormyblaze

42 Reedshine

One word: Pathetic

THANK YOU! Praise to whoever put this on here! Reedshine is WORSE then Dovewing! She was so annoying and was just all “Mapleshade, it doesn't matter if he used to be your mate, because he’s my mate now and i’m Not even gonna try to stop you killing him! ” I HATE REEDSHINE - oceanbreezetheawesomewarrior

43 Bloomheart
44 Hollystar

Hollystar killed Lilyheart, Squirrelstar And Puddleshine And is still alive under Cherrystar prison for no good reason.

45 Raggedstar

I have a HUGE problem with this list. this is bogus! All but like, three cats on here do NOT need to go to the dark forest! - rainshine

46 Nightcloud

I love nightcloud she cared for breezepelt even when crowfeather don't and in Crow feathers trial she protected breezepelt from the Stoats and almost died in the attempt she's a great cat with more personality then any cat in the series (apart from yellowfang)
She's a great cat! - Murphypaw

She made Crowfeathers life awful, and made Breezepelt mean! - sydneyhelget

HATE UU! - sydneyhelget

47 Willow Tail

From Dawn of the Clans. - Mellowix

48 Lambspring
49 Loudgorse

Killed Bobert in Raging Storm, will never forgive him!

50 Sheeptail

Killed cats for no reason, and ate their flesh and blood. Trained kittens. Very unknown, but she was a Brokenstar follower.

8Load More
PSearch List