Top 10 Worst Warrior Cat Leaders


The Top Ten

1 Brokenstar Brokenstar

He made kits apprentices when they are about 4 moons and made them warriors when they should just have became an apprentice, and why did you drive Yellowfang out?

I am very confused that on the worst warrior cats Tigerstar (tiger claw) came number one when Brokenstar came like 4th or something (not sue me on that)

He exiled elders and forced kits into battle. I don't think I need to say any more

1: I loved him as a kit
2: The fact that he's evil is Lizardstripe's fault
3: Yellowfang was just doing her duty
4: If he lived in Thunderclan as a kit, I'm sure he would have been good

V 4 Comments
2 Onestar Onestar

He was good before he became a leader. Well as far as we know. Turns out he doesn't care about his mates or kits, a liar, a danger to all the Clan and much more. He too scared that people make him look weak so he can't have any friends. Glad his son killed him. He was leader for way too long. I don't know who Harestar is, but I'm sure he'll be better than him. - Pebblepaw

I disagree with whoever hates One star. He was brave and honest and heroic. He was a great cat. I don't want to give any spoilers, but unless you read #3 Vision Of Shadows, you don't know his true amazing personality. He is my favourite character. - sunheart360

Sorry, I just really dislike him for challenging Tallstar and winning. That's all. - SpiritStar

Half the reasons why he’s on here is ‘cause he isn’t in the Firestar fan club.

V 4 Comments
3 Leopardstar

She was spoiled as a kit and I know this is a opinion but I found her VERY annoying, bossy, and arrogant as a leader

Oh come on Leopardstar was a strong leader and sadly underused character. What did she do wrong?!?

Hate her glad she died a stupid death of diabetes

4 Pinestar

Pinestar deserves to live with twolegs. How'd he ever become leader? - Pebblepaw

He left his son tigerkit/tigerclaw/tiger star, therefore he becomes evil not to mention he LEFT to become a KITTYPET

5 Sunstar

Why is he here? - IcetailofWishClan

6 Teller Of Pointed Stones

What! why is he on this list! he was great!

7 Tigerstar Tigerstar Tigerstar is a villain in the Warriors series by Erin Hunter. Son of Leopardfoot and Pinestar, former mate of Goldenflower and Sasha, and father of Bramblestar, Tawnypelt, Mothwing, Hawkfrost, and Tadpole. This brown tabby cat almost causes the downfall of the clans. But is killed, firstly by Scourge, more.

He was cruel, rude, and arrogant. I personally think that he should have been fed to the wolves!

I really like him, its just all the trouble he did that made him a bad leader. - SpiritStar

This cat should be the number 1 worst leader he is worse than Brokenstar.

Tigerstar should be #1-#6

V 3 Comments
8 Bramblestar Bramblestar

Though Graystripe should have been leader, I don't think Bramblestar is bad. I mean, he is awesome - Leafstar12

I have just never liked him that much... Don't hate me. - SpiritStar

Bossy, brought a bunch of kittypets when not food enough for the clan

Meh. Should've been Greystar

9 Clear Sky Clear Sky

He should be number one! I hate him and he's the worst. He's mean, makes a lot of cats kill each other then trys to make people feel bad for him. He's horrible to his son and his brother. He has too many mates and obviously to old for Star Flower because Thunder liked her. - Pebblepaw

It's clear sky - Jaywinglover

He's an idiot stupid and has an ugly personality and he has 3 girls I bet if star flower dies he will get another girl he is a saddo I don't like him he should be number 1

I HATE CLEAR SKY SO MUCH! why isn't he at the top of the list? One, he stole two of GRay Wing's loves, Bright Stream, and Storm, then his own son's love, Star Flower, and every cat just falls in love with him and he is so territorial and fights his brother and blames GRAYWING For Bright Streams death and makes a big deal only to love someone else, then disowns his son, TWICE!
And he was even worse in Moth Flight's vision and Thunderstar's echo, how is GRay Wing and THunderstar even related to him? My warrior cat crush is Thunderstar and Jayfeather!
Clear Sky can Clear Die in my opinion, NO ONE likes him, seriously!
and that, "I am never wrong." and "Micah's death was on HIM," scene in Moth Flight's vision made me wanna kill him, he makes amazing books, (ALl od dawn of the clans and Mothflight's vision and Thunderstar's echo) almost unbearable to re-read, he is a main character too, like HOW?
first leader of my second favorite clan
leader altogether
haves THREE (or ...more

V 1 Comment
10 Firestar Firestar Firestar is a character in the Warrior Cats series. He's the leader of ThunderClan after Bluestar. He's mates with Sandstorm and has 2 kits: Squirrelflight and Leafpool. He was formerly a kittypet named Rusty.

Firestar is the best! If you don't like him, you don't like Warriors. STOP READING WARRIORS IF YOU DISLIKE HIM MOUSE BRAINS! - Leafstar12

I think he was pretty good, mainly in the first series.

Why is he on here? - Pebblepaw

He sucks how the heck is he not number 1 henis the worst I love all of the leaders exept firestar

V 5 Comments

The Contenders

11 Scourge Scourge Scourge is a villain the Warrior Cats series . He's the leader of BloodClan . He was bullied by his siblings, Socks and Ruby, in the past because he was the smallest out of his kin . One of his most notable features is his collar of dog teeth .

I'm married to Scourge. -Horsestar of HorseClan - RedTheGremlin

Yep, you and the hundreds of other people! ~Mistyrain

12 Bluestar Bluestar Bluestar is a character in the Warrior Cats series. She one of the leaders of ThunderClan. She is mates with Oakheart of RiverClan and her kits, Stonefur and Mistyfoot, live in RiverClan

YES! Finally! I hate Bluestar! She was a terrible leader!


Honestly I love bluestar. she did go crazy in her last moons of her life but still

Sorry, Bluestar, but u r worst ever leader. still <3 u though. - Rosewhisker

V 1 Comment
13 Oakstar

He kicked out mapleshade just cause he wanted to! 😿
Thanks to him now mapleshade skits are dead

Oh I'm gunna kick out a QUEEN AND KILL HER KITS because I FEEL LIKE IT

He’s the reason for everything bad that happened in the entire series. Let me explain...

So he kicked out Mapleshade, a helpless queen, along with LITTLE TINY KITTENS, and they DIED. Like what else could’ve happened? He obviously knew they would die. This causes poor Mapleshade to go a little... insane. She did things to Crookedstar, killed a few Thunderclan cats, and pretty much ran the dark forest while Thistleclaw trained there. Thistleclaw was Tigerstar’s mentor, and we all know where that went. But back to Oakstar. He raised his son, Pinestar, to be the cat he was. Oakstar kind of just dumped all the stress of being leader on his young son. That made Pinestar leave for the easy life of a kittypet. That fueled Tigerstar’s rage and started a huge chain of terrible events that can all be traced back to Oakstar. In my opinion, he needs more votes on here.

14 Heatherstar

Heatherstar was wonderful. What are you talking about? - Pebblepaw

Heatherstar was a great leader - Leafstar12

15 Ripplestar (Shadowclan)

Really! he's all I wanna kill them just cause I'm evil! DUR

He's the one who got killed by StarClan. Ohhh! I wonder if he's in Dark Forest. - Pebblepaw

He's like


then he died and literally went to the dark forest

Therefore, he is a complete jerk.

16 Shadowstar

I love Shadowstar. Why is she on here? - Pebblepaw

Wait... Shadowstar? You mean like the first shadowclan leader? I'm sure he couldn't be really bad.

She is okay and by the way O

17 Raggedstar

He was so mean to Yellowfang

He should be higher!

Number 3 - Pebblepaw

18 Badgerstar
19 Nightstar

I mean really not letting cats go to gatherings? He was to old.

20 Darkstar (RiverClan)
21 Blackstar
22 Leafstar

Though she isn't the best name giver, she is still great - Leafstar12

She sucked at giving names. Harveymoon? BILLYSTORM? - RedTheGremlin

23 Mistystar Mistystar

I'm sick now. These list are getting crazy. I mean what did Mistysat ever do? - Pebblepaw


24 Featherstar

She made a cat deputy who was young,had no experience what's so ever and never had an apprentice.if you ask me she was to easy going and hardly ever stood up for her clan

25 Hailstar

He was a bit of an ass. " I want Reedfeather's kits back even though I gave them to WindClam. Oh, I know! We will attack them for no damn reason at all because I need to keep my rep of being an Ass as high as possible." GRRR

26 Breezestar
27 Graystar

He is not Turtle-tails kits father!

28 Darktail Darktail
29 Rowenstar

Darktail never would have taken over if Blackstar was in charge.

30 One Eye
BAdd New Item