Most Overrated Total Drama Characters

The Top Ten

1 Duncan

I hate how everyone blames Gwen for stealing Courtney's boyfriend when she acutally tried to avoid a relationship at first, Duncan is the one who started, he just entered into the confessional and kissed her but nobody cares. Also, Duncney is trash. - DaisyandRosalina

Duncan used to be the best character during season 1 and 2, but he changed during season 3 and he became worse in season 5

Duncan even sucks in TDI in my opinion.

This screen hog needs to go. - Synchronocity

2 Cody

The only reason why he is remotely interesting and made the top 3 in World Tour is because of Sierra, without her he is just a perverted punching bag. - DaisyandRosalina

This guy is treated like a god for making it far in World Tour. He did nothing to make it that far! He just floated there, because Sierra protected him. And then, when Sierra was eliminated, Cody flopped, and couldn't do anything, leading to his eliminated.

Agreed. His fanbase which I call "Sierras", droll over him for nothing. - Turkeyasylum


3 Zoey

I find her annoying and defiantly overrated - Spongehouse

4 Noah

No originality of any kind, just a sarcastic guy in a series where a lot of other characters have this trait. He is only funny because other characters around him make him behave on a specific way, he is not naturally hilarious like Owen or Izzy. Ridonculous Race was the only season where he acutally did something but his relationship with Emma was basically Sky x Dave: good ending edition. - DaisyandRosalina

Some people watch Total drama Ridonculos Race only for him!

Super underrated in TDI but super overrated in TDWT and RR

5 Courtney

I don't understand how she has so many fans. She drives me insane! - Spongehouse

She was tolerable in season 1...


6 Mike

He should be much higher. I think I am the only person who doesn't like him - Spongehouse

Zoey is just better, sure she was bland in All-stars but Mike was so unrealistic with the whole Mike thing. - DaisyandRosalina

Why did you mess up courtneys life?


7 Ella

Heck yeah she is! - Spongehouse

8 Gwen

She is so overrated, almost about as overrated as Duncan in my opinion - Spongehouse

Gwen is very overrated, I tried to like her but I just couldn’t.

9 Alejandro
10 Heather

The Contenders

11 Scott
12 Beardo

Seriously what did this guy do?! at least
EVERY other member on the team except him did something

13 Shawn

Sky cheated on her boyfriend she was supposed to dump before Pahkitew and "manipulated" Dave because he refused to help her after Chris did a mess but Shawn, who refused to listen and lied to his girlfriend and made fun of her dream gets a pass? That's just as wrong as Sky's situation. - DaisyandRosalina

14 Owen

Attention seeker, he gets most of the spotlight on every season he appears in, I love him but still. - DaisyandRosalina

15 Ezekiel

Don't understand how you can consider him overrated because he lost so many fans in world tour

How is he overrated exactly? - Spongehouse

Actually, the list was supposed to be called most underrated total drama characters. but I misspelled the name and I wrote ''overrated'' instead. - Yona_db

16 Staci

She is extremely overhated in my opinion not overrated - Spongehouse

17 Samey Samantha "Samey"/"Sammy" was a contestant on Total Drama: Pahkitew Island as a member of the Pimâpotew Kinosewak.

I'm sorry, but Beth did her rise-up-from-the-oppressor storyline before and better. Samey did nothing but complain about how she was in her sister's shadow and would have done nothing if Jasmine didn't intervene. Also, sorry, but causing your sister to nearly suffocate does not make you the good twin, no matter how much she abused you.

"Beth did her rise-up-from-the-oppressor storyline before and better." Eh, this is questionable. - DaisyandRosalina

How is it questionable? Beth came to the idea of standing up for herself on her own (see Paintball Deer Hunter). Only after Beth's open defiance, where she stood her ground without giving an inch, did she earn the aid and respect of Leshawna. In fact, had Beth not been cursed the episode prior, it might have been Heather who would have been eliminated after the cooking challenge instead. This only progressed in Action, where Beth not only outlasted Heather this time around, but also outlasted Courtney, who attempted to do the same as Heather. She made it to the TDA finals through sheer willpower and principle. Sure, she fell for Justin's looks for a while, but was there any girl in TDI that didn't?

Now let's look at Samey. If not for Jasmine putting the idea into her head, Samey would have done absolutely nothing. How did she rebel? By secretly and knowingly poisoning Amy with berries that caused her airways to swell, which could have potentially killed her. That's something ...more

18 Sugar
19 Katie and Sadie

How are they overrated? In fact, they are the most underrated characters on the show. They hopefully will return soon.

20 Dawn

She is mostly popular for the whole "weird kinda emo cutie girl" she didn't do much. Yes she is interesting but there are better written characters. - DaisyandRosalina

People think she is underrated. that is the only reason they like her and they made her overrated

Dawn was in like 6 episodes, but is one of the most popular characters.

Should be #1

21 Lightning
22 Topher
23 Jacques
24 Tyler
25 Amy

She's underrated! Only because you hate her doesn't mean that she's overrated!

26 Justin
27 Ann Maria

In what way?

28 Jo
29 Eva
30 Cameron
31 Mr. Coconut

He is JUST a coconut! I have no idea why this sorry excuse of a character has so many fans

More overrated than Shawn, Dawn, Duncan, Cody, and Beardo combined! And thar's saying something... - Turkeyasylum

32 Izzy
33 Sierra
34 Leshawna

She's not overrated.

35 Beth

She should be higher on this list! Nobody wanted her as a finalist! They wanted Lindsay! Not to mention how ugly she is...

She’s not overrated!

36 Scarlett
37 Dave
38 Lindsay
BAdd New Item