Top Ten This or That Questions About Total Drama to Ask TopTenners


The Top Ten

1 Chris McLean or Blaineley Stacey Andrews O'Hallaram?

I'll give Mildred a chance because Chris is obviously screwed as a character. - Darellfat

Blaineley was supposed to be the host, but declined it. Chris is the current, vile, sadistic host. - Turkeyasylum

Chris, he will always be the total drama host. - Therandom

Chris. Mildred's annoying.

V 4 Comments
2 Sundae Muddy Sundae or The Final Wreck-ening?

Sundae Muddy Sundae good?! Worst episode in the history of Total Drama. I'll take the latter. - Darellfat

Both were good... But I would choose Sundae Muddy Sundae. - cosmo

The Final Wreck-ening is my choice.

V 3 Comments
3 Noah or Dawn?

Noah by far. He is so funny. Also, Dawn is seriously overrated. - alexcousins

I prefer Dawn. She is cooler and a bigger badass than Noah - BlueDiamondFromNowhere

Two funny, witty, and somewhat suspicious characters. Which is better? - Turkeyasylum

Noah. I'm a huge fan of Dawn, but Noah's better in my opinion

V 5 Comments
4 First Generation Cast or Second/Third Generation Cast?

First generation will always be special, they are the reason I fell in love with the show, but at the same time I'm so glad we have the new characters as well. So this is a hard question! I'm neutral.

The second generation cast is by far the best, although I love them all, this cast has a spunk about them that the other ones lack.

So many good moments with the first generation cast. They win by a landslide for me. - Wolftail


V 4 Comments
5 Katie or Sadie?

Sadie even when their together Sadie just seemed smarter and she did outlast Katie. But I have a theory on why that happened. - Darellfat

Katie. Throughout her time on the show, she was good to watch. - Wolftail

The ultimate question: Which is better by themselves? - Turkeyasylum

Katie! She is prettiest girl on the show!

V 2 Comments
6 Riconculous Race or Total Drama Island?

Total Drama Island, the drama was real. A realistic antagonist. Realistic stereotypes. You just can't beat it. The only problem you can say they had was some eliminations that weren't well explained. - Darellfat

Total drama Island is better because it is fun and exciting, while Ridonculous Race is one long race boringg.

Total Drama Island. Can't wait for the Ridonculous Race, though! Some characters who didn't compete in TDAS will be in the Ridonculous Race; that's why they weren't chosen to compete in TDAS. - Wolftail

V 4 Comments
7 Painful Challenges or Embarrassing Challenges?

I don't know which one. They're both good. - cosmo

Embarrassing. I hate seeing the characters in pain

Embarrassing, most of them are painful. - Therandom


V 2 Comments
8 Duncney or Gwuncan?

Duncney, Because they are the cutest couple ever, while Gwuncan is like watching siblings make out. It makes you sick to your stomach, bro.

Duncney. I got butterflies the first the they kissed! It was so sweet. You can't beat it.

Duncney! He and Gwen are too alike to be together!

Duncney, by far!

V 8 Comments
9 Lindsay or Leshawna?

Gotta take the dumb blonde. One of the few characters to go above and beyond her stereotype. - Darellfat

I love Lindsay! She's an amazing character and so funny to watch! - Wolftail

Lindsay! Leshawna's stereotype is offensive.

Both provide excellent humor, but who is funnier? - Turkeyasylum

V 2 Comments
10 Hurl of Shame or Dock of Shame?

One elimination system is painful physically, the other is painful emotionally. - Turkeyasylum

Dock of shame for sure. Hurl of shame is cruel and life threatening.

Dock of shame. Hurl of shame is cruel.

V 2 Comments

The Contenders

11 TDAS or TDRI?

TDRI. Only good thing about TDAS was Mike and Zoey, and the fact that Duncan still has feelings for Courtney.

TDRI. Never will I like that disgrace known AS. - Darellfat

TDRI, that had Brick, Dawn. B and Scott...
But in the monstrosity named TDAS has SAM?! DUNCAN?! GWEN!?
Has Duncan and Gwen Been in enough seasons? - DapperPickle


12 Lindsay or Bridgette?

Bridgette, because she is a lot nicer and down to earth.

V 2 Comments
13 Jo or Eva?

Ever, she is the original jockette.

V 2 Comments
14 Dave and Staci becoming a couple or Courtney and Trent?

Dave and Staci because they are both annoying.

Courtney and Trent would make a cuter couple!

V 1 Comment
15 Devin or Carrie?

I like Carrie, she's so cool!


16 Amy or Samey?

Sammy is better than Amy - Yona_db


17 Owen or Max?

Max. As much as I love the original, he's funnier than Owen.

18 Chris McLean or Don?

Don by a longshot. Chris is just cruel to his contestants and actually loves to see them suffer. I hope Chris can finally come out of his shell next season. That's why Don is a lot cooler than him. He never turned a island into a dump and never made his contestants go feral. He even cares for his contestants and loves winners (as seen in Hawaiian Honeyruin).

Yah, don wins by a landslide. He's not as sadistic and cares much more.

19 Drop of shame or cannon of shame?


20 Cameron or Cody?

Cameron, because he is nicer to Sierra.

V 2 Comments
21 Ella or Courtney?

Courtney! You can't replace Courtney.

V 1 Comment
22 Beardo or Trent?

Trent of course!

I pick Beardo - Yona_db

23 Ellody or Mary?


24 Dawn dating Scott or Devin dating Carrie?

Devin and Carrie, of course! They are really sweet together, why pair Scott with Dawn they don't like each other; Scott's too much of a jerk.

V 2 Comments
25 Kitty or Emma?

Kitty. She's adorable!

26 Taylor or Courtney?

Taylor. I HATE Courtney!

They look like they could be sisters!

27 Crimson or Mike for season 6?


28 Miles marrying Harold, or Dakota marrying Max?

I don't ship either, but Harold and Miles go better together.

Miles + Harold = cuteness overload.

V 1 Comment
29 Seeing Top Her Take His Clothes Off, or Rodney Taking His Off?


30 Seeing Zoey In Skimpy Lingerie, or Seeing Jo Dance In a Towel?


31 Would you rather hook up with Tyler or Lightning?

Tyler because he is cuter and has a better attitude.

Tyler. He's a lot nicer, and he'd be able to tell I'm a girl.

32 Who's hotter, Justin or Alejandro?

Alejandro all the way!

33 Sisters or Police Cadets

The Sisters by far. Sure the Police Cadets were good but can get overrated at times. For the sisters team, they had a storyline, good development, and we get to know them both pretty well.

34 Fashion Bloggers or Ice Dancers?

Fashion Bloggers are better than those infamous and devastating Ice Losers.

35 New contestants or past contestants for season 6

They definitely won't be new contestants competing now that TDPI cast just got introduced. Some TDI contestants are coming back with other contestants yet to be announced.

36 Amy or Taylor?

Taylor gets my vote. She seemed unique for a stuck-up girl. Amy on the other hand is nothing but "Nega Samey".

37 Courtney in a relationship or Courtney remains single?

Courtney should just remain single after having to put so much drama. Maybe if she returns, she should never hook up with a man again. I mean not all ladies of TD need to go all "lovely dovely" over a man like her.

38 Cartoon comedy or dramatic scenes?

Dramatic scenes wins by a longshot. The show is called Total DRAMA, not Total COMEDY.

39 Any contestant that competed before or a brand new contestants cast?

Any contestant that competed before. Most of TD's three generations haven't wrapped up their plot arcs yet.

40 To see an old couple breaking up or a new one being formed?

Neither because both can lead to derailment and bad/rushed plotlines.

41 New location or at an already known one?

A new location would be fine.

42 Non-eliminations or team swaps?

I don't mind the non-elimination episodes of the series. One of my favorite aspects of "Total Drama" is the character development, and having characters that everyone likes can continue to develop. It's much more interesting than having them leave prematurely. Team swaps are okay though.

43 Fodders having a plot or screen-hoggers being fodder?

Screen-hoggers being fodder. I wanna see how screen-hoggers like Duncan would react if they were the first contestant voted off.

44 To see contestant's relatives as cameos or competing?

Depends on which one we're talking about.

45 A 3-way finale or the classic 2-way ones?

3-way finale gets my answer. It allows more interactions in the finale and more competing screen-time for someone.

46 Christmas themed TD special or an easter one?

Fresh should plan a TD Christmas special, kind of like what they did with 6teen.

47 To have another spin-off. or continue the already begun ones?

RR has just began and we, the fans of this show, really want the Ridonculous Race to continue. The show still has plenty of more teams that the IRL TD staff can create and brainstorm on their own (lifeguards, punks, etc), and lots of new destinations that Don can send the racers to (the Galapagos Islands, Tokyo, London, Los Angeles, etc). I also want new gameplay elements as well. Another spin-off is a "no thanks" for me. I rather have RR continue instead of another spin-off.

PSearch List

Recommended Lists

Related Lists

Top Ten This or That Questions About the Simpsons to Ask TopTenners Top Ten This or That Questions About Superhero Logos to Ask TopTenners Top Ten This or That Questions to Ask People This or That Questions to Ask About Which Team is Better In a City Top Ten Questions to Ask Guests When They Visit This Site

List Stats

47 listings
2 years, 364 days old

Top Remixes

1. Chris McLean or Blaineley Stacey Andrews O'Hallaram?
2. Noah or Dawn?
3. Sundae Muddy Sundae or The Final Wreck-ening?
1. Chris McLean or Blaineley Stacey Andrews O'Hallaram?
2. Sundae Muddy Sundae or The Final Wreck-ening?
3. Noah or Dawn?


Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.